The Pepperoni Square and Vodka Square are probably my two favorite slices I've ever had in NYC. Always hits the spot, open late, and the staff is always very quick and friendly.
Łukasz Kain
Small place, but it's place to get the slice, or slices and go, best to do it, or just simply it - but you must stand. They are many varieties, I choosed classic. Worth the hipy, crispy and tasty. But also there was a lot of fat in it, typical NY pizza I assume.
Khushi Gill
Honestly, wish I could try each & every slice so good, I’m already planning my next visit.
Do yourself a favor and try it. I got the Grandma slice & the thin crust was ON POINT!! Tastes like a slice of heaven! One of the best pizza places I’ve tried — no joke This is the kind of pizza that ruins other pizza for you.
A must-try for any pizza lover.
guy estragon
Small pizza place, the pies are super expensive compared to the quality. The crust of my margherita pie was chewy.
Sofia Strahl
The pizza was good, served quickly. Best to takeaway
Anmol Kapur
Messed up order and had to wait for them to remake …. Had to wait 30 minutes
Ming
Hot honey should be on every single pepperoni pizza. In fact, on every pizza! Spicy, sweet honey paired with savory pepperoni - what a combo. At Village Square Pizza, their pepperonis are stacked! Their slices are crispy and chewy at the same time, no floppy pizza, with a crisp base, which gives a satisfying crunch. This spot is known for thick crust square slices, hence the name. We’ve also tried their three cheese slices, grandma slices, and margherita slices - the hot honey pepperoni pizza slice is hands down the best one. Don’t knock it until you try it!
Kierlyn Seeley
My friends and I stopped her for a quick slice after some drinks around the corner and we ended up coming back later in the night for a second one because it was so good and we had to try more of their options. My favorite was the vodka as it was actually quite light and the cheese was the perfect combination with the vodka sauce with it being overwhelming or tasting like pasta. The pepperoni was also incredible, crispy crust, but soft inside, and a bit oily. Never been to a pizza place twice in a night until here, but I highly recommend giving it a try.
Noah Daniels
gave me food poisoning i went on friday night and it’s monday and im still out for the count. glad my man is taking care of me
Vodka slice stole the show, though the pepperoni was excellent as well! Quite liked how crisp they cook the crust while retaining some of that airiness in the dough.
Trevor Galivan
Very good takeout pizzaria. Their pepperoni and 'white' slices are my favourite. Mostly thick-crust with some thin-crust as well.
~$5/slice, pretty quick to get your pizza. Great to grab and go when you are in a rush but want some good pizza.
$10 minimum if paying by card which means two slices.
prime beatz
Pizza was great, didn’t appreciate the $10 minimum to use your card, I feel that is so unfair, but it was great and the female that works there is amazingly beautiful
The Pepperoni Square and Vodka Square are probably my two favorite slices I've ever had in NYC. Always hits the spot, open late, and the staff is always very quick and friendly.
Small place, but it's place to get the slice, or slices and go, best to do it, or just simply it - but you must stand. They are many varieties, I choosed classic. Worth the hipy, crispy and tasty. But also there was a lot of fat in it, typical NY pizza I assume.
Honestly, wish I could try each & every slice so good, I’m already planning my next visit.
Do yourself a favor and try it. I got the Grandma slice & the thin crust was ON POINT!! Tastes like a slice of heaven! One of the best pizza places I’ve tried — no joke This is the kind of pizza that ruins other pizza for you.
A must-try for any pizza lover.
Small pizza place, the pies are super expensive compared to the quality. The crust of my margherita pie was chewy.
The pizza was good, served quickly. Best to takeaway
Messed up order and had to wait for them to remake …. Had to wait 30 minutes
Hot honey should be on every single pepperoni pizza. In fact, on every pizza! Spicy, sweet honey paired with savory pepperoni - what a combo. At Village Square Pizza, their pepperonis are stacked! Their slices are crispy and chewy at the same time, no floppy pizza, with a crisp base, which gives a satisfying crunch. This spot is known for thick crust square slices, hence the name. We’ve also tried their three cheese slices, grandma slices, and margherita slices - the hot honey pepperoni pizza slice is hands down the best one. Don’t knock it until you try it!
My friends and I stopped her for a quick slice after some drinks around the corner and we ended up coming back later in the night for a second one because it was so good and we had to try more of their options. My favorite was the vodka as it was actually quite light and the cheese was the perfect combination with the vodka sauce with it being overwhelming or tasting like pasta. The pepperoni was also incredible, crispy crust, but soft inside, and a bit oily. Never been to a pizza place twice in a night until here, but I highly recommend giving it a try.
gave me food poisoning i went on friday night and it’s monday and im still out for the count. glad my man is taking care of me
I get pizza here far too often
Restaurantji Recommends
Pizza is oily and not that flavorful
Best pizza in town.
Vodka slice stole the show, though the pepperoni was excellent as well! Quite liked how crisp they cook the crust while retaining some of that airiness in the dough.
Very good takeout pizzaria. Their pepperoni and 'white' slices are my favourite. Mostly thick-crust with some thin-crust as well.
~$5/slice, pretty quick to get your pizza. Great to grab and go when you are in a rush but want some good pizza.
$10 minimum if paying by card which means two slices.
Pizza was great, didn’t appreciate the $10 minimum to use your card, I feel that is so unfair, but it was great and the female that works there is amazingly beautiful
Loading...