Vodka pizza was just "ok" and the delivery guy was rude as can be. You can do a lot better in New York.
Michael Basista
Online ordering with Ritual does not work. Order was confirmed and credit card charged. I was told it was the old system and no longer is used. Why is it still on the website? Fortunately, they still made the pie when I showed confirmation.
Viktoria D.
Perfect spot! Just moved to the area and went out for the first dinner-snack. The guy at the counter was wonderful and they let us have extra slices for free as the place was almost closing. You won’t miss if you shoot your hunger and crave there ? Ps. Key, Old Brooklyn does not suck, sorry for generalization the other night ?
Nathan Ngai
Place said they were open til 12am on Sundays. So I placed an order at 10pm last night, it’s accepted, they take my $40, but when I show up to the store, they’re closed. What scam is this? How do you even accept orders when your store is closed?
Chasity Alicea
It was empty when we ate there and the guy at the counter gave us free garlic knots! Everything was delicious
Joanna Wise
Pizza is great but they are charging double the sales tax. It isn't $1.24 on $7. The man behind the counter said he has no idea but it is simple math.
Aeowyn Kendall
Great pizza, both regular and vegan. Super friendly owners and staff.
Caroline Calandro
Key was a lovely friendly server, he helped us out right before closing with a very positive attitude
Terminal 8
Holy sh!t some of the finest pizza in the city/tri-state area up in here
Queeny Qiu
Affordable pizza that opens late at night. Their crust was delicious but the sauce and pepperoni (which is what we ordered) was too spicy for us.
This is the BEST pizza in New York! And the Zeppole are to live for!!!!
Vanessa Lubow
Great Pizza, lovely service, and they even have vegan cheese!Fantastic dough, nice crunchy and bubbly
barbara rocco
Best pizza by far in the UES, bread was just the right thickness and flavor was awesome! try it out you wont be disappointed
Helene
Like it but not crazy about it. The dough is chewy and crispy but the slice was lacking flavor. Might need to try a different slice. The white slice is $5.50.Seating inside and outside.Workers are friendly.
Jake Butler
Ordered a pizza online, waited more than an hour called them and they said they weren’t going to make it because “their pizza maker left” and left it up to me to try and get a refund from some secondary app.
Vodka pizza was just "ok" and the delivery guy was rude as can be. You can do a lot better in New York.
Online ordering with Ritual does not work. Order was confirmed and credit card charged. I was told it was the old system and no longer is used. Why is it still on the website? Fortunately, they still made the pie when I showed confirmation.
Perfect spot! Just moved to the area and went out for the first dinner-snack. The guy at the counter was wonderful and they let us have extra slices for free as the place was almost closing. You won’t miss if you shoot your hunger and crave there ? Ps. Key, Old Brooklyn does not suck, sorry for generalization the other night ?
Place said they were open til 12am on Sundays. So I placed an order at 10pm last night, it’s accepted, they take my $40, but when I show up to the store, they’re closed. What scam is this? How do you even accept orders when your store is closed?
It was empty when we ate there and the guy at the counter gave us free garlic knots! Everything was delicious
Pizza is great but they are charging double the sales tax. It isn't $1.24 on $7. The man behind the counter said he has no idea but it is simple math.
Great pizza, both regular and vegan. Super friendly owners and staff.
Key was a lovely friendly server, he helped us out right before closing with a very positive attitude
Holy sh!t some of the finest pizza in the city/tri-state area up in here
Affordable pizza that opens late at night. Their crust was delicious but the sauce and pepperoni (which is what we ordered) was too spicy for us.
Restaurantji Recommends
This is the BEST pizza in New York! And the Zeppole are to live for!!!!
Great Pizza, lovely service, and they even have vegan cheese!Fantastic dough, nice crunchy and bubbly
Best pizza by far in the UES, bread was just the right thickness and flavor was awesome! try it out you wont be disappointed
Like it but not crazy about it. The dough is chewy and crispy but the slice was lacking flavor. Might need to try a different slice. The white slice is $5.50.Seating inside and outside.Workers are friendly.
Ordered a pizza online, waited more than an hour called them and they said they weren’t going to make it because “their pizza maker left” and left it up to me to try and get a refund from some secondary app.
Loading...