Food, drinks and service was very good. However, they didn't inform us of an early closing time (10:30?) for NYC and after filling our final drink order, proceeded to rush us out the door. Don't ask us if we want another drink if you're closing in 15 minutes. Very annoying.
Marla
Always excellent! A favorite neighborhood spot! They did forget to celebrate the birthday that was noted in the reservation tho...
Catherine
Our second time there. Great ambiance. Friendly staff. Excellent guacamole strong drinks. Ceviche and tacos yum. Truly a go to neighborhood gem.
Randy
Absolutely phenomenal experience! The food was beyond delicious, especially the nachos and the birria tacos. The nachos were perfectly fresh and the sauce had an incredible flavor in every bite. The birria tacos were the real star—tender, juicy, and packed with rich, savory goodness, with that amazing dipping broth that takes everything to another level. Every bite was bursting with authentic Mexican flavor. This place truly knows how to do it right, and I can't wait to come back for more. Highly recommend to anyone craving amazing Mexican food!
Susan
We had an amazing experience. The service was wonderful and the food was delicious. I would recommend it to anyone.
Tracey
Best experience with family on Christmas. Food was delicious, drinks were great and our server was lovely! Cant wait to come back next time in NYC. Do not miss out on the truffle quesadilla! It's a banger!
Janet
It's always fun going to Toloache. However, during Hanukkah it's even more fun with a terrific special Hanukkah menu in addition to their regular menu. Coming early meant we missed the large parties that were going to be there later. The service is always friendly and accommodating.
Haig
We were seated quickly with reservations. The host was very pleasant. We had a quiet table for 2. Service was outstanding. The server was attentive and our water glasses were filled quickly. The spicy guac was great, very flavorful. The fish tacos was nicely presented and tasty. The braised brisket in chiles was also nice presented and overall was excellent. If we are in the upper East Side of Manhattan we would definitely go again.
julie
I just love this restaurant the food is delish and the help is so nice they always take care of me and with a smile Thank you so much
Tim
Daniel and Vanessa were great.. made my girlfriend and I feel right at home. Food & cocktails were also amazing. Thank you for the hospitality!!
Toalache on the UES is our favorite restaurant! The food is consistently delicious and the service is very good. Our favorites are the guacamole and Tacos, but you cannot go wrong with any of the menu items! Oh and the margaritas are consistently delicious!
Michael
They didn't rush us but didn't disappear - key for me. I had the NY Strip & the Maître D' offered that it's his favorite sauce of this chef - and it was a sincere compliment of my choice. Who doesn't like that - and it was fantastic!
Amit Sagiv
Super nice service ❤️ great margarita and taco , we stepped in from the street it was pure fun , thank you 🚀
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Lee Wilson-Hayes
Mouth watering carnitas tacos, heavenly guacamole, and great service. We'll be back!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Martha Arellano
Great Mexican fare food. Was there for dinner, had carnitas tacos as appetizer and the special fish that was perfectly cooked tasty. The only part that could have been better were the tortillas, as they were too thin and broke.
Food, drinks and service was very good. However, they didn't inform us of an early closing time (10:30?) for NYC and after filling our final drink order, proceeded to rush us out the door. Don't ask us if we want another drink if you're closing in 15 minutes. Very annoying.
Always excellent! A favorite neighborhood spot! They did forget to celebrate the birthday that was noted in the reservation tho...
Our second time there. Great ambiance. Friendly staff. Excellent guacamole strong drinks. Ceviche and tacos yum. Truly a go to neighborhood gem.
Absolutely phenomenal experience! The food was beyond delicious, especially the nachos and the birria tacos. The nachos were perfectly fresh and the sauce had an incredible flavor in every bite. The birria tacos were the real star—tender, juicy, and packed with rich, savory goodness, with that amazing dipping broth that takes everything to another level. Every bite was bursting with authentic Mexican flavor. This place truly knows how to do it right, and I can't wait to come back for more. Highly recommend to anyone craving amazing Mexican food!
We had an amazing experience. The service was wonderful and the food was delicious. I would recommend it to anyone.
Best experience with family on Christmas. Food was delicious, drinks were great and our server was lovely! Cant wait to come back next time in NYC. Do not miss out on the truffle quesadilla! It's a banger!
It's always fun going to Toloache. However, during Hanukkah it's even more fun with a terrific special Hanukkah menu in addition to their regular menu. Coming early meant we missed the large parties that were going to be there later. The service is always friendly and accommodating.
We were seated quickly with reservations. The host was very pleasant. We had a quiet table for 2. Service was outstanding. The server was attentive and our water glasses were filled quickly. The spicy guac was great, very flavorful. The fish tacos was nicely presented and tasty. The braised brisket in chiles was also nice presented and overall was excellent. If we are in the upper East Side of Manhattan we would definitely go again.
I just love this restaurant the food is delish and the help is so nice they always take care of me and with a smile Thank you so much
Daniel and Vanessa were great.. made my girlfriend and I feel right at home. Food & cocktails were also amazing. Thank you for the hospitality!!
Restaurantji Recommends
Toalache on the UES is our favorite restaurant! The food is consistently delicious and the service is very good. Our favorites are the guacamole and Tacos, but you cannot go wrong with any of the menu items! Oh and the margaritas are consistently delicious!
They didn't rush us but didn't disappear - key for me. I had the NY Strip & the Maître D' offered that it's his favorite sauce of this chef - and it was a sincere compliment of my choice. Who doesn't like that - and it was fantastic!
Super nice service ❤️ great margarita and taco , we stepped in from the street it was pure fun , thank you 🚀
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Mouth watering carnitas tacos, heavenly guacamole, and great service. We'll be back!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great Mexican fare food. Was there for dinner, had carnitas tacos as appetizer and the special fish that was perfectly cooked tasty. The only part that could have been better were the tortillas, as they were too thin and broke.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Loading...