Trudy's Ice Cream

975 Columbus Ave, New York
(646) 649-3612

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Fajas Svalen

I was walking through the neighborhood the other day and stumbled across this tiny ice cream shop that caught my eye. Inside the place were covered with a menu and a nostalgic smell-like vainilla and waffle cones. The have a variety from cookies and cream to matcha-pistachio. The place was clean. The girl behind the counter was friendly. I stood at the window watching people walk by while the sun did its best to melt my cone. Honestly, I felt like a perfect little pause in my day and definitely I’ll be back next time I’m in the area.

Michelle Hersh

Gem of a local ice cream store. I love this place. Ice cream is delicious, staff is extremely nice, very kid-friendly, very dog-friendly. Really, a neighborhood ice cream store does not get any better than this.

Charles

Great ice cream and great owners! Thank you

Raul Rodriguez

The ice cream is very delicious!

Solel Soleil

Really good small-batch, artisanally flavored ice cream, gelato and soft serve (including orange creamsicle), especially chocolate, at a much better price than most other parlors in NYC. Owner and staff are good-natured. Really good bittersweet hot fudge, chocolate-dipped frozen bananas and candied apples also available.

Kathleen B

Great variety of flavors and so delicious! Some of the best we’ve had! Highly recommend pistachio and banana pudding!

Dita Starks

AMAZING !!! Thank you

Kimia Dargahi

Chocolate cherry, peanut butter, cookies and cream and add some sprinkles —
Yummm!

And a stone’s throw from Central Park! A must visit

🍦

Natalie Vera

Coffee toffee - loved the light toffee crunch

Strawberry - tastes quite authentic. Not too sweet or milky

Cookies & creme - excellent

Eleni Tountas

A wonderful corner neighborhood ice cream shop! The servers are all very nice and will let you try multiple flavors. Our dog also loves that they give out pup cups, so he can enjoy a sweet treat, too! I highly recommend the orange and vanilla swirl soft serve - it's sooooo delicious and keeps me coming back for more!! 🍊🍦🍊

Carl Wolf

Good folks and better ice cream! Was not expecting such a warm welcome when I came in but it was much appreciated ☺️

lindsey t

the worker there was so nice and welcoming+ ice cream sundae was awesome. Definitely going back

Marc Aaron

Great ice cream, friendly staff, and dog-friendly!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Alyssa

so friendly!! soft serve creamsicle was amazing!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Ying Xiang Tan

Delicious, especially the banana pudding flavour

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Loading...