I’m from Iowa and this place is amazing. I’ve been through many places in NYC with a similar background and style and this place is the best. The atmosphere at a minimum is 6 stars and the service was even better. The food topped it all with the cherry on top. Our server was amazing and helped our larger group out perfectly. Food is slightly on the higher end of expense but you get exactly if not better than what you pay for. 100% worth it and 100% reccomend.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Gabriel Carral
Genuinely such a great spot to eat on a semi regular basis. Been here multiple times and the food is always enjoyable and more importantly it tastes fresh. Another awesome thing about this location is that the meals all taste just as good as they look! The fries really are that crispy, the salad really is that balanced, and both the entrees really are the star of the show. I would have liked to see the waiter be more approachable and attentive but he’s also the only one so it’s understandable! Last thing is that it is pretty hot in here. I’m not sure if the AC was down, but New York heat mixed with hot served food would really benefit from having a cooler environment.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Bethany Breton
Been our staple for 10 years now. Never fails to hit the spot - due to the variety of the menu Toast fits every mood! Service/servers are kind, attentive, and personable.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jeffrey Rosario
I usually come by for Buffalo Wings & other foods and I must say HUGE Shoutout to Ruth (Waitress) & the manager ( older guy with glasses ) I should remember his name lol, but let me let everyone know! These 2 give amazing service!! from the manager he always fixes any little mistakes or issues, always on point with customers and restaurant overall!! & Ruth always greeting and getting the right orders and delivering safe and delicious foods! Love Toast and I will continue to come and enjoy it!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Franklyn Mendez
Visited Toast 125 at 3157 Broadway for the second time. Overall, it's a nice spot with a good vibe. The Mexican burger was solid; juicy and flavorful; but like most of the menu, priced on the higher side. Then again, that's consistent with the restaurant's overall pricing.
The ambiance was pleasant; low-level music playing boleros and other Spanish classics really set a cozy, relaxed mood. We checked out the special lunch prices, but honestly, they didn't make much sense to us. We ended up ordering from the regular entrée menu, which felt like a better value.
One thing that caught our attention was the drink pricing; beer was only $2 more than a soda, so it felt like a better deal than paying high for soft drinks.
Service-wise, this is where they dropped the ball. It took quite a while to get our appetizers, and after that, we barely got any attention from the staff. That part of the experience really stood out in a negative way.
Overall, good food and ambiance, but the service needs serious improvement.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 2
Beret Loncar
This is our go to with kids, even though it’s great as a pub as well. During old people dinner it’s super laid back and no one cares if your toddler is annoying (other than you). Nothing flash, just a solid regular . At night it has sports and a pub feel.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 4
Kimena Castellanos
Food is always good here and they serve all day breakfast options. I had the french toast and I love the strawberry butter it comes with. I also love the mac and cheese.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
mischa gushiken
Really nice atmosphere. Great service. Great food. Easy to talk, music a little bit lower would be nice but yeah very nice place thank you. What a classy burger
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Joshua Perez Leduc
One of the best Cuban sandwiches I’ve ever had. Also you get your money’s worth. It’s amazing. Service was great, lunch was busy so it lagged but very friendly and the food came fast. Will be coming back asap
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 4
Darin May
Bringing the bill before it being asked for sends the message "it's fine for you to go" despite wanting more dink or food.
We weren't making noise, just talking in a normal volume. Just finished our meal and my first wanted another drink. Well the bill came before he asked for a 2nd drink.
So we left.
Also, watch the tables. If you see empty water glasses, refill them. Empty drink glasses? Ask if we want another drink.
This place is amazing the service was great. The waiter would be nearby and ready to answer any questions that I had about the food. The interior was so elegant it felt like an indoor picnic the exterior makes the place look like a ghost and you would never expect something like that to be there. I blame myself for choosing the wrong food, but everything else was worth.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 3
Service: 5
Nicole Louie
Came to toast for dinner and got the fish sandwich. It was pretty tasty and definitely big enough that I took home half for the next day
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Benjamin Shanblatt
The food and the service is exceptional. My wife and I love coming here and make it a point to have dinner here when we’re in the neighborhood. They have amazing happy hour options. We’ve tried most things from the menu and they’re all fantastic. Strongly recommended
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jody Fish
Very misleading - sign says $10 burger and beer, which seems too good to be true. Turns out it was! We were explained AFTER our check arrived that it’s a $10 burger if you buy a beer. The server admitted it was misleading but did nothing to rectify the situation. I even ordered by saying, “We’re going to have the $10 burger and beer!” As someone who works in the industry I find this incredibly sketchy and I will definitely not be back.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Damian Purdue
Saw flies in the kitchen, they got half of our orders wrong, when they came back with the “fixed” plates, they were completely unchanged, the servers were rude and even cursed as we spoke to them, had to ask multiple times for just two cups of water, and then again for straws, and this was overall a horrendous experience. They also have almost none of the items as they do online. Never coming back
I’m from Iowa and this place is amazing. I’ve been through many places in NYC with a similar background and style and this place is the best. The atmosphere at a minimum is 6 stars and the service was even better. The food topped it all with the cherry on top. Our server was amazing and helped our larger group out perfectly. Food is slightly on the higher end of expense but you get exactly if not better than what you pay for. 100% worth it and 100% reccomend.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Genuinely such a great spot to eat on a semi regular basis. Been here multiple times and the food is always enjoyable and more importantly it tastes fresh. Another awesome thing about this location is that the meals all taste just as good as they look! The fries really are that crispy, the salad really is that balanced, and both the entrees really are the star of the show.
