We visited this bar on our last trip to NYC and had a great, memorable experience. Our hostess, Luna, was attentive and had great recommendations for us, which made our visit even more enjoyable. We were excited to return, but unfortunately this recent experience fell short of our expectations and left us disappointed…beyond disappointing. As a result, we won’t be coming back and would not recommend it. We ended up at The Red Lion next door instead, and it was well worth it. The service there is fantastic and, most importantly, consistent.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
John Conway
Food was okay. I ordered the wings. I visited here twice. The last time they applied a tip to my final bill without my consent and at a ridiculously high percentage. I went ahead and tipped not knowing this until I checked my cards account. This practice is a non-starter for me so I will not be visiting this establishment again. There are plenty of other choices in the area so do yourself a favor and walk on by Wicked Willy's if you're ever in the neighborhood.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 3
Service: 3
Rob
Certainly better than average pub food! Very convenient if you're heading for music upstairs.
Melissa
My boyfriend and I were in the city for the holiday and looking for a brunch option on a Friday. Wicked Willy's was not busy but still a fun atmosphere with delicious food and build your own spritz carafe deals!
Julian George
Loved the salmon
Food: 5
Service: 5
viki akki
Great bar. I came here for Emo Night and the music was great!!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
aya
I really hope that tips are shared here because the guy that was supposed to be my “server” came to me one time the whole night and never followed up. The girl that was serving the table next to me was the only one following up with me and event took my payment. The guy that was supposed to be my server walked up at the end of the show to see had had paid and never asked anything else didn’t even say anything just threw the pos in my face. I am a server as well and genuinely don’t think he deserved a tip the only reason i tipped was on the principal that they may have been shared. when he noticed i had already paid he gave a thumbs up and walked away… strange. I go to a lot of watch parties and the vibe of this was one was off .
Jeffrey Flores
Few things wrong with the place 1. They have $5 drinks if you post a BeReal for them. I was asking our server Diana the options for $5 drinks and as she was listing them I picked the mango marg. She brings us our drinks and I show her my post and tells me I was supposed to tell her earlier. I replied back with “we were literally discussing the BeReal drink options” when I told her I’d want that one. She says no worries I’ll get the overcharge canceled. At the end of the hangout when we ask for the check is when she says her manager said they couldn’t void the charge(it’s not like it’s difficult to void a charge). And then for whatever reason she’s like I’m so sorry ☹️ would you like another drink 😃. Like no first you overcharge me, waited too long to tell me, and we’re checking out asking for the bill why would I get another drink. 2. They handed out these seasonal menus and everything we tried ordering was apparently sold out for the season. Not sure why they would hand them out then to begin with 3. We wanted to keep a menu for the table and apparently this place is so stingy they don’t have enough menus to go around.
Overall bad service and high prices not worth checking out or going too. Nothing stood out about this place.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Nicole Gibson
Initially, I visited for brunch between 11:00 a.m. and 4:00 p.m., as the website did not specify that brunch service is exclusively available from Friday to Sunday. This was quite disappointing after a considerable journey. Additionally, we ordered a mega watermelon punch, but the alcoholic content seemed negligible. Furthermore, for a watermelon-based drink, its color was not as vibrant pink as anticipated. On a positive note, the overall ambiance was very serene. My friend and I attempted to use the pole, but its surface was excessively dry, almost causing friction burns when attempting to slide down. Finally, encountering a bartender who admits to not knowing how to prepare drinks is a significant concern for an establishment of this nature.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 2
Pam Buss
We stopped in for a drink prior to dinner reservations. We sat at the bar. We wish we could have stayed. The vibe was fun and the drinks were strong!
This place was dead by 12AM. If you are looking for something at late night look elsewhere
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 3
Andrea Vargas
The place is really good, we ordered our drinks and food and we were satisfied with it, we wanted to share and enjoy a while and the place was ideal for that, we will definitely come back later ☺️
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
jennifer
We didn't realize this is more of a bar. I would not go here for dinner, specifically. The service was awful. Our waiter took the order and then we never saw him again. Had to get up and ask other staff for drinks. The food was fair, at best. You go here to drink not for dinner.
