The Pie Guy Pizza

83-85 Baxter St, New York
(646) 895-9507

Recent Reviews Order Online

Customers' Favorites

Signature Spicy Rigatoni Pizza Slice
Pepperoni and Vodka Sauce Slices
Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza Slice
Classic White Pizza Slice
Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza
The Classic Pizza Slice
Vodka Sauce Pizza Slice
Margherita Pizza Slice
Meat Lovers Pizza Slice
Pepperoni Pizza Slice

Menu

Menu for Baxter Street Pizza
The Classic Pizza
Classic New York pizza style with whole milk mozzarella and our classic tomato-basil sauce.
Classic White Pie Pizza
Extra mozzarella cheese topped with whole milk ricotta, hints of caramelized onions, finished with pecorino romano cheese.
Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza
Mushroom Pizza
Classic NY-style pizza with mushroom topping.
Margherita Pizza
Homemade mozzarella and chunky tomato sauce with fresh herbs, a touch of Tuscan olive oil finished with fresh basil.
Grandma Pizza
Homemade mozzarella, crushed tomatoes, basil, fresh garlic, authentic pecorino romano, and extra virgin olive oil.
Italian Sausage Pizza
Classic NY-style pizza topped with crumbled Italian style sausage.
Meat Lovers Pizza
Classic NY-style pizza topped with our spicy pepperoni, crumbled Italian sausage, and bacon.
Signature Spicy Rigatoni Pizza
Our delicious homemade vodka sauce is finished with Calabrian chili, fresh mozzarella, and baked rigatoni.
Pepperoni Pizza
Classic NY-style pizza topped with spicy pepperoni.
Vodka Sauce Pizza
Our delicious homemade light red cream sauce with sauteed prosciutto di parma and vodka with fresh mozzarella.
Garlic Knots
6 Knots

Slices
The Classic Pizza Slice
Classic New York pizza style with whole milk mozzarella and our classic tomato-basil sauce.
Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza Slice
Signature Spicy Rigatoni Pizza Slice
Margherita Pizza Slice
Homemade mozzarella and chunky tomato sauce with fresh herbs, a touch of Tuscan olive oil finished with fresh basil.
Meat Lovers Pizza Slice
Classic NY-style pizza topped with our spicy pepperoni, crumbled Italian sausage, and bacon.
Classic White Pizza Slice
Extra mozzarella cheese topped with whole milk ricotta, hints of caramelized onions, finished with pecorino romano cheese.
Vodka Sauce Pizza Slice
Our delicious homemade light red cream sauce with sauteed prosciutto di parma and vodka with fresh mozzarella.
Mushroom Pizza Slice
Classic NY-style pizza with mushroom topping.
Pepperoni Pizza Slice
Classic NY-style pizza topped with spicy pepperoni.
Grandma slice
Homemade mozzarella, crushed tomatoes, basil, fresh garlic, authentic pecorino romano, and extra virgin olive oil.
Italian sausage pizza slice
Classic NY-style pizza topped with crumbled Italian style sausage.

Drinks
Coke
Can of Coke
Sprite
Sprite Can
Diet Coke
Diet Coke Can
Gingerale
Gingerale Can

Photos

Photo credit: google
Photo credit: google
Photo credit: google
+26 photos
Photo credit: google
+25 photos
Add a photo

Recent Reviews

Walked in & ordered a margarita pie for take out. Pie Guy guy says “gimme 15 minutes”. No problemo. In the meantime I observe the slice window & everything looks copacetic (except the fried chicken rolls looked pretty tired).

12 minutes later I get the “Hey Buddy”. $26 & a $3 tip later I’m on my way. Open the box at home & have a still warm slice. The sauce is delicious & the crust has an excellent flavor (properly proofed). I guess...
November 2024
Tucked away at 83-85 Baxter St, New York, The Pie Guy Pizza might be small, but it serves big flavors and generosity. This is more than just a pizza place—it's where neighbors gather, friendships are made, and every slice is served with a heaping side of kindness.
October 2024
Found on ai. Told server of ai and great reviews. He said don't frust reviews, judge after eating. Picture of kim Kardashian on wall. We asked, she ate here? He said, no. It was at another pie guy store, but added, "Trump bought pizza from here." I asked you talked to him? He said, "no." He sent his secret service agents.
Pizza is great, I am new Yorker, raised in little italy.
June 2024

More Reviews

You May Also Like

Pasteur Grill & Noodles - 85 Baxter St
Vietnamese, Noodles, Vegan
Baxter Street Pizza - 83 Baxter St
Pizza
Sugarcane Daddy - 87 Baxter St
Juice, Juice Bar & Smoothies

The Pie Guy Pizza

83-85 Baxter St, New York, NY 10013
(646) 895-9507