Village Square Pizza - West Village

I came here after reading all the great reviews — especially about the pepperoni and vodka pizza. So of course, I had to try both.

They’ve got a $10 minimum for credit cards, so I grabbed two slices. The woman asked if I wanted hot honey. I said sure, on both — but didn’t realize they charge $1.50 per sauce (and it’s just a tiny plastic container, not even drizzled on). Bit sneaky, especially since there’s no heads-up.

Pepperoni slice was solid — crispy edges, good flavor. Vodka pizza had this creamy white cheese on top, which was tasty, but the slice itself felt undercooked and floppy. The dough wasn’t quite there.

So overall:
• Pepperoni: good
• Vodka slice: meh
• Surprise honey tax: not cute

3 out of 5. Would I come back? Not really ….

Awesome, the square pepperoni slice had perfect flavour and texture. Unpretentious spot. Great for if you don’t want to queue for L’industrie but still want a great NY slice

I was on the hunt for a good deep dish style pizza here in the city & Village Square Pizza did not disappoint. Vegan options available so that’s always a plus!! 🍕💌✨

better than the overhyped l’industrie - no 2 hour long line, staff was nice, the chicken bacon ranch was 🔥

When the lines at L'Industrie and Mama's are too crazy... The pepperoni square with hot honey is a must

Excellent pizza. Good prices. Friendly staff. Short wait compared to down the street.

Really good and fast service nice staff love the Sicilian pizza 😋😁

Best pizza around

The folks are very nice here! They pointed me out the tastiest vegan slice (eggplant)! Such a crispy crust and a excellent sauce! All vegan! What a find!

Excellent grandma slice

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Grandma Pizza Slice

Every time I visit, there’s only one slice of vegan pizza left. Here’s a sales tip: if the vegan slices are selling faster than the regular ones, maybe it’s time to make more of them—you’ll boost your sales that way. Also, a quick note on authenticity: traditional marinara pizza doesn’t include cheese; if it does, it’s actually a margherita.

Village Square Pizza in the West Village is an absolute gem! The slices here are truly unique, standing out from the usual New York pizza spots with their incredible flavor and top-notch ingredients. Every bite is bursting with quality, and you can tell a lot of care goes into each slice. It's underrated compared to the more well-known spots, but that's what makes it even better. If you're looking for a delicious and distinctive pizza experience, this is the place to go. 5/5. Also, open late!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

A decent pizza shop in Greenwich village. ??

Atmosphere: 2

Oscar is the best

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Do not order from this dump, Customer service is non existent, They cant deliver 4 pies 5 blocks away. A complete dumpster fire of a place

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1