YORK AVE PIZZA
434 E 72nd St, New York
(212) 744-4000
Customers' Favorites
Drunkside Down Sicilian Pizza
Fresh Prince Pan Pizza Slice
Pepperoni Sicilian Pizza
Buffalo Chicken Hero
Drunk Grandma Pizza
Upside Down Pizza
Pepperoni Lovers
Slice of Grandma
Slice of Rita
Pizza & More
Pizza
Drunk-a-Roni Pizza
Fresh Mozzarella, our signature house vodka sauce with spicy pepperoni topped with vodka sauce
Drunkside Down Sicilian
Calabrian chili vodka sauce on top fresh mozzarella on the bottom thick square fresh mozzarella on the bottom
Drunk Grandma Pizza
12 slice vodka sauce (marinara, cream, contains proscuitto and fresh basil)
Brooklyn Square Pizza Small (8)
8 slice brooklyn style
Sicilian with cheese on bottom and our special sauce on top
York Ave Twister Pizza (18")
Pesto, vodka, and fresh mozzarella.
Pepperoni Lover Pizza (18")
Sweet pepperoni, spicy pepperoni, our special sauce and premium mozzarella
Crazy Grandma Square Pizza
Thin square with fresh mozzarella, grandma sauce, vodka sauce and our pesto sauce (without nuts)
Pepperoni Detroit Square Pizza (10 slices)
8 slice square pie toppings upsidedown, pepperoni garlic cheese & sauce on top
DETROIT Lil' Cesar (sausage, green peppers, mushrooms)
Thick square with sauce & our premium cheese to the edges topped with Crumbled sweet sausage, green bell peppers & mushrooms
"The Rita" Pizza 18"
Fresh mozzarella, marinated plum tomato, drizzled with extra virgin olive oil, cracked black pepper and fresh basil
Fresh Prince Pan Pizza (18")
Pepperoni cups and fresh mozzarella.
Detroit Veg
Thick square with cheese to the edges, topped with mushrooms, green bell peppers and olives and our special sauce on the bottom
Grateful Bread Pizza Large 18"
Pizza, pesto and vodka sauce with fresh mozzarella a tie-dye style pizza
Supreme Pizza 18"
Sexy pepperoni, jersey honey ham, our marinated mushrooms and bell peppers premium mozzarella and our special pizza sauce
C P R Pizza 18"
Our panko breaded chicken cutlet, sexy pepperoni and our premium mozzarella drizzled with buttermilk ranch dressing
Regular Pizza
Classic cheese or create your own pizza.
Detroit Pizza PLAIN (10 slices)
deep dish detroit style tavern pizza with cheese to the edges crispy and sauce
10" Little Gluten Free Pizza
Gluten free personal Little Pizza
Sausage & Onion Pizza
Crumbled italian sausage, sauteed onions, our special pizza sauce and premium mozzarella
PEPPERS & ONIONS Detroit Style Pizza Backwards (10 slices)
Thick square with cheese to the edge cooked to a crispy butter brown with peppers & onions with garlic our signature pizza sauce and premium cheese on top
All White Pizza (18")
Fresh mozzarella, Romano, and premium mozzarella.
Sicilian Pizza (8 slice)
8 slice square with our special pizza sauce, pecorino romano & our premium mozzarella
"The Ray" Pan Pizza
Cooked to golden brown pan pizza with crumbled italian sausage, pecorino romano, classic pepperoni and our special pizza sauce
Mushroom & Jalapeno
Marinated mushrooms & jalapeno with top quality mozzarella and our special pizza sauce
Buffalo Chicken Pizza (18")
Drizzled with Gorgonzola dressing and parsley.
Meat Lover (Pepperoni, Sausage & Bacon
pepperoni, crumbled sausage and hickory bacon with our premium mozzarella and our special pizza sauce
Grandma Square Pizza
12slice fresh mozzarella with our sweet tangy garlicy delicious sauce and fresh basil
The "CBR" Pizza
Hickory smoked bacon, grilled chicken, top quality mozzarella drizzled with buttermilk ranch and parsley
Upsidedown Sicilian
Sauce on top fresh mozzarella on the bottom thick square 8 slice!
