Always has great pizza, and right next to the state park and waterfalls. Usually only open in the summer. Worth getting a slice.
Kartik Sehgal
Small restaurant with amazing, hot delicious pizza! The desi pizza is worth trying even if you eat meat!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Desi Pizza
Any More
This place is a bus
Scott Summers
Been going to Niagara Fall NY 4 times a year for the last 20 years! Mario's Pizza has always been the Highlight of Our Trip! Thank You Mario and Staff! The BEST!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cheese Pizza
Tony Gattas
This is the worst restaurant I’ve experienced. Visited Niagara Falls and wanted to get a pizza for 3 days. They close at 5p every day and when I finally arrived on day 3 at 3:40p, they refused new orders. Horrible business, poor response when I’m trying to give them my money and were not nice about it.
Atmosphere: 1
Service: 1
MNDoodles
Yay for gluten free pizza! I was SO pleased they have gluten free crusts. It was delicious. My husband had two slices of regular pizza, a veggie slice and Hawaiian. Both were hot and very good. We enjoyed sitting outside on a picnic table next to the pizza place on a mild autumn evening to eat and drink sodas we ordered. We didn’t see indoor seating. After we ate, we walked a block to see the falls at dusk. This is a great spot very close to Niagara Falls State Park. We parked in the state park lot #1 which is only a block from Mario’s. High recommend for this place. It’s delicious.
Chris C.
It was fine, not great. We tried cheese, veggie, and pepperoni. Cheese was the best, I thought. Sauce could be more flavorful, and a little light on cheese on all of it
Dharminder Singh
Pizza was so so. Nothing special. Definitely could’ve used more cheese. I’ve had way better NY pizza. Pizza was hot though at least. Lady at the counter was friendly.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 4
Ramesh Patel
If you have no other choice, you can give it a try, but it's not very tasty. However, if there's another pizzeria further away, it's definitely worth considering due to the poor quality and high prices at this one.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 3
Rajat red
NY style pizza their veg combo pizza slice was super good and had lot of veggies which compliment each other must try pizza in Niagara
Hubby walked down there from our hotel to pick us up a pizza. He ordered and they forgot to make our pizza twice & he waited over an hour. They then had the audacity to be rude to him b/c he was asking how much longer. They also wouldn't refund him so he continued to wait. We've had other NY pizza & this one sucked!! Do not recommend!!
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
rebelVegans “Electric Vegans”
Very nice tasting Vegan Pizza. Unfortunately, Vegan Pizza is veggies only. Please introduce Beyond or Impossible meet ingredients in the future.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Vegan Cheese, Vegan Pizza
Shelly L.
I read 1 review for this place and was sold since it was written by a Jersey guy. I should have looked at the date of his post or what part of Jersey he was from because I was super disappointed. As fellow Jersey people know, we are VERY particular about our pizza (at least in North Jersey). My kids make fun of me for it in fact. They say it's ruined me from enjoying pizza from anywhere else. We now live in PA where a good slice is hard to find. I guess I was spoiled growing up around a lot of old school Italians who made phenomenal food in general. Anyway, I was excited to see the Falls for 2 reasons and being in NY was one of them. Again, maybe this is just a North Jersey thing thinking NY pizza is usually on the same level as NJ) Bottom line: when I head back to PA today, I'm bringing a pie from NY and it will not be from Mario's. Both my kids enjoyed it though, to be fair. That's the reason I gave it 3 stars and the nice staff.
Tara L
Best pizza I've ever had! Homemade pizza sauce is the best. The ham was fully marinated with wine, sausage was fully of Italian seasoning and pepperoni was amazingly old-school! I highly recommend this place over some chain restaurants!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Style Pizza
rebelVegans
Very nice tasting Vegan Pizza. Unfortunately, Vegan Pizza is veggies only. Please introduce Beyond or Impossible meet ingredients in the future.
Always has great pizza, and right next to the state park and waterfalls. Usually only open in the summer. Worth getting a slice.
Small restaurant with amazing, hot delicious pizza! The desi pizza is worth trying even if you eat meat!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Desi Pizza
This place is a bus
Been going to Niagara Fall NY 4 times a year for the last 20 years! Mario's Pizza has always been the Highlight of Our Trip! Thank You Mario and Staff! The BEST!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cheese Pizza
This is the worst restaurant I’ve experienced. Visited Niagara Falls and wanted to get a pizza for 3 days. They close at 5p every day and when I finally arrived on day 3 at 3:40p, they refused new orders. Horrible business, poor response when I’m trying to give them my money and were not nice about it.
Atmosphere: 1
Service: 1
Yay for gluten free pizza! I was SO pleased they have gluten free crusts. It was delicious. My husband had two slices of regular pizza, a veggie slice and Hawaiian. Both were hot and very good. We enjoyed sitting outside on a picnic table next to the pizza place on a mild autumn evening to eat and drink sodas we ordered. We didn’t see indoor seating. After we ate, we walked a block to see the falls at dusk. This is a great spot very close to Niagara Falls State Park. We parked in the state park lot #1 which is only a block from Mario’s. High recommend for this place. It’s delicious.
It was fine, not great. We tried cheese, veggie, and pepperoni. Cheese was the best, I thought. Sauce could be more flavorful, and a little light on cheese on all of it
Pizza was so so. Nothing special. Definitely could’ve used more cheese. I’ve had way better NY pizza. Pizza was hot though at least. Lady at the counter was friendly.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 4
If you have no other choice, you can give it a try, but it's not very tasty. However, if there's another pizzeria further away, it's definitely worth considering due to the poor quality and high prices at this one.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 3
NY style pizza their veg combo pizza slice was super good and had lot of veggies which compliment each other must try pizza in Niagara
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
Hubby walked down there from our hotel to pick us up a pizza. He ordered and they forgot to make our pizza twice & he waited over an hour. They then had the audacity to be rude to him b/c he was asking how much longer. They also wouldn't refund him so he continued to wait. We've had other NY pizza & this one sucked!! Do not recommend!!
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Very nice tasting Vegan Pizza. Unfortunately, Vegan Pizza is veggies only. Please introduce Beyond or Impossible meet ingredients in the future.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Vegan Cheese, Vegan Pizza
I read 1 review for this place and was sold since it was written by a Jersey guy. I should have looked at the date of his post or what part of Jersey he was from because I was super disappointed. As fellow Jersey people know, we are VERY particular about our pizza (at least in North Jersey). My kids make fun of me for it in fact. They say it's ruined me from enjoying pizza from anywhere else. We now live in PA where a good slice is hard to find. I guess I was spoiled growing up around a lot of old school Italians who made phenomenal food in general. Anyway, I was excited to see the Falls for 2 reasons and being in NY was one of them. Again, maybe this is just a North Jersey thing thinking NY pizza is usually on the same level as NJ) Bottom line: when I head back to PA today, I'm bringing a pie from NY and it will not be from Mario's. Both my kids enjoyed it though, to be fair. That's the reason I gave it 3 stars and the nice staff.
Best pizza I've ever had! Homemade pizza sauce is the best. The ham was fully marinated with wine, sausage was fully of Italian seasoning and pepperoni was amazingly old-school! I highly recommend this place over some chain restaurants!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Style Pizza
Very nice tasting Vegan Pizza. Unfortunately, Vegan Pizza is veggies only. Please introduce Beyond or Impossible meet ingredients in the future.