not great, food was under seasoned and restaurant was understaffed... i was disappointed as the reviews are glowing.
Anna
Another great time was had at Vinateria...thank you Tom and staff for always making us feel so special...great food, great service...best in Harlem!
Ashley
Fast service and a great drink to start. The grilled octopus was good, but the branzino fell flat and was just okay. Unfortunately, not enough to make me want to come back.
Ray
Fantastic setting where everyone feels like they are at their neighborhood restaurant, because they are.
Lillian
I wish I could give Vinsteria 100 stars across the board. This venue is a place that I almost want to keep it a big secret but at the same time, tell the world because its such a special, magical place. The manager and the servers are the best in any of the restaurants I've ever dined at in my 73 years in NYC. It's the warmth, the attention, the humility, the intimacy, the old-school hospitality from the entire staff that makes you feel like they are serving only you. No matter how busy they are, they always make it work for you. The ambiance is always a quiet energy and you feel like you are dining with friends and family even when dining alone. The quality of the food is phenomenal and I have rarely been disappointed with their suggestions. The wine selection is DIVINE! You could never go wrong here and in warm weather, dining outdoors and people watching adds another flavor to your dining. Vinateria has become my home away from home and one of my all time favorite restaurants in all of NYC.
Brett
We went on NYE and it was lively and tight! Drinks took a while to come to the table and our food was delicious - as people checked out to go to their next destination we were able to really sit back and look forward to the New Year.
Tom
This was our first time here. Sierra was a joyful part of our experience from the first moment we sat down. She had good suggestions and helped us navigate the menus. My manhattan was wonderful, and was stolen by my wife, who had the winning dish of the night with the amazingly tasty and beautiful black ravioli pasta stuffed with lobster. I had a close second with the black spaghetti with scallops and mussels. The sauces were tasty, savory and light. The wine list was good and we enjoyed a delicious white Bordeaux with our meal. I wish I was staying in NYC longer so we could eat there again. Go and enjoy the food, drink and atmosphere!
Rosa
I really love this restaurant. I've been there many times, and it always exceeds my expectations.
John
This is my favorite restaurant in Harlem and one of my top 5 faves in the city. I wouldn't change a thing. I've enjoyed every meal here and look forward to enjoying many more.
Lucy
Vinatería has truly become one of my all-time favorite restaurants. Every time I walk through the doors, I'm greeted with warmth, great energy, and the kind of atmosphere that instantly makes you feel at home. The food is always outstanding — fresh, flavorful, and beautifully presented. The pasta dishes are perfection, the seafood is always cooked just right, and the cocktails and wine list are some of the best in the city. You can tell everything is made with real care and creativity. What really makes Vinatería special, though, is the people. The staff is always so kind, attentive, and welcoming — they remember you, they take time to connect, and they truly make the experience feel personal. That combination of great food, great service, and great vibes is what keeps me coming back again and again. Whether I'm meeting friends for dinner, having a solo night with a glass of wine, or celebrating something special, Vinatería always hits the mark. It's a place with heart, soul, and style — and it's hands-down one of the best dining experiences in Harlem.
Consistently consistent with service, sumptuous food, drinks, ambience and always a wonderful experience. Whether Im enjoying cocktails at the bar or sitting with friends for dinner as I often do, I am guaranteed to enjoy the full experience where all my expectations are met . From the warm welcome to my departure, my time at Vinateria is always a memorable one. I extend my thanks to Tom and staff for their professional and friendly service over the six years that I have been going to Vinateria.
Tobias
Our favorite neighborhood restaurant. Cozy, good food and excellent wine selection with a very friendly staff and a knowledgeable manager. Good for dates and dinner with friends. We are never being rushed and closed the restaurant down at many occasions.
Jacob
We always have a great time at Vinateria! We visit frequently- and the food and drinks are always amazing. Check out their Happy Hour - one of the best in Harlem! They have some vegan friendly dishes- hope to see some new dishes for their Autumn/Winter menu!
Lola
This was an important business meeting, and I wanted everything to be perfect. The staff at Vinateria did not disappoint. I arrived a bit early and gave the Asst GM, Sam, a heads-up. He was lovely and accommodating in every way. Offered one of their best tables and continued to deftly check in without interrupting conversation. The food arrived in a very timely manner, everything was delicious. they even offered a round of drinks on the house. My guest remarked that it was the best experience he's had in Harlem generally. Thanks Vinateria!!! You helped me look like a superstar!!!
james
Happy Hour was divine. Lots of little bites + wine flowing. Loud inside but a good energy.
not great, food was under seasoned and restaurant was understaffed... i was disappointed as the reviews are glowing.
