Unregular Pizza

135 4th Ave, New York
(646) 609-4699

Recent Reviews Order Online

Customers' Favorites

Grandma Peppina Gluten Free Pizza
Burrapizza Cafonata Gluten Free
Truffled Mushrooms Burrapizza
Truffle Mushrooms Burrapizza
Fried Pasta Cacio E Pepe
Diavolona Pizza Square
Bufala Chicken Pizza
Burrapizza Cafonata
Burrapizza Pugliese
Unmargherita Pizza

Menu

Featured items
Cafonata Burrapizza
Tomato sauce, pepperoni, spicy hot honey, whole burrata, and 'nduja sauce
Diavolona Pizza Square
Pepperoni, mozzarella, tomato sauce, and spicy hot honey optional.
Grandma Peppina
Garlicky tomato sauce, mozzarella, parmigiano.
Fried Pasta Cacio e Pepe
Fried spaghetti, pecorino, mozzarella, black pepper.
Fried Pasta Vodka Sauce
Spaghetti, vodka sauce, smoked mozzarella
Garlic Squares
Garlicky focaccia bites, marinara on the side
Plain Cheese Square
Mozzarella, tomato sauce
Cacio e pepe
Mozzarella, black pepper, Pecorino Romano DOP (24 months)
Pizza Nutella & Pistachio
Roman-style square pizza with nutella and pistachio crumbs
Chicken Vodka Sandwich
All natural fried chicken, fresh mozzarella, vodka sauce, and parmigiana reggiano (24 months).
Mini Stromboli Pepperoni
Premium pepperoni, 'nduja sauce, spicy honey, mozzarella, tomato sauce
Chicken Parm Sandwich
All natural fried chicken, fresh mozzarella, tomato sauce, and parmigiana reggiano (24 months).
Nutella Tarts
Claudio's Kitchen brand, 6 pieces
Vegan Margherita (VG)
Vegan mozzarella, tomato sauce, and house garlic olive oil.
Emiliana Sandwich
Prosciutto di parma, fresh mozzarella, arugula, roasted tomatoes, parmigiano.
Burrapizza Prosciutto e Carciofi
Mozzarella, cherry tomatoes confit, artichokes, prosciutto, whole burrata
Apricot Jam Tarts
Claudio's Kitchen brand, 6 pieces

Rosticceria - Small bites
Fried Pasta Vodka Sauce
Spaghetti, vodka sauce, smoked mozzarella
Fried Pasta Cacio e Pepe
Fried spaghetti, pecorino, mozzarella, black pepper.
Mini Stromboli Spinach/artichokes
Spinach, artichokes, mozzarella
Mini Stromboli Pepperoni
Premium pepperoni, 'nduja sauce, spicy honey, mozzarella, tomato sauce

Pizza
Diavolona Pizza Square
Pepperoni, mozzarella, tomato sauce, and spicy hot honey optional.
Grandma Peppina
Garlicky tomato sauce, mozzarella, parmigiano.
Cacio e pepe
Mozzarella, black pepper, Pecorino Romano DOP (24 months)
Plain Cheese Square
Mozzarella, tomato sauce
Bufala Chicken Pizza
Fried chicken, buffalo mozzarella, buffalo sauce, and mozzarella.
Unmushrooms Pizza
Mixed mushrooms shimaji, cremini, oyster, Pecorino Romano DoP ,mozzarella
Meat Dream Pizza
Beef and pork meatballs, sweet sausage, pepperoni, mozzarella, and tomato sauce.
Chicken Out Pizza
Roasted chicken, cherry tomato confit, mozzarella, and basil pesto (no nuts).

Burrapizza
Cafonata Burrapizza
Tomato sauce, pepperoni, spicy hot honey, whole burrata, and 'nduja sauce
Burrapizza Prosciutto e Carciofi
Mozzarella, cherry tomatoes confit, artichokes, prosciutto, whole burrata

Plant-based pizza
Vegan Margherita (VG)
Vegan mozzarella, tomato sauce, and house garlic olive oil.
Veggie Festa Pizza
Mixed mushrooms (shimaji, cremini, oyster), cherry tomato confit, roasted peppers, vegan mozzarella, and tomato sauce.

Sandwiches
Chicken Vodka Sandwich
All natural fried chicken, fresh mozzarella, vodka sauce, and parmigiana reggiano (24 months).
Chicken Parm Sandwich
All natural fried chicken, fresh mozzarella, tomato sauce, and parmigiana reggiano (24 months).
Vertage Vegan Chicken Parm Sandwich
Emiliana Sandwich
Prosciutto di parma, fresh mozzarella, arugula, roasted tomatoes, parmigiano.
Unacaprese Sandwich
Roasted tomatoes, fresh mozzarella, basil pesto (no nuts), and arugula.