Liam
very good on sunday night karaoke
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Mackenzie
Fishbowl always hits, food is good in the moment, but really makes my stomach hurt. I like the rotating cocktails and new things on the menu when I return here quarterly.
We visited this bar on our last trip to NYC and had a great, memorable experience. Our hostess, Luna, was attentive and had great recommendations for us, which made our visit even more enjoyable. We were excited to return, but unfortunately this recent experience fell short of our expectations and left us disappointed…beyond disappointing. As a result, we won’t be coming back and would not recommend it.
We ended up at The Red Lion next door instead, and it was well worth it. The service there is fantastic and, most importantly, consistent.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Food was okay. I ordered the wings. I visited here twice. The last time they applied a tip to my final bill without my consent and at a ridiculously high percentage. I went ahead and tipped not knowing this until I checked my cards account. This practice is a non-starter for me so I will not be visiting this establishment again. There are plenty of other choices in the area so do yourself a favor and walk on by Wicked Willy's if you're ever in the neighborhood.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 3
Service: 3
Certainly better than average pub food! Very convenient if you're heading for music upstairs.
My boyfriend and I were in the city for the holiday and looking for a brunch option on a Friday. Wicked Willy's was not busy but still a fun atmosphere with delicious food and build your own spritz carafe deals!
Loved the salmon
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great bar. I came here for Emo Night and the music was great!!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
I really hope that tips are shared here because the guy that was supposed to be my “server” came to me one time the whole night and never followed up. The girl that was serving the table next to me was the only one following up with me and event took my payment. The guy that was supposed to be my server walked up at the end of the show to see had had paid and never asked anything else didn’t even say anything just threw the pos in my face. I am a server as well and genuinely don’t think he deserved a tip the only reason i tipped was on the principal that they may have been shared. when he noticed i had already paid he gave a thumbs up and walked away… strange. I go to a lot of watch parties and the vibe of this was one was off .
Few things wrong with the place
1. They have $5 drinks if you post a BeReal for them. I was asking our server Diana the options for $5 drinks and as she was listing them I picked the mango marg. She brings us our drinks and I show her my post and tells me I was supposed to tell her earlier. I replied back with “we were literally discussing the BeReal drink options” when I told her I’d want that one. She says no worries I’ll get the overcharge canceled. At the end of the hangout when we ask for the check is when she says her manager said they couldn’t void the charge(it’s not like it’s difficult to void a charge). And then for whatever reason she’s like I’m so sorry ☹️ would you like another drink 😃. Like no first you overcharge me, waited too long to tell me, and we’re checking out asking for the bill why would I get another drink.
2. They handed out these seasonal menus and everything we tried ordering was apparently sold out for the season. Not sure why they would hand them out then to begin with
3. We wanted to keep a menu for the table and apparently this place is so stingy they don’t have enough menus to go around.
Overall bad service and high prices not worth checking out or going too. Nothing stood out about this place.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Initially, I visited for brunch between 11:00 a.m. and 4:00 p.m., as the website did not specify that brunch service is exclusively available from Friday to Sunday. This was quite disappointing after a considerable journey. Additionally, we ordered a mega watermelon punch, but the alcoholic content seemed negligible. Furthermore, for a watermelon-based drink, its color was not as vibrant pink as anticipated. On a positive note, the overall ambiance was very serene. My friend and I attempted to use the pole, but its surface was excessively dry, almost causing friction burns when attempting to slide down. Finally, encountering a bartender who admits to not knowing how to prepare drinks is a significant concern for an establishment of this nature.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 2
We stopped in for a drink prior to dinner reservations. We sat at the bar. We wish we could have stayed. The vibe was fun and the drinks were strong!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
This place was dead by 12AM. If you are looking for something at late night look elsewhere
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 3
The place is really good, we ordered our drinks and food and we were satisfied with it, we wanted to share and enjoy a while and the place was ideal for that, we will definitely come back later ☺️
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
We didn't realize this is more of a bar. I would not go here for dinner, specifically. The service was awful. Our waiter took the order and then we never saw him again. Had to get up and ask other staff for drinks. The food was fair, at best. You go here to drink not for dinner.
very good on sunday night karaoke
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Fishbowl always hits, food is good in the moment, but really makes my stomach hurt. I like the rotating cocktails and new things on the menu when I return here quarterly.
Loading...