Toloache delivers a modern take on traditional Mexican cuisine with bold flavors and beautiful presentation. The guacamole was fresh and perfectly seasoned, and the tacos were packed with flavor — especially the carnitas. The atmosphere is lively yet intimate, making it a great spot for both date nights and small gatherings. Service was attentive without being overbearing. While prices are on the higher side, the quality and experience make it worth it.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jo Hastings
Delicious all around! Loved the ceviche tasting, but the short rib tacos with bone marrow ... 👩🏼🍳😘
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Diane La Von
I just wanted to say, the staff here went out of their way to be kind to my daughter, and take care of us, best service I have had frankly in time square. Would definitely recommend to anyone going to see wicked. Conveniently next door, and they are amazing to kids.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Mari Baci
Came here before a show with my mom and sister. We made reservations for 6:15 so we’d have time to enjoy our meal before our 8 pm show. However we weren’t seated until almost 6:45! There is no area to wait and it was freezing outside so we were crowded by the entrance trying our best to not be in peoples ways. If everything else wasn’t so busy that day we would have left and gone elsewhere. When we were finally seated we ordered the spicy guacamole and the hamachi ceviche. They were both good but nothing very sprcial. For dinner we had carnitas de lechon, quesadilla de tuetano, and the carne asada along with sweet plantains and rice and beans to share. They were all good though the quesadilla was fairly small. The beans had an odd almost floral flavor but they were still nice. We had a couple sangrias as well but they were pretty mid. Overall, I would definitely never wait that long as the food was good but nothing too special and the prices only make sense for the location. Anywhere else I’d never pay that much.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 3
ron
Our waiter was pleasant, food was okay, service was rushed. I know turnover is good for restaurant but 30 minutes for dinner was pushing it.
JIM
We loved this restaurant . The margaritas and guacamole were great, and the food was outstanding....highly recommend.
Charlie Alterman
Have been coming here for years as it always hits. Food is first rate, drinks are truly incredible. And our server, Gabriela, is a treasure. She made our whole night. Thank you!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
D Williams
Ordered a quesadilla and enchiladas Was brought what appeared to be a Taco Bell style Mexican pizza with only one tortilla, and a the enchiladas was essentially just a plate of barely seasoned shredded chicken.
Felt pressured/rushed to order within 5 minutes of sitting down, even after telling the first waiter to give me some time.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 2
Service: 2
Minerva Mendoza
My husband and I went for dinner food was okay , we felt rushed while having dinner , towards the end while we got our dessert served the server brought out the check when we never asked for it we still wanted to order drinks but we didn’t since the server brought out the check without us asking for it !! Very unprofessional! won’t be coming back here !
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 2
Service: 1
Laurie
Everything was great but it's very off putting that they wouldn't allow me to be seated without my full party despite the fact that I had a reservation, am a long time customer and the place wasn't yet full. This is the first time that happened at toloache
Staff were rude and were talking behind our back. Food is very mid with small portions so expect to pay a high price and still be hungry. Need to work on customer service
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Clarita Rios
The place was packed. We didn't have reservations but they accommodate us at the bar. It was perfect for us since we couldn't stay to long. The food was great. Customer service was 👌. They served food pretty quick and were attend to our needs.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
ESharon
I worked in the building next door to Toloache for over 30 years. Since they've been in business it was always a go-to place for a nice lunch.
Jacquelyn
Food and service were outstanding, as usual! Guac is made right in front of the customers and is so fresh and delicious!! Joseph went above and beyond to make it an awesome experience once again for my daughter and me! Will definitely be back!
Toloache delivers a modern take on traditional Mexican cuisine with bold flavors and beautiful presentation. The guacamole was fresh and perfectly seasoned, and the tacos were packed with flavor — especially the carnitas. The atmosphere is lively yet intimate, making it a great spot for both date nights and small gatherings. Service was attentive without being overbearing. While prices are on the higher side, the quality and experience make it worth it.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Delicious all around! Loved the ceviche tasting, but the short rib tacos with bone marrow ... 👩🏼🍳😘
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
I just wanted to say, the staff here went out of their way to be kind to my daughter, and take care of us, best service I have had frankly in time square. Would definitely recommend to anyone going to see wicked. Conveniently next door, and they are amazing to kids.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Came here before a show with my mom and sister. We made reservations for 6:15 so we’d have time to enjoy our meal before our 8 pm show. However we weren’t seated until almost 6:45! There is no area to wait and it was freezing outside so we were crowded by the entrance trying our best to not be in peoples ways. If everything else wasn’t so busy that day we would have left and gone elsewhere.
When we were finally seated we ordered the spicy guacamole and the hamachi ceviche. They were both good but nothing very sprcial. For dinner we had carnitas de lechon, quesadilla de tuetano, and the carne asada along with sweet plantains and rice and beans to share. They were all good though the quesadilla was fairly small. The beans had an odd almost floral flavor but they were still nice. We had a couple sangrias as well but they were pretty mid.
Overall, I would definitely never wait that long as the food was good but nothing too special and the prices only make sense for the location. Anywhere else I’d never pay that much.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 3
Our waiter was pleasant, food was okay, service was rushed. I know turnover is good for restaurant but 30 minutes for dinner was pushing it.
We loved this restaurant . The margaritas and guacamole were great, and the food was outstanding....highly recommend.
Have been coming here for years as it always hits. Food is first rate, drinks are truly incredible. And our server, Gabriela, is a treasure. She made our whole night. Thank you!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Ordered a quesadilla and enchiladas
Was brought what appeared to be a Taco Bell style Mexican pizza with only one tortilla, and a the enchiladas was essentially just a plate of barely seasoned shredded chicken.
Felt pressured/rushed to order within 5 minutes of sitting down, even after telling the first waiter to give me some time.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 2
Service: 2
My husband and I went for dinner food was okay , we felt rushed while having dinner , towards the end while we got our dessert served the server brought out the check when we never asked for it we still wanted to order drinks but we didn’t since the server brought out the check without us asking for it !! Very unprofessional! won’t be coming back here !
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 2
Service: 1
Everything was great but it's very off putting that they wouldn't allow me to be seated without my full party despite the fact that I had a reservation, am a long time customer and the place wasn't yet full. This is the first time that happened at toloache
Restaurantji Recommends
nice place
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Staff were rude and were talking behind our back. Food is very mid with small portions so expect to pay a high price and still be hungry. Need to work on customer service
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
The place was packed. We didn't have reservations but they accommodate us at the bar. It was perfect for us since we couldn't stay to long. The food was great. Customer service was 👌. They served food pretty quick and were attend to our needs.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I worked in the building next door to Toloache for over 30 years. Since they've been in business it was always a go-to place for a nice lunch.
Food and service were outstanding, as usual! Guac is made right in front of the customers and is so fresh and delicious!! Joseph went above and beyond to make it an awesome experience once again for my daughter and me! Will definitely be back!
Loading...