Goodfellas Pizzeria Inc

Ordered from Seneca Niagara Casino! If you are from western NY and love your hometown pizza this is for you! Great crust & sauce! Fast!

Great food. We come all the way from Canada for this pizza AND wings!

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Wings

Great food and great service.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Some of the best pizza & beer in Niagara Falls! Their crispy wings are as some of the best you'll ever have. Be sure to try some char-grilled!

Vegetarian options: Pizza options with just veggies

Dietary restrictions: Gluten free crust available

Parking: Unlimited free parking

Kid-friendliness: Kids welcome!

Wheelchair accessibility: All first floor accessibility

Recommended dishes: Chicken Wings, Cheese Pepperoni Pizza, Wings

Got 2 finger dinners and hamburger to go, shorted my fingers as I ordered 5 piece gave me 3 piece dinners.
Hamburger was plain and that was ordered with toppings. Second time in a row order was like this, I am done with

Food: 3

Service: 1

Waited 25 min for just chicken wings. And we were the only people in there.....good thing they were worth the wait. I ordered fries with them, which came out first, 10 min before the wings made it to the table. And I had to ask for napkins which should not have to ever be asked for at a restaurant no matter what you order.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 5

Service: 3

Recommended dishes: Wings

very great food and customer service waitresses very nice nice phone girls very great experience here

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Steak

Run down place, building is nasty, old... glad didn't see kitchen, we googled this coming out of Niagara Falls state park, hungry this place sounded good, it was Saturday so we thought it might be busy but it was empty so we walked in, set down and immediately regretted but tired we ordered pizza and wings
... waited 47 minutes, jeez we were only customers here. My husband was losing his patience, and finally, she brought our food. The pizza was ok, and the wings were overcooked too crispy dry. I don't understand why people go saying, "Don't miss this place if in niagara Falls, come on, we are here once and have one stomach, and this place needs serious improvement. So sad to say, and by the way, ithis was not cheap.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 2

Service: 3

Recommended dishes: Chicken Wings, Bakery Pizza

Hands down the best pizza I’ve ever had! Perfectly crispy and buttery crust. Wings were amazing also!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

If you love plenty of cheese on your pizza, Cheese that pulls bite to mouth watering bite.. If fresh high quality pizza toppings matter to your pizza experience then you will not be disappointed.

There are many nouveau pizza places using high quality ingredients however I have yet to find another Pizza place in Niagara Falls with generous portions comparable to GoodFellas. Combine freshly made pizza dough , high quantity & quality toppings, a tasty pizza sauce….THEN GOODFELLAS PIZZA IS FOR YOU!!

My review is for Goodfellas medium six slice and large eight slice round Pizza’s. I do not eat or like square tray pizza which is everywhere in Niagara falls Goodfellas makes tray pizza too, I will not order tray pizza because there is more crust than pizza and for me, tray pizza is a stepped down experience, as such my review is for Goodfellas medium and large round Pixza only.

Service = 4 stars
expecting more than that from a small family run business which phone rings from opening to close is what any reasonable customer should expect.

Atmosphere= 3 stars
Goodfellas, located in Niagara Falls “Little Italy” in the now rundown market square just off Pine Avenue The facade of Goodfellas hasn't been updated since the business opened. When you enter GoodFellas you are greeted by an oversized front bar made of Formica, outdated stools and a limited audio visual experience. You will not be going to GoodFellas to catch a ballgame with your good friends. Just past the bar area is the dining room, antiquated is putting it kindly, with regard to atmosphere, 3 stars is being nice.
Go for the Pizza. If you appreciate a good pizza, you will not be disappointed.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 5

Service: 4

Yall should ask if the person wants salt and pepper

Great chicken wings if they get your order right . 4 different times they messed my order up . I order once a week you think they could get it right. Twice they gave me 50 wings plain with no sauce when I order them hot and char broiled every time. They NEED a good MANAGER there. They do fix the problem and I love their food .

Food: 5

Service: 1

Recommended dishes: Chicken Wings

Best Pizza in the

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Just a dive spot. Na air conditioner and bad area. Really went down hill since the last time I was there. Such a shame.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Gross. You’ll find out for yourself if you order food from here.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 2