Sefton

1373 1st Ave., New York
(212) 812-8942

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Madison Maxwell

Amazing cocktails! Stopped by for a quick drink, started outside, and then moved inside once there was a table available. Great service and environment.

Atmosphere: 5

Service: 5

Lyndsey Lange

Amazing BLT! Bacon perfectly cooked and spicy mayo - so good. Lunch special with a drink -$15. Great music too!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

A A

Excellent cocktails. Excellent service.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 5

Trish Moran

Great food, gorgeous drinks, fun atmosphere. Pornstar martini was top notch, spicy tuna with crispy rice starter is so tasty. Burger and chicken sandwich for main did not disappoint.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Hannah Puig-Holzman

Bar tender was exceedingly rude. Was with my friend and she really needed something to eat. Said the kitchen was closed and then brought out food to the people sitting next to us. Horrible service. Unfortunate because it’s a cute place.

Joseph Kiper

Avoid this place, Slow service, our drinks were all mixer, only after we mentioned something and were told they are correct did they come out later and apologize that the gun was only dispensing syrup. We were told they were on the house and brought one replacement for two drinks instead of the two we ordered and they charged us for two anyways. The hamburger was rubbish but the beef tacos were very good. Also, without telling us they had put a high gratuity on the check.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 2

Service: 3

Sucheen Sundaram

Bought two drinks from this establishment. I tried to eat a small snack not purchased at the establishment and was chastised for it. I understand the “no outside food”, but I was humiliated and disrespected by the staff of the place. Will not be returning

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 1

Service: 1

Nando Banquez

A great spot for a Sunday brunch. The food is excellent and the drink as well. Excellent service 100% recommended

Isabel Campbell

Wanted to try a new bar in our neighborhood and got super lucky scoring an outside table! Had a Hugo spritz which was perfect and their BLAT salad. Great service and vibe! Will be back

David

Probably going to be our new go-to spot. Great vibe, food was great for what it is, and the cocktails were very generous 😊

Elliot Rogers

Good Guinness will be back 👍🏼

Ben Hertzfeld

Easily the best bar in UES. Great bartenders, delicious food & cocktails, proper whisky / beer selection all neatly put together in an amazing atmosphere w comfortable seating. We started going for the lunch specials but ended up hanging w evening crowd. Local gem

Yianni Glavas

Had a few beers and margaritas. Wife had some non alcoholic beverage. Decent spot. Can get a bit loud

Gabriele Fusi

Had a good time! Very fast service and solid Old Fashion cocktail 🍸

Jackie Giammara

Bartender was rude, acted really inconvenienced by my friend asking for the music to be turned down. We couldn’t get service to order food until we moved to a table. Sandwiches were open faced without saying so on the menu and total bill didn’t include a 2.7% processing fee. Food and drinks aren’t cheap so this is really a poor look. Charge whatever you have to for the complete experience and work on the customer service.

Loading...