Two Boots Pizza Upper East Side

Were two flavours when I was there and got the V for vegan. Crust and sauce were so good! Also really cute interior

First time I went I ordered some Grandma Slices and it was raw dough in the middle.

Today I returned to give them a 2nd chance and my slices were just rubbery and not good, unfortunately. I won't be coming back a 3rd time! Staff seem nice though--just wish they could cook up a proper slice 😑

As someone who is married to someone with a late in life diagnosed dairy allergy, pizza is a real cheat food. Like, sneak it and feel guilty for eating it kind of cheat food, because food is meant to be shared.

Finding pizza that tastes great while being dairy free has been a huge pain point. At Two Boots Pizza, they have vegan options (gives us the dairy free cheese) that are absolutely amazing!

Not to mention they have real cane sugar creme soda and this is a little slice of heaven. 🍕🥤

Dietary restrictions: Has great vegan options!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 4

I ordered a pizza with extra sauce so they gave me crust and cheese 😭

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Been driving past this spot for years, and onna rainy day decided to stop in to get a slice. My husband and I were kind of in a rush, and what's a quicker on the go meal than a slice of pizza? We walked in and was quite overwhelmed with the decor and vast array of pizzas to choose from. The decor is cherry,bright and eclectic with a giant pizza artsy thing on the ceiling and the pizzas all have interesting names and descriptions with the ingredients listed and it made it so hard to decide! That's not a complaint - we were in a rush and didn't have time to really take it all in so we opted for a regular slice. The super kind and informative tall guy behind the counter who helped us was so patient with my indecisiveness and questions, and gave us an extra regular slice. We opened the box he handed us to put our fixings on the slice and we asked if he gave us the correct order and he let us know he intended to give us the extra slice. Even before that kind gesture I planned to revisit to try one of their many varieties of pizza, but that kind gesture amped up my desire to go back very soon.
Oh! And I didn't even tell you how delicious the regular slice was! First off..the sauce tasted like someone really took their time with it because it was flavorful, Herby, and well seasoned! I wish I had time to take pics or video of the cheese pull because it was insane! Real mozzarella cheese, not that cheap stuff that turns to rubber within seconds... So good! And the crust rounded it off - crispy enough to withstand the cheese and sauce and not get soggy, but not to crunchy where it tears up the roof of your mouth. Best slice I've had in a long time. Can't wait to go back, I'm already planning to try some crawfish on my pizza from Two Boots!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

The worse pizza I have ever tasted, it was look like made of rubber and bunch of garbage, the lady at the counter was very nice polite & respectful.
Soda can was $2.50. Will never go there again and won’t recommend it to anyone

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 1

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Mild Marinara

Ordered for pickup. Wasn’t ready and had to wait extra 15 minutes

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 4

Service: 1

Good, not great, but for the price it's straight up

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 3

Service: 5

Pizza is alright

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 4

Was looking for the Two Boots experience from 30 years ago, no luck. Pizza was Mall food court quality. Nostalgia mostly ends with disappointment.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 1

Service: 3

Good vegan pizza.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Vegan Cleopatra Jones Calzone

Had a pizza from here a few days ago. It’s was a delivery so don’t know about the service and atmosphere. But definitely liked the pizza. It was a very unique flavor with spinach. Definitely my first time having a pizza with spinach.
They have some vegetarian and vegan options too.

Food: 5

Recommended dishes: V for Vegan

really really dissapointed ! best garlic knots in town and perhaps their specialty pizzas are more fresh because I enjoyed the one i tried - but i paid for a really really terrible cheese pizza that had no base to it, pure cheese - just flopped over - got it replaced with a tasteless, rushed heated additional cheese pizza that was handed to me with haste and 0 customer service. A shame cause i enjoyed this place initially - so close to the hospital and great change to lunch options but its declining in service and quality quite fast since its opening and the absence of a man who worked the counter, who I believe was the manager! - these old cheese slices are deplorable!

Recommended dishes: Marinara Sauce

A really fun little spot. The first thing I noticed was the decor and how it just pops with so much life and personality. It truly feels quite unique.

There’s also a variety of special pizzas that help break from the monotony of choosing in typical pizza establishments. I went for The Newman and The Meg and they were both so good. Thin crust, not too oily, just the right amount of toppings.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Alright, here’s the deal:
Two Boots Pizzeria is killing it. The crust is perfectly crispy yet chewy—solid 8.7. The sauce? It’s the star here—rich, balanced, just the right amount of tang—8.9 out of 10. Cheese and toppings? Fresh, well-distributed, and not too greasy—another 8.6. Overall, this pie’s an 8.7. One bite, everybody knows the rules.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5