Upside Pizza

20 E 40th St, New York
(917) 409-5972

Recent Reviews Order Online

Customers' Favorites

Upside Don Sicilian Pizza
Sicilian Pepperoni Pizza
Upside Down Sicilian
Mushroom wwlc Pie
Norm's Vodka Pizza
Spicy Vodka Pie
Pepperoni Pie
Cheese Pizza
Tomato Pie

By the Pie
Cheese Pie
A classic cheese slice with a homemade sauce, fresh mozzarella made daily in our kitchen, and more.
Sunny Goldstein
Fuzzy Dunlop Pie
Housemade Berkshire sausage seasoned with our secret spice blend. Paired with our house-pickled peppers for a kick of perfectly balanced heat.
Tomato Pie
Upside Pep Pie
A plethora of pepperoni. What else do you need to know.
Upside Don Pie
A very special homemade sauce is splotched on top of whole milk mozzarella, homemade breadcrumbs, EVOO, Parmigiano-Reggiano, and more. A 72-hour naturally fermented sourdough makes up the crust of this light but a savory slice.
Falcowitz Pie
A white wine lemon cream sauce topped with fresh mozzarella and sautéed mushrooms. Finished with fresh lemon zest, chopped parsley, cracked black pepper, and Parmigiano Reggiano.
Pepperoni Papi Pie
Some very special roni cups top this classic but innovative slice.
50/50
Half Cheese/Half Pepperoni

Drinks
Soda Can
Glass Bottle Soda
Brooklyn Best - Iced Tea/Lemonade
Low Sugar
Water Bottle

Other
Cup of Sauce
Some pizza sauce for dipping.
Garlic Knots
ButterCrust Garlic Knots (Order of 4)

Photos

Photo credit: google
Photo credit: google
Photo credit: google
+35 photos
Photo credit: google
+34 photos
Add a photo

Recent Reviews

Pizza was delicious. A few vegetarian options. Pricing was a little intransparent but good value for money. Service was very fast but did not understand special requests. Condiments (chili, oregano, Parmesan) were available and clean. More seating would be nice! Overall a great pizza place. Recommend:)
August 2025
ehh. I got a slice of pizza with some sort of cheese piled on top of it that was dripping off with oil and grease. the crust was kind of burnt and crumbling like a cracker. and the piece was so huge, I could only eat half of it before I gave it to someone else because I started to feel queasy. pretty pricy at 30 some dollars for 4 slices.
August 2025
I actually really like the pizza at this particular location (world’s difference compared to the 8th Ave & 39th St location 👎

That being said… I agree with previous reviewer Ba B. Everytime I come here, the same rude heavy-set male treats me very poorly with passive aggressive gestures, rude tone, and impatience (even when it is not a busy time of day). Strangely, I hardly say a word to him so I am not so sure why I trigger him each time I visit…...
July 2025

More Reviews

You May Also Like

Gregorys Coffee - 20 E 40th St
Coffee Shops, Coffee & Tea, Coffee
Chipotle Mexican Grill - 274 Madison Ave
Mexican, Fast Food
CAVA - 280 Madison Ave
Mediterranean, Salad

Upside Pizza

20 E 40th St, New York, NY 10016
(917) 409-5972