What a lovely little cocktail bar in Upper Westside! The moment you walk in you begin to feel happy vibes. From the person greeting you at the front desk to the server - everyone meets and greets you with such wonderful energy! ❤️ To add to that, the cocktails are just fantastic. We tried a few and loved all of them. Our server JOHN was so wonderful too. He made sure we got exactly what we wanted. Thank you! It’s important that everything about a place is lovely… Owl’s tail gets all of it right! Will definitely be back!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Karen R.
Drinks were excellent, and we highly enjoyed the meatballs! The shrimp dumplings were a bit underwhelming, especially for the price.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Elaine Kelly
Love this spot! Went there before a show at the Beacon Theater.It was the perfect spot for my friends and I to grab a bite and have a cocktail. We had a cute little booth in the back. You felt as though you were sitting in your living room. I'm going back there on Saturday before my next concert. Highly recommended.Vegetarian options: Spiced nuts and bruchetta pompadoro.
Stopped buying for a couple of cocktails. They were all
Atmosphere: 5
Service: 5
Andrey Kiyanitsa
Lighting and ambience is chill. Cocktails are some of the best I’ve had. Glassware is beautiful.
Atmosphere: 5
Service: 5
Adam Lowe
By far the best cocktail bar in the area. John was a great server. Very knowledgeable and hospitable. Highlights were the the cigars on ice and the barrel aged manhattan.
Service: 5
Emma
very pretty space, kind and accommodating staff, quick and friendly service! i had the winter break cocktail and it rocked my world
Samuel Long
Worst hostess EVER. Never met a more rude woman, ever. Don't go.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Ed Peterson
Visited the Owl Tavern recently, and I must say, their Whistle Pig Manhattan is nothing short of amazing—a true highlight for any cocktail aficionado. The deviled eggs were another standout, delightfully delicious and a must-try. However, the rest of the menu didn’t quite hit the mark for me, with dishes that felt a bit underwhelming, avoid the shrimp dumplings,and overpriced. But it’s not all about the food; the service was fabulous, with a waitstaff that’s attentive, efficient, and genuinely makes your experience better. If you’re in for a great drink and some light bites, this place won’t disappoint, but for a full meal, you might want to manage your expectations.
I stopped for an hour or so for a couple of drinks alone, after a long walk in Central Park. I took a seat in the heated outdoor area, where it was very comfortable despite the freezing temperatures outside. I had a New York Sour (the best I've ever had) and a drink from their signature list, again bourbon-based. Both excellent, as is the welcome and a series of measures in the service (example: welcome glass of water, constantly refilled) that make you feel pampered. If I were to return I will also try the kitchen because my neighbors at the table were served very appetizing dishes.
Atmosphere: 5
Service: 5
Samantha McLeod
Super cute place with some great cocktails and drinks. Small bites available as well. Very cozy atmosphere.
Neesh Shah
It was a very cold Saturday night and we were looking for a place to grab drinks before a late dinner reservation. The hostess was very nice and was able to squeeze our group of five in, without a reservation. We're so glad that worked out because everything we drank was phenomenal."Owl's Gone Fishing," "She's a scorpio," "Dracarys," "Sweater Weather," A Warm Hug," "The Freshmaker" and then some delicious dealer's choice shots that went down very easily.Cool vibes, great drinks, make sure you stop by if you're near!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Luis Pertuz
Laura the hostess is awesome. She makes being at The Owl's Tail fun.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
James Messing
Really innovative (and delicious) cocktails! Things I wouldn’t try normally but really glad that I did. Smoke & Mirrors was my favorite drink that I had. John was an amazing server and incredibly friendly!
What a lovely little cocktail bar in Upper Westside! The moment you walk in you begin to feel happy vibes. From the person greeting you at the front desk to the server - everyone meets and greets you with such wonderful energy! ❤️ To add to that, the cocktails are just fantastic. We tried a few and loved all of them. Our server JOHN was so wonderful too. He made sure we got exactly what we wanted. Thank you! It’s important that everything about a place is lovely… Owl’s tail gets all of it right! Will definitely be back!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Drinks were excellent, and we highly enjoyed the meatballs! The shrimp dumplings were a bit underwhelming, especially for the price.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Love this spot! Went there before a show at the Beacon Theater.It was the perfect spot for my friends and I to grab a bite and have a cocktail. We had a cute little booth in the back. You felt as though you were sitting in your living room. I'm going back there on Saturday before my next concert. Highly recommended.Vegetarian options: Spiced nuts and bruchetta pompadoro.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Spiced Nuts, Bruschetta Pomodoro, Meatballs, Deviled Eggs 3-Way, Charcuterie
Stopped buying for a couple of cocktails. They were all
Atmosphere: 5
Service: 5
Lighting and ambience is chill. Cocktails are some of the best I’ve had. Glassware is beautiful.
Atmosphere: 5
Service: 5
By far the best cocktail bar in the area. John was a great server. Very knowledgeable and hospitable. Highlights were the the cigars on ice and the barrel aged manhattan.
Service: 5
very pretty space, kind and accommodating staff, quick and friendly service! i had the winter break cocktail and it rocked my world
Worst hostess EVER. Never met a more rude woman, ever. Don't go.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Visited the Owl Tavern recently, and I must say, their Whistle Pig Manhattan is nothing short of amazing—a true highlight for any cocktail aficionado. The deviled eggs were another standout, delightfully delicious and a must-try. However, the rest of the menu didn’t quite hit the mark for me, with dishes that felt a bit underwhelming, avoid the shrimp dumplings,and overpriced. But it’s not all about the food; the service was fabulous, with a waitstaff that’s attentive, efficient, and genuinely makes your experience better. If you’re in for a great drink and some light bites, this place won’t disappoint, but for a full meal, you might want to manage your expectations.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 3
Service: 5
Cocktails are delicious! Service is
Atmosphere: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
I stopped for an hour or so for a couple of drinks alone, after a long walk in Central Park. I took a seat in the heated outdoor area, where it was very comfortable despite the freezing temperatures outside. I had a New York Sour (the best I've ever had) and a drink from their signature list, again bourbon-based. Both excellent, as is the welcome and a series of measures in the service (example: welcome glass of water, constantly refilled) that make you feel pampered. If I were to return I will also try the kitchen because my neighbors at the table were served very appetizing dishes.
Atmosphere: 5
Service: 5
Super cute place with some great cocktails and drinks. Small bites available as well. Very cozy atmosphere.
It was a very cold Saturday night and we were looking for a place to grab drinks before a late dinner reservation. The hostess was very nice and was able to squeeze our group of five in, without a reservation. We're so glad that worked out because everything we drank was phenomenal."Owl's Gone Fishing," "She's a scorpio," "Dracarys," "Sweater Weather," A Warm Hug," "The Freshmaker" and then some delicious dealer's choice shots that went down very easily.Cool vibes, great drinks, make sure you stop by if you're near!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Laura the hostess is awesome. She makes being at The Owl's Tail fun.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Really innovative (and delicious) cocktails! Things I wouldn’t try normally but really glad that I did. Smoke & Mirrors was my favorite drink that I had. John was an amazing server and incredibly friendly!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5