Buffalo Bacon Ranch 18"
Our buffalo chicken topped with hickory bacon and drizzled with buttermilk ranch with our premium mozzarella
10" Cauliflower Pizza
Cauliflower crust with our special sauce & premium cheese
Buffalo Roni Ranch Large 18"
Our buffalo chicken with sexy pepperoni drizzled with our buttermilk ranch dressing and premium mozzarella
Pizza by the Slice
Slice Long Island Buffalo Chicken Detroit
A square detroit with a long island flare topped with our premium mozzarella, buffalo chicken, celery, blanched red onion, jalapeno and drizzled with gorgonzola bleu cheese dressing and parsley garnish
SLICE Regular Pizza (1 sl)
Slice DRUNKside Down
Fresh mozzarella on bottom calabrian chili infused vodka sauce on top
Slice of Grandma
Thin square, fresh mozzarella, grandma sauce and fresh basil
Slice Crazy Grandma
Slice Drunk GMA
Grandma square with our housemade vodka sauce
Buffalo Chicken SLICE
Drizzled with Gorgonzola dressing and parsley.
Fresh Prince SLICE
Hand cutPepperoni cups, fresh mozzarella deep dish pan pizza slice
Pepperoni Lover SLICE
Fresh pepperoni cups, classic pepperoni, our special pizza sauce and our premium mozzarella
THE RITA SLICE
Our rendition of the margherita
fresh mozzarella, our special saucen, marinated plum tomato and fresh basil
Slice CBR
our housemade grilled chicken, hickory bacon, premium mozzarella drizzled with buttermilk ranch
All White SLICE
Fresh mozzarella, Romano, and premium mozzarella.
Slice UpsideDown
Square sicilian with fresh mozzarella on bottom pizza sauce on top!
Slice Sicilian
Slice Chicken Caesar Pizza
Regular with mozzarella and garlic topped with chicken caesar salad!
Slice Drunk-A-Roni DEEP DISH
A deep dish pan pizza slice with our vodka sauce fresh mozzarella and topped with hand cut pepperoni
Slice of Buffalo-Roni Ranch
Our buffalo chicken topped with our hand cut pepperoni drizzled with buttermilk ranch with our premium mozzarella
Slice Drunken Chicken
Fresh mozzarella our vodka sauce and panko breaded chicken cutlet
Slice Grateful Bread
A combination of pizza, pesto & vodka sauce with fresh mozzarella! (A tie dye style pizza)
Spinach Roll
Sauteed spinach, garlic, ricotta & fresh mozzarella (Pizza Roll)
Pepperoni Roll
Spicy and sweet pepperoni with our special pizza sauce and premium mozzarella (Pizza Roll)
Chicken Roll
Panko breaded chicken cutlet, our special pizza sauce and our premium mozzarella (Pizza Roll)
Hot Dog Roll
Beef frank with mozzarella
Sausage Roll
Sweet sausage, sauteed peppers and onions mozzarella & pizza sauce
Eggplant Roll
Our pan fried Eggplant, pizza sauce, ricotta and our premium mozzarella
Slice C P R Chicken Pep Ranch
Topped with our panko chicken cutlet, hand cut pepperoni and buttermilk ranch with our premium mozzarella
Appetizers
York Ave Mozzarella Stix
6pc our premium mozzarella breaded and fried to perfection with our marinara dipping sauce
Chicken Tenders & Fries
House made panko breaded chicken with french fries served with buttermilk ranch
Buffalo Wings
Please specify flavor, buffalo mild bbq or mango habanero
Toasted Garlic Hero
Semolina hero with extra virgin olive oil and garlic baked in oven cut in 3 served with marinara sauce
Chips & Guacamole
Made in house, fried tortilla chips with guacamole and pico to Gallo
Garlic Knots (4)
Dough tied into knots baked with olive oil and tossed with garlic parsley and pecorino romano cheese
French Fries
Tossed with salt & black pepper
Mozzarella Caprese Appetizer
Side of Meatballs Reggiano
Served with shaved parmigiano reggiano and marinara sauce with basil !