I would have liked to see the waiter be more approachable and attentive but he’s also the only one so it’s understandable!
Last thing is that it is pretty hot in here. I’m not sure if the AC was down, but New York heat mixed with hot served food would really benefit from having a cooler environment.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Been our staple for 10 years now. Never fails to hit the spot - due to the variety of the menu Toast fits every mood! Service/servers are kind, attentive, and personable.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I usually come by for Buffalo Wings & other foods and I must say HUGE Shoutout to Ruth (Waitress) & the manager ( older guy with glasses ) I should remember his name lol, but let me let everyone know! These 2 give amazing service!! from the manager he always fixes any little mistakes or issues, always on point with customers and restaurant overall!! & Ruth always greeting and getting the right orders and delivering safe and delicious foods! Love Toast and I will continue to come and enjoy it!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Visited Toast 125 at 3157 Broadway for the second time. Overall, it's a nice spot with a good vibe. The Mexican burger was solid; juicy and flavorful; but like most of the menu, priced on the higher side. Then again, that's consistent with the restaurant's overall pricing.
The ambiance was pleasant; low-level music playing boleros and other Spanish classics really set a cozy, relaxed mood. We checked out the special lunch prices, but honestly, they didn't make much sense to us. We ended up ordering from the regular entrée menu, which felt like a better value.
One thing that caught our attention was the drink pricing; beer was only $2 more than a soda, so it felt like a better deal than paying high for soft drinks.
Service-wise, this is where they dropped the ball. It took quite a while to get our appetizers, and after that, we barely got any attention from the staff. That part of the experience really stood out in a negative way.
Overall, good food and ambiance, but the service needs serious improvement.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 2
This is our go to with kids, even though it’s great as a pub as well. During old people dinner it’s super laid back and no one cares if your toddler is annoying (other than you). Nothing flash, just a solid regular . At night it has sports and a pub feel.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 4
Food is always good here and they serve all day breakfast options. I had the french toast and I love the strawberry butter it comes with. I also love the mac and cheese.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Really nice atmosphere. Great service. Great food. Easy to talk, music a little bit lower would be nice but yeah very nice place thank you.
What a classy burger
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
One of the best Cuban sandwiches I’ve ever had. Also you get your money’s worth. It’s amazing. Service was great, lunch was busy so it lagged but very friendly and the food came fast. Will be coming back asap
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 4
Bringing the bill before it being asked for sends the message "it's fine for you to go" despite wanting more dink or food.
We weren't making noise, just talking in a normal volume. Just finished our meal and my first wanted another drink. Well the bill came before he asked for a 2nd drink.
So we left.
Also, watch the tables. If you see empty water glasses, refill them. Empty drink glasses? Ask if we want another drink.
This time it was a "one and done".
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 3
Restaurantji Recommends
This place is amazing the service was great. The waiter would be nearby and ready to answer any questions that I had about the food. The interior was so elegant it felt like an indoor picnic the exterior makes the place look like a ghost and you would never expect something like that to be there. I blame myself for choosing the wrong food, but everything else was worth.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 3
Service: 5
Came to toast for dinner and got the fish sandwich. It was pretty tasty and definitely big enough that I took home half for the next day
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The food and the service is exceptional. My wife and I love coming here and make it a point to have dinner here when we’re in the neighborhood. They have amazing happy hour options. We’ve tried most things from the menu and they’re all fantastic. Strongly recommended
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Very misleading - sign says $10 burger and beer, which seems too good to be true. Turns out it was! We were explained AFTER our check arrived that it’s a $10 burger if you buy a beer. The server admitted it was misleading but did nothing to rectify the situation. I even ordered by saying, “We’re going to have the $10 burger and beer!” As someone who works in the industry I find this incredibly sketchy and I will definitely not be back.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Saw flies in the kitchen, they got half of our orders wrong, when they came back with the “fixed” plates, they were completely unchanged, the servers were rude and even cursed as we spoke to them, had to ask multiple times for just two cups of water, and then again for straws, and this was overall a horrendous experience. They also have almost none of the items as they do online. Never coming back
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 2
Service: 1
Loading...