Sides
Garlic Squares
Garlicky focaccia bites, marinara on the side
Garlic Squares Parmigiana
Garlicky focaccia bites, mozzarella, parmigiano marinara on the side
Green Salad
Mixed greens, side of balsamic vinaigrette
Burrata
Whole burrata

Dolce
Pizza Nutella & Pistachio
Roman-style square pizza with nutella and pistachio crumbs
Nutella Tarts
Claudio's Kitchen brand, 6 pieces
Pistachio Cookies
Claudio's Kitchen brand, 6 pieces
Apricot Jam Tarts
Claudio's Kitchen brand, 6 pieces

Water & Sodas
Diet Coca-Cola
12 oz can
Aranciata A' Siciliana
Italian Blood Orange Soda
Coca-Cola
12 oz can
Limonata A' Siciliana
Italian Lemon Soda can
S. Pellegrino Blood Orange seltzer
Blood Orange seltzer
Sprite
12 oz can
Ginger Ale
Ginger ale can 12oz
S. Pellegrino Lemon Zest seltzer
Lemon zest seltzer
Still Water
Smeraldina boxed still water 500mL from Sardinia, Italy.

Gluten Free
Veggie Festa Gluten Free (12" personal round pie)*
Mixed mushrooms, red and yellow peppers, cherry tomato confit, tomato sauce, mozzarella. *This product is NOT intended for those with celiac disease, as our facility is not 100% gluten free.
Vegan Mushrooms Gluten Free (12" personal round pie)*
Mixed mushrooms (Shimaji, Cremini, Oyster), Vegan mozzarella, Cherry tomato confit. *This product is NOT intended for those with celiac disease, as our facility is not 100% gluten free.
Plain Cheese Gluten Free* (12" personal round pie)
Mozzarella, tomato sauce *This product is NOT intended for those with celiac disease, as our facility is not 100% gluten free.
Bufalona Gluten Free (12" personal round pie)*
Cherry tomato confit, bufala mozzarella, basil pesto (no nuts), tomato sauce *This product is NOT intended for those with celiac disease, as our facility is not 100% gluten free.
Vegan Margherita Gluten Free (12" personal round pie)*
Vegan mozzarella, tomato sauce, house garlic olive oil *This product is NOT intended for those with celiac disease, as our facility is not 100% gluten free.
Cacio e pepe Gluten free (12" personal round pie)*
Mozzarella, ricotta, black pepper, pecorino romano DOP (24 months) *This product is NOT intended for those with celiac disease, as our facility is not 100% gluten free.
Diavolona Gluten Free (12" personal round pie)*
Premium pepperoni, mozzarella, tomato sauce, spicy hot honey (optional) *This product is NOT intended for those with celiac disease, as our facility is not 100% gluten free.
Chicken Out Gluten Free (12" personal round pie)*
Roasted chicken, cherry tomato confit, basil pesto (no nuts), mozzarella *This product is NOT intended for those with celiac disease, as our facility is not 100% gluten free.
Burrapizza Truffled Mushrooms Gluten Free (12" personal round pie)*
Mixed mushrooms (cremini, shimaji, oyster), whole burrata, truffle oil *This product is NOT intended for those with celiac disease, as our facility is not 100% gluten free.
Grandma Peppina Gluten Free (personal 12" round pie)*
Garlicky tomato sauce, mozzarella, parmigiano. *This product is NOT intended for those with celiac disease, as our facility is not 100% gluten free.
Unmushrooms Gluten Free (12" personal round pie)*
Mixed mushrooms (shimaji, cremini, oyster), mozzarella, Pecorino Romano (24 months) *This product is NOT intended for those with celiac disease, as our facility is not 100% gluten free.
Burrapizza Cafonata Gluten Free (12" personal round pie)*
Tomato sauce, premium pepperoni, spicy hot honey, whole burrata, ‘nduja sauce *This product is NOT intended for those with celiac disease, as our facility is not 100% gluten free.

Special
Weekly Special Pizza
Mozz., cherry tomatoes confit, artichokes, prosciutto, whole burrata

Photos

Photo credit: google
Photo credit: facebook
Photo credit: ubereats
+43 photos
Photo credit: ubereats
+42 photos
Add a photo

Recent Reviews

The kitchen creates memorable dishes. The space shows attention to detail. Everything works together. Deserves attention. The cooking was good and service attentive. Wasn't expecting excellence in this location. The employees provided solid service. I was taken aback by the quality here.
August 2025
I pinned this pizza place to give it a try and I wasn’t disappointed. The slice was so nice and fresh and very different than what I’m use to in NYC, but it was tasty. I would definitely go back for more.
August 2025
What a great little find. Based on all the reviews and the average score, its clearly a well known place. We were killing time in the area and stopped into the market for a quick bite to eat. We settled on pizza and im so glad we did. I'll keep this review short and sweet. The sauce. It's all about the sauce. We only ordered a plain pizza but it was superb! I know there are a plethora of great pizza places in NY but if youre in the area, make sure to give them a try!
August 2025

More Reviews

You May Also Like

Dos Toros Taqueria - 137 4th Ave
Mexican, Vegan, Vegetarian
CAVA - 143 4th Ave
Mediterranean, Salad, Vegan
Le Cafe Coffee - 145 4th Ave
Coffee Shops, Coffee & Tea, Coffee, Vegan

Unregular Pizza

135 4th Ave, New York, NY 10003
(646) 609-4699