Garlic Fries
Our fries tossed with fresh minced Garlic extra virgin olive oil , salt, black pepper and topped with shaved Reggiano Parmigiano
Cheese Fries
Our french fries with sea salt & cracked black pepper melted mozzarella
Chicken Rice Soup
Made in house!
Lentil Soup
Made in house!
Tortelloni en Brodo Soup
Tortellini soup in a chicken broth
Salads
York Ave Salad
Panko chicken cutlet, avocado, fresh mozzarella, tomato, roasted pepper over romaine with creamy balsamic.
Caesar Salad
Romaine, tomato, shaved Parmesan, housemade garlic croutons, and our creamy Caesar dressing.
Greco Salad
Greek feta, Kalamata olives, tomato, cucumbers, chickpeas, pepperoncini peppers, green pepper, and red onion over romaine, served with Greek dressing.
House Salad
fresh mozzarella pearls, cucumber, red onion, tomato over romaine served with house dressing
Arugula Salad
Tomato, red onion, shaved Parmesan, extra virgin olive oil & sea salt over arugula greens
Chicken Arugula Salad
Marinated sliced grilled chicken, red onion, shaved parmesan, plum tomato, sea salt & extra virgin olive oil over arugula greens
Caprese Salad
Housemade sweet roasted red peppers, plum tomato, fresh basil, fresh mozzarella tossed in our red win vinaigrette
AntiPasto Salad
Romaine lettuce, imported proscuitto, jersey honey ham, sweet pepperoni, fresh mozzarella, plum tomato, kalamata olives, banana peppers & red onions
Californiano Salad
Romaine, pico de gallo, avocado, fresh mozzarella and breaded chicken cutlet served with creamy balsamic
Pasta
Chicken Parmigiana with Ziti
Our panko breaded chicken cutlet
With our marinara sauce and melted mozzarella served with ziti marinara with fresh basil
Chicken Francese over Fettucine
An egg batter dipped sauteed chicken breast in a white wine lemon butter sauce over fettucine
Chicken Marsala over Ziti
A sauteed chicken breast in a brown marsala wine sauce with mushrooms
Penne Alla Vodka with Breaded Chicken
Pink cream sauce with vodka proscuitto fresh basil topped with breaded chicken cutlet!
Penne alla Vodka
Marinara, vodka, cream, prosciutto, and fresh basil.
Spaghetti Broccoli
Sautéed with garlic and olive oil.
Eggplant Parmigiana with Spaghetti
Baked Penne al Forno
Ricotta, marinara, fresh basil, and melted mozzarella.
Spaghetti Marinara
Spaghetti Bolognese
Our ground beef sauce cooked in red wine and a touch of bay leaf over spaghetti marinara
Lasagna Americano
Pasta sheets layered with ricotta, ground beef and mozzarella topped with melted mozzarella & our marinara sauce
Penne Quattro Formaggio
Marinara, cream, and 4-cheese blend.
Penne alla Vodka with Shrimp
Shrimp in a Marinara, cream, proscuitto, & fresh basil sauce
Penne al Fredo
White cheese cream sauce
Spaghetti Meatballs
Our meatballs over spaghetti with marinara and fresh basil.
Penne Gamberi (Shrimp)
Shrimp in a sauce with marinara, cream and fresh basil
Spaghetti Marinero Diavolo (shrimp & calamari)
Shrimp and calamari in a spicy marinara sauce
Tortelloni alla Vodka
Hat shaped ricotta filled pasta in a sauce with marinara cream fresh basil & proscuitto!
