P.J. Clarke's | Tioga Downs Casino Resort

The food was very good, but I think the breadsticks that we were given at the start of the meal were from the day before they weren't very fresh and it was only 5 pm

We had the Prime Rib and the Filet. Both were cooked to our perfection. We are always treated like royalty there. Love the waitress's and bar staff. Definitely recommend PJClark's!

Wonderful service every time we visit. Food is always consistent. Maddison made my son's birthday special. She went above and beyond to learn his name and asked if liked chocolate cake all ahead of time without him suspecting anything. Then they all sang to him. It's the small stuff that matters. Attention to details is what they do best!

Bread sticks were microwaved and got hard as a brick within 5 mins. Soup taste was good but not hot, didn't microwave it long enough. The salmon was good I would not go back and it was over priced.

Unfortunately due to it being a holiday the service was extremely slow. We ordered a bottle of wine which sat on our table for 15 minutes before someone came to open it up. We got our salad and within two minutes our entrées were there, we are at a tiny little table so there was no room to put anything. I understand with it being Valentine's Day there was limited seating but that is the reason I made this reservation three weeks ago. I ordered the salmon, it was very dry and overcooked. Don't think we'll be returning there anytime soon

Our dining experience was enjoyable. The waitress offered a steak knife for the Prime beef I ordered, yet cutting the meat was difficult. When a second steak knife was also ineffective, I used my Camillus titanium knife, which cut through the meat with ease. It might be a good time to consider upgrading your steak knives. Ed

Our experience at P. J. Clarke's was outstanding. The service was exemplary. Our waitress, Mattison, was friendly, cheerful, knowledgeable and very accommodating. The food was tremendous. I had the petite filet, and my wife had the prime rib. Both were done perfectly, the way we ordered, and absolutely delicious. The sides were very tasty, and the presentation on all the dishes was very tasteful. The price was definitely in line with what should be expected for a fine dining experience. The only negative, and it was understandable, was that the noise level was a little high, due for the most part by proximity to the bar. I would highly recommend this establishment to anyone looking for a fine meal at a reasonable price.

For the first half of our dining experience, we were enjoying drinks, food & atmosphere then an extremely intoxicated person was seated next to us and the entire experience changed and was very disappointing.

I ordered the seafood risoto. There was NO cheese in it. The watress was kind enough to hring me some grated cheese (not fresh). For $38 it was very disappointing. My husband orfered the $42 scallops. He was shocked and disappointed when his meal arrived. 4 scallops.

We love PJ Clarke's! The bartender, Amy, is AMAZING! Our favorites on the menu are the oysters, seafood risotto, filet mignon with Brussel sprouts and garlic fries and the Mac and cheese. Can't go wrong with any of those!

We had great food! It was just a very busy night to attend. We were at the restaurant for almost 2 hours, but still had a great experience. I have never seen the restaurant that busy before. Again, food was great & service was good.

We went for our anniversary and everything was perfect. I had one of the better steaks I've ever had and the service was top rate! The manager even came out and wished us happy anniversary. We will definitely go back again.

Pjs is the best. Excellent food and service. Chelsea is one of the best servers I've ever encountered. She's efficient, very polite- she makes your dining experience the best it can be. We live in CA and come to NY for summer vacation each year and always look forward to PJs. Tony Skelly July 17th 2024

Living in Canada, it was our first time back since Covid. Ordered the beef short ribs and they were fabulous! Our server Madison(sp?) was outstanding. She was informative and attentive and very pleasant. If we make it back down to Tioga again soon, we will ask for her section. Everything was great.

We have been here a few times before and all was fine but this time they were very busy. 4th of July and only had a limited menu and food took about an hour. They did tell us it would take a half hour and did give us dessert on the house because of the wait. Waitress was amazing!