Erie Shore Cafe & Ice Cream

50 East Ave, Newark
(315) 830-0105

Recent Reviews

Sort by
RJ Bella Mia Ross

I do recommend however not today. I had asked/ordered under the DYI for all the veggies on a sandwich, my sister ordered a sandwich with dressing on the side. We told them it was for “here”. We got the food brought to us in a bag to go. My sister asked for the dressing on the side. I did not get a veggie sandwich I got a panini with feta cheese, tomato, spinach and onion with a pesto sauce. Granted it was busy, but today the young woman did not listen to what we asked for. It was based on what they thought we asked for. Or who knows maybe the cook misinterpreted the order. Even though I brought it to their attention, she said I asked for a very veggie panini and I told her I did not ( that was her copartner telling us it’s covered under the veggie panini, I told her when she the copartner said that i was thinking i had no clue how they were going to fit all those veggies on a panini but ok). she wanted to make it right, but we already waited over 30 mins for our to go meal which should have been for there to begin with, to even be brought to us. I threw my meal out, couldn’t even eat it I was so disappointed, my sister could not finish her sandwich or chips because there was too much dressing on the sandwich when it was supposed to be on the side. Overall today was a big disappointment and waste of 26.00 plus a nice tip in the jar. Will I go there again? Sure at some point, because really they do a good job. This is the 2nd time I’ve gone this yr, last time was for breakfast which was fantastic! I considered today a donation.

Angela Baker

This place had a very generous breakfast for only 7 bucks! Coffee included. I’ve had a couple of their cookies too and they were nice, not too sweet. I’m looking forward to trying more treats.

Denise Jackson

Sweet cafe. Great food. Great coffee. Great atmosphere!

Denise Breen Jackson

Sweet little cafe! Good food. Good coffee! Comfortable atmosphere. HIGHLY RECOMMEND!

Atlas

I go here mostly for the baked goods, and they are so so amazing. Highly recommend their croissants especially. This place also has a beautiful park/sitting area across a one way street with a lovely view of the canal so it would be perfect for just a nice time out for a quick snack. Their profits also supposedly go towards helping their local disabled community!

E C

I can’t remember the names of the pastries I bought but one was caramel-y and the other was a raspberry cream cheese combo and both were DELICIOUS!

Jack Porcello

My wife and I took a stroll along the canal, and decided to give your place a try. I was a bit disappointed by the lack of non dairy offerings (the Dole Whip machine was down, and there were no other options).

On the other hand, the "single scoop" of ice cream that my wife ordered made up for this failure. The bowl was huge, and full of a serving as big as a human head!

Hopefully next trip along the canal will find a lactose free option, and I can bump you up to five stars.

Service was exemplary, and the place was clean, including the outdoor seating area. The ambiance provided by the waterfront made the whole experience complete.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 5

Mike _

I’m a local vendor…..the owner of the shoppe told me she was interested in picking up some of my Premium Marinara products, told me to come back the next week with check in hand. I did so and now she tells me she needs to sample the product herself, for FREE. I offered to sell her 1 jar after that, she went in the back and I never saw her again. Waste of time, I do not recommend you buy or sell from/to them.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Jess’s Mess

My husband ordered the breakfast crunch wrap and said it was the BEST breakfast wrap he has ever had! I ordered the 2x2 breakfast platter and it was also so good! The portions and food quality were incredible! Also very good prices. We will definitely be coming here again.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Timothy OBoyle

Had a great iced coffee on a hot day. Should have slipped next door to have an Ice Cream too. Thanks!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Bonnie Cazer

I stopped by for a pastry and purchased a strawberry crunch scone. It was HUGE, moist, just right sweet and delicious my first time ever at this bakery. The gentleman behind the counter smiled was polite etc. great value nice customer service. I’m going back

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Scones

Jack Howell

Check it

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Madelyn Simpelaar

I am a regular at Erie Shore and always enjoy their fresh healthy food options and not secretly in looove with their baked goods!

Bruce White

Always enjoyable. Recommend them to others when I can.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Scones, Cookie, Peach, Cinnamon Roll, Build Your Own Sandwich, Erie Philly Cheesesteak

Chsrlene Grady

If I could give 0 stars I would. Cashier hirl acted like she didn't want to take my order and then it was wrong. Asked for a build your own sandwich and it came grilled. Also asked to have the mustard on the sandwich substituted for mayo and was charged 80 cents for that.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Loading...

Erie Shore Cafe & Ice Cream

50 East Ave, Newark, NY 14513
(315) 830-0105