Fettucine Alfredo
White cream sauce with cheese and topped with fresh ground black pepper
Drunk Chicken Parmigiana with Spaghetti Marinara
Panko breaded chicken cutlet topped with vodka sauce and melted fresh mozzarella served with spaghetti marinara
Baked Ziti al Forno
Ziti pasta with ricotta, marinara, fresh basil
And topped with melted mozzarella and marinara
Spaghetti Diavolo (Shrimp)
Shrimp a spicy marinara sauce with calabrian chili and fresh basil
Penne Carbone
Penne in a spicy calabrian chili vodka sauce!
Eggplant Rollatini with Penne Arrabiata
Our fried eggplant rolled with ricotta topped with melted mozzarella and marinara sauce Served with spaghetti in a spicy marinara sauce with jalapeno!
Heros
Buffalo Chicken Wrap with French Fries
Buffalo tossed Panko breaded chicken cutlet, shaved parmesan, mozzarella, romaine lettuce tomato, red onion in a whole wheat wrap
OLD FASHIONED Meatball Parm Hero
Our house made beef meatballs, fresh mozzarella, marinara sauce and fresh basil on a toasted garlic semolina hero
Chicken Parmigiana Hero
Panko Breaded chicken cutlet, melted mozzarella, and our marinara sauce on a toasted semolina hero
Chicken Caesar Wrap with French Fries
Whole wheat wrap with tomato, romaine lettuce romaine, shaved parmesan and our housemade caesar dressing
Sophia Hero (no meat)
Fresh mozzarella, housemade roasted red pepper, tomato, arugula, and creamy balsamic dressing on a toasted semolina hero
Gallina Hero
Panko Breaded chicken cutlet, imported prosciutto, fresh mozzarella, lettuce, tomato, herb mayo, and house made balsamic glaze.l
Meatball Parmigiana Hero
Meatballs, marinara, and melted mozzarella.
Eggplant Parmigiana Hero
Our egg batter dipped Fried eggplant, marinara sauce and melted premium mozzarella on a toasted semolina hero
York Ave Hero
Panko breaded Chicken cutlet, fresh mozzarella, avocado, lettuce, tomato, and herb mayo on a toasted semolina hero
Buffalo Chicken Hero
Buffalo tossed panno breased chicken cutlet, Gorgonzola bleu cheese dressing, lettuce, tomato, and red onion on a toasted semolina hero
Californiano Wrap with French Fries
Whole wheat wrap with breaded chicken, fresh mozzarella, housemade pico de gallo, lettuce, avocado & mayo!
The Primo Hero
Panko Breaded chicken cutlet, avocado, tomato, red onion, fresh mozzarella with calabrian chili mayo
Barbie Hero
Marinated grilled chicken, bbq sauce, hickory bacon, melted mozzarella, lettuce, plum tomato bbq sauce & mayo on a toasted semolina hero
Italian Sausage Hero
Sweet italian sausage, sauteed peppers & onions in a light marinara sauce with fresh basil
Vincenzo Hero
Prosciutto, arugula, shaved Parmesan, roasted pepper, tomato balsamic glaze, and olive oil.
Chicken de Gallo Hero
Our panko breaded chicken cutlet, pico de gallo with melted mozzarella and mayo
Drunk Chicken Parm Hero
Panko breaded chicken cutlet vodka sauce and melted fresh mozzarella on a toasted semolina hero
Buffalo Chicken Bacon Ranch Hero
Panko breaded chicken cutlet, hickory bacon, buttermilk ranch lettuce and tomato on a toasted semolina hero!
Chicken Margharita PANINI with Greek Fries
Panko breaded chicken cutlet, melted fresh mozzarella, tomato & fresh basil on our housemade pressed panini bread
Served with Greek Fries oregano & sea salt
Californiano PANINI with Cajun Fries
Panko breaded chicken cutlet, melted fresh mozzarella, pico de gallo, and mayo on our housemade panini bread pressed!