Another great time was had at Vinateria...thank you Tom and staff for always making us feel so special...great food, great service...best in Harlem!
Fast service and a great drink to start. The grilled octopus was good, but the branzino fell flat and was just okay. Unfortunately, not enough to make me want to come back.
Fantastic setting where everyone feels like they are at their neighborhood restaurant, because they are.
I wish I could give Vinsteria 100 stars across the board. This venue is a place that I almost want to keep it a big secret but at the same time, tell the world because its such a special, magical place. The manager and the servers are the best in any of the restaurants I've ever dined at in my 73 years in NYC. It's the warmth, the attention, the humility, the intimacy, the old-school hospitality from the entire staff that makes you feel like they are serving only you. No matter how busy they are, they always make it work for you. The ambiance is always a quiet energy and you feel like you are dining with friends and family even when dining alone. The quality of the food is phenomenal and I have rarely been disappointed with their suggestions. The wine selection is DIVINE! You could never go wrong here and in warm weather, dining outdoors and people watching adds another flavor to your dining. Vinateria has become my home away from home and one of my all time favorite restaurants in all of NYC.
We went on NYE and it was lively and tight! Drinks took a while to come to the table and our food was delicious - as people checked out to go to their next destination we were able to really sit back and look forward to the New Year.
This was our first time here. Sierra was a joyful part of our experience from the first moment we sat down. She had good suggestions and helped us navigate the menus. My manhattan was wonderful, and was stolen by my wife, who had the winning dish of the night with the amazingly tasty and beautiful black ravioli pasta stuffed with lobster. I had a close second with the black spaghetti with scallops and mussels. The sauces were tasty, savory and light. The wine list was good and we enjoyed a delicious white Bordeaux with our meal. I wish I was staying in NYC longer so we could eat there again. Go and enjoy the food, drink and atmosphere!
I really love this restaurant. I've been there many times, and it always exceeds my expectations.
This is my favorite restaurant in Harlem and one of my top 5 faves in the city. I wouldn't change a thing. I've enjoyed every meal here and look forward to enjoying many more.
Vinatería has truly become one of my all-time favorite restaurants. Every time I walk through the doors, I'm greeted with warmth, great energy, and the kind of atmosphere that instantly makes you feel at home. The food is always outstanding — fresh, flavorful, and beautifully presented. The pasta dishes are perfection, the seafood is always cooked just right, and the cocktails and wine list are some of the best in the city. You can tell everything is made with real care and creativity. What really makes Vinatería special, though, is the people. The staff is always so kind, attentive, and welcoming — they remember you, they take time to connect, and they truly make the experience feel personal. That combination of great food, great service, and great vibes is what keeps me coming back again and again. Whether I'm meeting friends for dinner, having a solo night with a glass of wine, or celebrating something special, Vinatería always hits the mark. It's a place with heart, soul, and style — and it's hands-down one of the best dining experiences in Harlem.
Restaurantji Recommends
Consistently consistent with service, sumptuous food, drinks, ambience and always a wonderful experience. Whether Im enjoying cocktails at the bar or sitting with friends for dinner as I often do, I am guaranteed to enjoy the full experience where all my expectations are met . From the warm welcome to my departure, my time at Vinateria is always a memorable one. I extend my thanks to Tom and staff for their professional and friendly service over the six years that I have been going to Vinateria.
Our favorite neighborhood restaurant. Cozy, good food and excellent wine selection with a very friendly staff and a knowledgeable manager. Good for dates and dinner with friends. We are never being rushed and closed the restaurant down at many occasions.
We always have a great time at Vinateria! We visit frequently- and the food and drinks are always amazing. Check out their Happy Hour - one of the best in Harlem! They have some vegan friendly dishes- hope to see some new dishes for their Autumn/Winter menu!
This was an important business meeting, and I wanted everything to be perfect. The staff at Vinateria did not disappoint. I arrived a bit early and gave the Asst GM, Sam, a heads-up. He was lovely and accommodating in every way. Offered one of their best tables and continued to deftly check in without interrupting conversation. The food arrived in a very timely manner, everything was delicious. they even offered a round of drinks on the house. My guest remarked that it was the best experience he's had in Harlem generally. Thanks Vinateria!!! You helped me look like a superstar!!!
Happy Hour was divine. Lots of little bites + wine flowing. Loud inside but a good energy.
Loading...