Williamsburg Pizza
1617 2nd Ave, New York
(212) 457-3114
Customers' Favorites
Paesano and Brooklyn Slice
Williamsburg Pizza UES
Cup & Char Pepperoni
Williamsburg Pizza
Cup & Char Grandma
The Brooklyn Pizza
Sophia Loren lg
Margarita Pie
Vegan Slice
Vegan Pizza
Menu
Photos
+52 photos
+51 photos
Add a photo
Recent Reviews
Consistent quality & heats up well the next day. I always get the vegan pepperoni pizza. This is one of the only spots I've found that does vegan cheese/pepperoni well-I almost couldn't tell the difference the first time I got it. The garlic knots are great too.
The pizza is good and is massive for the price you pay so pretty good value - I had maybe 5 or 6 meals from the large pizza, whereas at other places I might get 2 meals from a large pizza so keep that in mind. Flavors were immaculate. Only improvement I would suggest is to get the under crust a bit more well cooked so that it has some crunch to it. I found the crust to be too soggy so I just baked it a bit in my oven to my desired crunch level and it was perfect.
We ordered the gluten-free, dairy-free cheese version. The sauce and pepperoni are great. The cheese and meatballs were okay, but need more seasonings. If we had eaten in the restaurant we would’ve used Parmesan & red pepper flakes, etc. But, we ordered thru DoorDash. The gluten-free crust is super crunchy & thin, but, overall we enjoyed it.
You May Also Like
Green Kitchen - 1619 2nd Ave
![]()
American, Cocktail Bar, Pet Friendly, Vegan, Vegetarian
Elio's - 1621 2nd Ave
![]()
Italian
Hummus Kitchen - 1613 2nd Ave
![]()
Mediterranean, Vegetarian, Kosher, Vegan