Utopia Diner

267 Amsterdam Ave, New York
(212) 873-6233

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Konstantin Astafurov

Utopia Diner? more like Dystopia Diner!
- terrible milkshake (served in a plastic cup ; tasted watery)
- Disappointing burger with Leningrad blockade portions of bacon
- Matzo ball soup is two sad balls of starch floating in an onion puddle. It's just two balls and broth.
- Tolerable fries

Sandra Zeug

Great food and excellent service!! +++

Harry King

Came here despite the low ratings, craving a diner breakfast. Totally regretted it. I was given spoiled half & half with my iced coffee, which I drank before realizing. Upon smelling the half & half by itself, it clearly smelled spoiled. When I told the waiter and told him to smell it, he stared blankly at it and walked away. He came back with the small half & half pods, but didn’t apologize about the spoiled half & half I had originally been given, and just walked away.
Me and my friend got 2 eggs any style with sausage. Everything tasted like nothing. The potatoes were especially bland. My sausage was also slightly pink on the inside, which may have been fine, but at that point I didn’t trust it.
In short, Would not recommend this place at all.

Tyson Gholston Davis

Rude manager. Bland mediocre food.

Sophia Smith

My husband and I love it here and come all the time. It's very classic NYC diner with your standard fare and you can find delicious pancakes and even better waffle fries.

Mimi Fries

it's a diner with mediocre food. that should say it all

Amy Testa

Great place for breakfast, service was very fast. My juevos rancheros were excellent and my husband enjoyed the breakfast sausage.

Ivory Hannigan

let the food speak for itself, horrible waiter who left for 30 mins, asked for turkey bacon on the side and it came with a variety of liquids on it aswell as the egg, the bacon was charcoal.

Robbert van Batenburg

Ridiculously overpriced.

Elad Levy

Great and simple, both breakfasts and dinner was very good, fresh, not as expensive as the other places around. kids friendly. When you want to grab a bite and relax without tearing up the wallet. The whole family is happy. No photos we ate it all and fast (: very recommended

Kid-friendliness: High chair and a kids friendly dishes

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Pierre Bailly

Very good, inexpensive and very plentiful

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Sonsoles Heras

Great food and service

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Indira Arroyo

This is our favorite diner

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Bacon Cheeseburger Deluxe, Gyro, French Fries, Grilled Cheese, Lumberjack French Toast with Bacon or Ham or Sausage and Two Eggs, Club Sandwich, Cobb Salad with Chicken

Samia Dhib

Big disappointment. Poor breakfast, there were 3 of us and none of us was satisfied. Omelets served cold and dry, almost burnt and the failed potatoes cold and mostly burnt ?, the slices of bread also served cold and stale like a feeling of already served and collected from previous customers, I regret not having taken a photo ...And the icing on the cake was the tip amount imposed on the final bill ?. We will never come back there again ?.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 1

Service: 1

Jo Drew

I have been eating at that diner for most of my adult life. It was always a good source for classic diner eats, with fresh ingredients. Recently, there have been minor changes to their food prep when only one person is in the kitchen that take the service downa notch for me. However, it is generally a good spot.

Vegetarian options: My favorites are; veggie burger delux, with sweet potato fries, spinach pie with a Greek salad, or falafel platter that was divine along with an assortment of omelets filled to the brim with different amazing flavors.

Dietary restrictions: I don't eat animal flesh, but I always find something wonderful.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Water Coffee Juice, French Fries

Loading...