Fortunato's

28 N Main St, Newark Valley
(607) 642-8244

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Amanda Moore

The pizza is pretty good. I’d definitely come back and order it. The calzone was not good. Not sure what was going on with that thing, but I wouldn’t get it again. The waitress was super nice!

Detrick Boone

Get there hole made ranch is the best ranch ever

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Jennifer Leighann Elliott

Their “garlic bread” is not garlic bread. It’s some prepackaged breadstick with Parmesan cheese thrown on it, that eats like a rubber-band. Their spaghetti sauce makes spaghetti-o’s look good 😳

Maddy Swan

The first half didn’t taste too bad…. But then took a closer look at the second half and the bread is moldy…. I’ve worked in food service for over a decade…. It is not hard to look through your bread…. Which also means it’s not fresh or even made there. Honestly really sad since you’re the only restaurant in town and family owned. I also really hope I don’t get sick at all, I just got food poisoning a couple weeks ago from a place in owego…. It’s also just bread frozen chicken and hot sauce and you’re charging $10…. Maybe you should take it off the menu all together.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 1

Service: 2

Cindy Schroeder

Google said it was open but it wasn't

steven smith

Best pizza in the Southern tier . Real genuine old world hospitality the staff and food are all the reason to go back again and again. Loved my experience.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Kevin Norris

We did takeout and it was delicious.

Food: 5

Service: 5

blue “cam” wolf121704

Unusual stuff in salads and not fresh. But the loaded fries were good but wish there was more fires and less cheese

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 2

Service: 4

paige steinhilber

Good food but impossible to get ahold of

Cody Densmore

Couldn't ask for better pizza. Close to home ♡

Robert Robinson

My wife and I ordered a large hot sub and the BLT chicken salad, a kids rigatoni and meatball , plus two tossed salsas and two slices of the Stromboli pizza and were charged $66 and change. It’s crazy how much we were charged. The food is good sometimes and others horrible. Never consistent.. this time it was horrible. We could have gone to olive garden and spent just as much and been stuffed and enjoyed it a lot more. And we won’t be recommending to anyone or going back.

chris aingworth

Good food for the right price..and they're local

Lee Lamontain

Best pizza in upstate New York

Kevin Kunze

Takes forever to get someone on the phone to place orders, other then that no complaints as far as food.

Food: 4

Service: 1

thomas downey

I could eat here everyday. Chicken parm sub for days

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Chicken Parm, House Stromboli

Loading...