Servied with our cajun seasoned fries
Chicken Club Panini with Cajun Fries
Panko breaded chicken cutlet, hickory bacon, American cheese, lettuce, tomato and calabrian chili mayo in a pressed housemade panini bread
Served with our cajun seasoned fries
72 Panini with Greek Fries
Grilled chicken, bacon, fresh mozzarella, plum tomato, red onion fresh basil
And calabrian chili mayo in our pressed housemade panini bread
Desserts
Nutella Bombomlone Donuts (3)
Black & White Cookie
Tiramisu
Ladyfinger cookies, soaked in our house espresso layered with sweet mascaparone cheese topped with cocoa powder
New York Cheesecake
Crumb Cake
Not too sweet with a touch of cinnamon!
Zeppole with Powdered Sugar
Topped with powdered sugar.
Greek Rice Pudding
Vanilla and cinnamon
Cold Coffee & Espresso
Iced Greek Frappe
Iced Chai Latte
Iced Freddo Espresso
Greek style whipped espresso.
Iced NY Drip Coffee
Iced Freddo Cappuccino
Greek style whipped espresso, whipped milk, and topped with cinnamon.
Iced Latte
Iced Dirty Chai Latte
Iced double shot espresso and chai over milk
Iced Americano
Espresso over ice water
Iced Pumpkin Latte
Iced double espresso shots over milk with pumpkin flavor
Iced Peppermin Latte
Iced Caramel Latte with Whipped Cream
Iced Mocha Latte with Whipped Cream & Nutella
Hot Coffee & Espresso
Cappuccino
NY Drip Coffee
Latte
Macchiato
Espresso with 2 spoons of foamed milk
Cortado
Flat White
Chai Latte
Hot Tea
English Breakfast, Wild Raspberry Hibiscus, Chamomile or Mint
Nutella Hot Chocolate
Nutella, real cocoa & steamed milk
Peppermint Latte
Pumpkin Spice Latte
Baked
Butter Croissant
Classic buttery croissant.
Beverages
Can of Soda
Coke, Diet Coke, Sprite, A&W Root Beer, Canada Dry Ginger Ale, Pepsi, Diet Pepsi, Pepsi Max, Mtn Dew, Crush Orange, dr Browns Black Cherry
Snapple Tea
Fruit Punch, Mango Madness, Apple, Lemon Tea, Peach Tea, Kiwi Strawberry,
Lemon Tea Zero, Peach Tea Zero, Raspberry Tea Zero
Poland Spring Water
Hal's Seltzer
20oz
Original, Lime or Black Cherry
Gatorade
Fruit Punch, Lemon Lime, Orange, Cool Blue or Fierce Grape
San Pellegrino Can
Limonata,
Melograno Pomegranate,
Pompelino grapefruit
Rossa Blood Orange,
Aranciata Orange
Or
Fico D'India Prickly Pear
Boylans Soda
Classic Glass bottle root beer or cane cola
Essentia Water
20oz
Photos
+17 photos
+16 photos
Add a photo
Recent Reviews
Came here with two elderly family members. They gave us menus and we were able to take our time and order. The staff was happy, nice, and the food suggestions were delicious. My mom and aunt had a BEC (Bacon,Egg,Cheese) on brioche. The serving size was perfect, and my mom and aunt said it tasted good. One of the cooks suggested a pizza that had breaded chicken slices and jalapeños (for me) and...I have never tasted something like that. It was good! I highly recommend. Overall,...
August 2025
I grew up in Canarsie but have been on the Island for decades and needed my tried and true NYC pizza fix. York Ave did not disappoint and totally hit the spot. Thank you (I'll be back)!!!
August 2025
Wow! Okay I work around the area and my coworker told me to try this place. I’m use to ordering from Little Italy but this will quickly take their spot soon. Their slices are amazing. And they have cool twists on Sicilians and grandma slices. I just have the drunk grandma and I ate it before i could take a picture. I just got cheese garlic knots. Everything is 10/10
April 2025
You May Also Like
Sant Ambroeus Sotheby's - 1334 York Ave
![]()
Italian, Cafe
Finestra - 1370 York Ave
![]()
Italian, Seafood, Pet Friendly, Gluten-Free, Vegan
Murphy's Law - 417 E 70th St
![]()
Pubs, Sports Bar, Irish, Vegetarian