Mr. Coolee's Ice Cream Shop
5076 NY-31, Newark
(315) 331-2245
Recent Reviews
Sort by
Atmosphere: {{ item.info.Atmosphere }}
Food: {{ item.info.Food }}
Service: {{ item.info.Service }}
Recommended dishes: {{ item.info['Recommended dishes'] }}
There is no competition for two counties around in the quality & service Mr. Coolee's provides - especially in regards to the flavor of their soft serve ice cream.
We continue patronage with the new owners of the business, and have been every bit as satisfied as for years past - in fact, more so - as they have extended the hours further into the Fall season than ever before!
We appreciate your efforts to take over this great local business and look forward to patronizing the shop again and again.
literally my new favorite ice cream place, its only 13 minutes from my house and I didn't find it until the end of summer π their sizes and flavors are AMAZING I can't say enough good about them!!
Great place to go w the family
The sizes, the price, the ice cream, the staff all AMAZING! new favorite discovery!
Love it!
Love the variety of flavors, the service, the fish fountain, and the value for the price. Their serving sizes are MASSIVE! The ice cream was deliciously creamy and smooth.
The place has an old fashioned soda shop feel. It has outdoor and indoor seating (not much, because it's a small shop). Young and old alike seemed to enjoy it. I'd go out of my way to come here again.
Best ice cream, amazing serve sizes, wonderful customer service. Team in training keep it up. You guys are definitely on the road to success. Thanks for your friendly atmosphere and patience. Will be back.
Ive been three times now since I discovered Mr. Cooleeβs in the past month π Tons of delicious flavors esp Cow Tippins flavor, huge servings, and the shop is super clean and kid-friendly. The staff is incredibly kind β 10/10 every time!!
Amazing customer service & great value! Love the option to drive through or park and dine in. Staff was fast & so friendly! They have the BEST black cherry ice cream πππ
More like Mr. unCoolee's.
The staff was very bothered by our basic questions that we only had due to the poor signage and lack of available up-to-date menus on the internet.
The ice cream was very alright, but I feel like our vibe was killed, and vibe is like 90% of the getting ice cream experience.
I get it, they're training, that's the only information that the signage makes clear.
Had a very pleasant experience everyone is very friendly and nice
Restaurantji Recommends
We've been 3 times now since the new owners and are disappointed more and more each time. First time, we got 2 smalls and they charged $12, and they were pretty small (smaller than the smalls from the previous owners). Second time, we got 2 mediums because we didn't like how small the smalls were and they were monstrous. Again, $12. Ordered the exact same thing. Third time, got 2 smalls, $9.50 and one was tiny and the other was almost as big as the medium from the second time. Incredibly inconsistent with portion and prices. Unfortunately, we are done with this place.
We've been 3 times now since the new owners and are disappointed more and more each time. First time, we got 2 smalls and they charged $12, and they were pretty small (smaller than the smalls from the previous owners). Second time, we got 2 mediums because we didn't like how small the smalls were and they were monstrous. Again, $12. Ordered the exact same thing. Third time, got 2 smalls, $9.50 and one was tiny and another was almost as big as the medium from the second time. Incredibly inconsistent with portion and prices. Unfortunately, we are done with this place.
Best ice cream in the county
Great place to go good people Great service
Excellent service this morning. New owners were very welcoming:)
Loading...