Trudy's Ice Cream

975 Columbus Ave, New York
(646) 649-3612

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Molly

The peanut butter ice cream is delicious!

Allen He

Best orange vanilla swirl soft serve in town!!!

Stella Vlachou

Such a beautiful little spot, with delicious home made ice cream at affordable prices, and really kind staff. I got the chocolate cherry and mango flavours twice already.
Importantly, also pet friendly with delicious ice cream for doggies. It seems that, judging from the reaction of a couple of them, even some doggies are regular customers! :-)
I love the atmosphere and colours of this little gem, which has a long bench and quite a few spots to sit down and enjoy your ice cream, as well as the colourful metal tables outside at a vibrant and friendly neighbourhood, so close to Central Park and in the wider Columbia University lively neighbourhood.
If I lived in the area long term, I would visit it every day!

Odin Howdock

Went to his lewisburg location at the fair, staff was very sweet but clearly overworked. And witnessed him fire two employees very publicly and in a way that was very unprofessional. Also the ice cream was very subpar.

Kelly Myslinski

a true neighborhood ice cream parlor that always hits the spot.

Haochen You

The young lady at the counter is very gentle and patient! But it seems that the air conditioner was not very good when I came here. The ice cream ball began to melt before I ate it, and it dripped directly on the table.

Oz

Tasty and homemade ice cream.

Tammy

Cutest neighborhood ice cream shop. The peanut butter was so good!!

Daniel

Nice place ice cream is a cool treat on a hot day!!! Go try n enjoy

NYC Guide

Susue is always nice!

ariany ariany

I’m honestly surprised by all the good reviews—this place was a big letdown. The ice cream tasted off, definitely not fresh or flavorful, and the hot fudge was the worst part. It tasted cheap and burnt, like it had been sitting around too long or made with low-quality ingredients. On top of that, it’s overpriced for what you get. Definitely not worth the hype.

Fajas Svalen

I was walking through the neighborhood the other day and stumbled across this tiny ice cream shop that caught my eye. Inside the place were covered with a menu and a nostalgic smell-like vainilla and waffle cones. The have a variety from cookies and cream to matcha-pistachio. The place was clean. The girl behind the counter was friendly. I stood at the window watching people walk by while the sun did its best to melt my cone. Honestly, I felt like a perfect little pause in my day and definitely I’ll be back next time I’m in the area.

Svalen Fajas

I was walking through the neighborhood the other day and stumbled across this tiny ice cream shop that caught my eye. Inside the place were covered with a menu and a nostalgic smell-like vainilla and waffle cones. The have a variety from cookies and cream to matcha-pistachio. The place was clean. The girl behind the counter was friendly. I stood at the window watching people walk by while the sun did its best to melt my cone. Honestly, I felt like a perfect little pause in my day and definitely I’ll be back next time I’m in the area.

Michelle Hersh

Gem of a local ice cream store. I love this place. Ice cream is delicious, staff is extremely nice, very kid-friendly, very dog-friendly. Really, a neighborhood ice cream store does not get any better than this.

Charles

Great ice cream and great owners! Thank you

Loading...