Village Square Pizza - West Village

My favourite pizza place in NYC, and the best pizza I’ve had in a very long time. Cheese, margherita, siciliana all amazing. Only thing I’d say is that it’s not consistent - sometimes the pizzas taste a little different. But when they’re good, they’re incredible.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Best pizza and service, Armando is the goat. Get the vodka slice

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

I had to wait for 1 slice and 5 garlic knots for 1 hour to be delivered on Saturday September 6 2025 around 11:00 pm you need to fire the slow pizzaman and get faster one

My family and I traveled from Texas and spent a week in NYC. We tried at least 8 different pizza places and this was our favorite of all. I don’t do many reviews, but felt it was a shame that there was a line down the street for a good pizza place a few doors down and this GREAT shop had no line at all. It’s a must try!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Nice small little pizzeria, phenomenal pizzas! Very friendly and hard working staff.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

If you dont feel like making the line for L'industrie just walk down the block a couole feet and you won't be disappointed! The Grandma Square was amazing.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Grandma Pizza Slice

Supposed to be the best pizza in NYC, but my slices had a weird taste, like conservation additive, and I didn't even finish the 2nd one. Music pretty loud

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 1

Service: 4

We visited here with the kids, we really liked it. The staff is friendly, the pizza is very tasty. Thank you!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

So the owner of this place brought some pizza out on a sailing tour of the NY harbor and I was able to take some home after the tour. 24 hours later, I popped it in the oven and holy cow. Amazing slices. The marg was perfectly thin and the fresh mozzarella was perfect balanced with the sauce. The grandma slice is on another level. The pesto has such a healthy amount of garlic in it but in no way is it overwhelming. Great pizza cant wait to have it fresh out of the oven 😂

Food: 5

Our final stop on our West Village pizza tour was The Village Square Pizza, and it was such a sweet way to end the day!

Their pizzas are fluffy yet still have a nice crunch, and the toppings are super creative. My absolute favorite was the white pizza—it honestly tasted like eating a sweet cloud. I’m pretty sure they mix ricotta with honey, and it’s magical. We also loved the roasted eggplant on marinara—so flavorful and comforting.

The interior is cozy and feels like a charming little café. Seating is limited, so it’s more of a grab-and-go or quick-bite kind of place, but it’s worth the stop.

Highly recommend it if you’re looking for something a little different but still delicious on your NYC pizza adventure!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

The best pizza

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

I came here after reading all the great reviews — especially about the pepperoni and vodka pizza. So of course, I had to try both.

They’ve got a $10 minimum for credit cards, so I grabbed two slices. The woman asked if I wanted hot honey. I said sure, on both — but didn’t realize they charge $1.50 per sauce (and it’s just a tiny plastic container, not even drizzled on). Bit sneaky, especially since there’s no heads-up.

Pepperoni slice was solid — crispy edges, good flavor. Vodka pizza had this creamy white cheese on top, which was tasty, but the slice itself felt undercooked and floppy. The dough wasn’t quite there.

So overall:
• Pepperoni: good
• Vodka slice: meh
• Surprise honey tax: not cute

3 out of 5. Would I come back? Not really ….

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 3

Service: 2

I came here after reading all the great reviews — especially about the pepperoni and vodka pizza. So of course, I had to try both.

They’ve got a $10 minimum for credit cards, so I grabbed two slices. The woman asked if I wanted hot honey. I said sure, on both — but didn’t realize they charge $1.50 per sauce (and it’s just a tiny plastic container, not even drizzled on). Bit sneaky, especially since there’s no heads-up.

Pepperoni slice was solid — crispy edges, good flavor. Vodka pizza had this creamy white cheese on top, which was tasty, but the slice itself felt undercooked and floppy. The dough wasn’t quite there.

So overall:
• Pepperoni: good
• Vodka slice: meh
• Surprise honey tax: not cute

3 out of 5. Would I come back? Not really ….

Awesome, the square pepperoni slice had perfect flavour and texture. Unpretentious spot. Great for if you don’t want to queue for L’industrie but still want a great NY slice

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

I was on the hunt for a good deep dish style pizza here in the city & Village Square Pizza did not disappoint. Vegan options available so that’s always a plus!! 🍕💌✨