I was so disappointed in the pizza here. It looked and smelled delicious but the cheese was terrible. Biitter and with an odd aftertaste. I got the white pizza so maybe sauce would have helped? In any case, i won't be back. :-(
Mike O.
Really good pizza lots of creative flavors. $3 short beer $5 house salad. Very fresh. Great food great value
Kyle S.
Ordered this pizza following such amazing reviews... pizzas were severely overcooked, delivery took forever, and they did not follow the order. Will never order from here again.
Aimee B.
We got to our hotel room late and this was around the corner and we could pick up the order pretty quickly. We ordered a small cheese for the kids and a medium pepperoni and mushroom for us. The flavor was bitter/salty cheese and the sauce was almost non existent. I was able to get one slice in to get some food in my and the kids also each did one slice. They asked us to take the pizza out of the room since it was smelly. I can't recommend this place knowing how many pizza places there are around the area.
Mia B.
All I've wanted in NYC is a build-your-own pizza spot that's quick, convenient, and comes in a personal size.... And I found exactly that at Waldy's! I've walked past this building multiple times in search of a quick, Midtown lunch but it came up on my radar after an intentional search. I created my own pie, added FREE anchovies on top, and was out in less than 5 minutes. Seeing as how my lunch was the talk of the office, I'll be back very soon!
Joseph Zodda
The pizza is thin here but excellent. The crust tasted better than most. Cheese and sauce also high quality. The small size was fine for a big guy like myself and it was under 10 bucks for a pie with 2 toppings. Would go again in a heart beat.
Allie S.
Not your typical NY pizza slice of place. However it was near my hotel on a rainy day so I gave them a chance. The pizza are personal size on a very thin crust. I had the margherita which was freshly prepared and baked after ordering. While the pizza is okay if given a choice I'd rather get a slice for cheap elsewhere. While service is friendly the place is small so you most likely will have to do a to-go order.
Monte A.
So good I forgot to take pic. 10 miles of Manhattan walking and I needed a couple beers. Got a braised lamb pizza and added jalapenos. Damn!!! So nice. Downed a coupleMontauks, charged the phone, and gift the road. I'll be back...if I'm lucky.
90CathyMac
Freshly made delicious wood fired pizza, friendly service what more could you want $10 for a pitcher of beer, not bad in New York.
Maurice
The pizzas are really good and taste nothing like the other pizzas places around. This is my main go-to when I feel like having pizza. The staff is friendly as well.
Perfectly cooked thin crust pizza, I ordered the pepperoni and half way through the cook I asked for goat cheese and wasn’t charged(made sure to tip well). Great service and the pizza was as good as it gets
Polly Anywhere
We always have their pizzas delivered. The pizzas are freshly baked and yummy yummy yum. Every single one tastes good. Also love the caesar salad!!
Amy Colorado
Everything looked so good, but sadly the pizza was SO salty it was difficult to eat. I don’t know what cheese they use, but it’s so so salty it makes the pizza inedible. We got a classic and margarita so maybe it was what we ordered ¯\_(ツ)_/¯ the salads are delicious and fresh!
Brandt Callahan
Flatbread pizza is the tops...wow! And the penne pasta was very tasty. Great service, and flavorful dishes, what more can you ask for! If you are near this area while visiting NYC, you can't go wrong here.
Mary P
The personal pizzas are delish. Fast service and great staff. We went back several times. Great menu and although it was often crowded, the line moves quickly and we always found a place to sit.
I was so disappointed in the pizza here. It looked and smelled delicious but the cheese was terrible. Biitter and with an odd aftertaste. I got the white pizza so maybe sauce would have helped? In any case, i won't be back. :-(
Really good pizza lots of creative flavors. $3 short beer $5 house salad. Very fresh. Great food great value
Ordered this pizza following such amazing reviews... pizzas were severely overcooked, delivery took forever, and they did not follow the order. Will never order from here again.
We got to our hotel room late and this was around the corner and we could pick up the order pretty quickly. We ordered a small cheese for the kids and a medium pepperoni and mushroom for us. The flavor was bitter/salty cheese and the sauce was almost non existent. I was able to get one slice in to get some food in my and the kids also each did one slice. They asked us to take the pizza out of the room since it was smelly. I can't recommend this place knowing how many pizza places there are around the area.
All I've wanted in NYC is a build-your-own pizza spot that's quick, convenient, and comes in a personal size.... And I found exactly that at Waldy's! I've walked past this building multiple times in search of a quick, Midtown lunch but it came up on my radar after an intentional search. I created my own pie, added FREE anchovies on top, and was out in less than 5 minutes. Seeing as how my lunch was the talk of the office, I'll be back very soon!
The pizza is thin here but excellent. The crust tasted better than most. Cheese and sauce also high quality. The small size was fine for a big guy like myself and it was under 10 bucks for a pie with 2 toppings. Would go again in a heart beat.
Not your typical NY pizza slice of place. However it was near my hotel on a rainy day so I gave them a chance. The pizza are personal size on a very thin crust. I had the margherita which was freshly prepared and baked after ordering. While the pizza is okay if given a choice I'd rather get a slice for cheap elsewhere. While service is friendly the place is small so you most likely will have to do a to-go order.
So good I forgot to take pic. 10 miles of Manhattan walking and I needed a couple beers. Got a braised lamb pizza and added jalapenos. Damn!!! So nice. Downed a coupleMontauks, charged the phone, and gift the road. I'll be back...if I'm lucky.
Freshly made delicious wood fired pizza, friendly service what more could you want $10 for a pitcher of beer, not bad in New York.
The pizzas are really good and taste nothing like the other pizzas places around. This is my main go-to when I feel like having pizza. The staff is friendly as well.
Restaurantji Recommends
Perfectly cooked thin crust pizza, I ordered the pepperoni and half way through the cook I asked for goat cheese and wasn’t charged(made sure to tip well). Great service and the pizza was as good as it gets
We always have their pizzas delivered. The pizzas are freshly baked and yummy yummy yum. Every single one tastes good. Also love the caesar salad!!
Everything looked so good, but sadly the pizza was SO salty it was difficult to eat. I don’t know what cheese they use, but it’s so so salty it makes the pizza inedible. We got a classic and margarita so maybe it was what we ordered ¯\_(ツ)_/¯ the salads are delicious and fresh!
Flatbread pizza is the tops...wow! And the penne pasta was very tasty. Great service, and flavorful dishes, what more can you ask for! If you are near this area while visiting NYC, you can't go wrong here.
The personal pizzas are delish. Fast service and great staff. We went back several times. Great menu and although it was often crowded, the line moves quickly and we always found a place to sit.