Gorgeous venue. So busy, but not overcrowded at all. Our server was the best ever and I eat out nearly every day of my life. Our reservation was at 9pm and people were still being seated up til 9:45 and the staff was still so friendly and easygoing. Didn't feel rushed at all. Food was melt in your mouth delicious! Definite 10/10!
Eric
Another great experience at Arlo. Management was very accommodating to our seating request. Food was delicious. We had the crab cake, grilled octopus (a bit chewy) and wedge salad for appetizers. We had the pork chop, lobster pappardelle and Chilean sea bass. They were all perfect. Drinks were great. For dessert, we had my favorite Baked Alaska. Yum! Service was great and we were checked on a few times by management. The ambiance upstairs is stunning. Arlo sets the standard for fine dining!
dan
We went last night for our 5th wedding anniversary and it was amazing. The staff was all super friendly and they even gave us a card and, noticing my wife was pregnant, they gave us a ginger ale toast for free. I highly recommend this restaurant to everyone.
George
All four of us had martinis at their bar. Very good. Were alerted via phone text when table was ready. Right on time ! We had filet mignon and Chilean sea bass. 2 and 2. Steaks came out HOT as did fish. Steaks done medium to perfection. Girls said the coconut sauce for the fish was fantastic ! Sorry girls had salads and guys had the octopus. Octopus charred exactly as we liked. Dinner was great ! Looking forward to our next visit
genene
always a wonderful experience!! service is top notch! favorites of mine include the lobster pappardelle, the halibut and the pork chop!!
Debra
From walking into the door at one of the prettiest restaurants I've seen on Long Island . Enjoying drinks at the bar upstairs and dinning downstairs. The bars signature drinks were amazing. We had Corey as a waiter he was amazing, friendly and helped us decide on what to eat from appetizers to steak or seafood , everything that came out was delicious. This is a must try and we can't wait to go back again .
Kim
Incredible food and service! We went for restaurant week and Arlo did not disappoint! We will definitely be back!
Simone
I was a little disappointed that when the reservation was made I added it was for an Anniversary. We were seated next to the kitchen. The service was really great though and we did receive a card with well wishes which was nice along with a complimentary glass of champagne. We started off with the Arlo salad which was fantastic. I had the Chilean Seabass which was a little tough. My husband had the NY Strip and said it was good. The restaurant itself is beautiful, service was great, I just expected the food to be a lot better.
Russ
Amazing meal at Arlo tonight. The staff was perfect, especially our server, DARWIN. He understood and explained everything well, and was there quickly for everything we needed. Best EVER Crab cake and Pork chop!! The Caesar salad, Chicken Spiedini, kitchen sink potato, and mac&cheese were very good. My 3 year old son liked his chicken fingers and fries, they have a few options for kids. Good soda, beer, cocktails. Loved it, will be back, and definitely recommend.
Lynne
Since our anniversary coincided with the start of LI Restaurant week, we decided to try Arlo, which had been on the "radar" for awhile. It is, in fact, one of our friends' favorite places and after last night, we totally understand why!! The place was lively when we arrived just a bit early for our rezzie, but we found the bar & settled in to a pre dinner cocktail. Located in the back of the house, the bar area has a few tables and about 8 comfortable seats for drinking (of course!) or dining. The bartender was busy but took our order and swiftly set us up. Did I mention hos gorgeous the restaurant is? Done up in neutral tones with splashes of black it screams sophisticated luxury without pretense. The vibe is definately laid back and comfortable. We were seated quickly and visited by Naomi our server and given the requisite water...gotta stay hydrated!! A basket of complimentary bread (did you hear that Farm Italy??) also arrived. After perusing both the Restaurant Week pre fixe & the regular menus, we opted to order the pre fixe-a great value may I add. We both ordered the crab cake appetizer-a wonderful patty of crab served on frisee. A crunchy outside revealed a creamy crab meat filling puncuated by the caper tartar sauce. A perfect combo of sweet and tangy. Dinner consisted of the 10oz filet cooked to medium rare perfection with a side of broccolini, sautéed in a super yummy garlic butter. Hubby ordered the Short Rib Ragu, a very rich dish which was utterly delicious. The paccheri pasta was perfectly al dente to absorb that awesome sauce! We finshed the meal with NY Cheesecake & Chocolate Mousse cake-both stellar desserts we could barely finish. My only regret was not ordering the wine pairing to accompany the meal-will def not forget the next time. Our service was perfect, friendly, not overbearing and all the waitstaff was on top of clearing plates, glasses and replacing silverware when appropriate-a pleasure. Arlo is a great dining experience.
Gorgeous venue. So busy, but not overcrowded at all. Our server was the best ever and I eat out nearly every day of my life. Our reservation was at 9pm and people were still being seated up til 9:45 and the staff was still so friendly and easygoing. Didn't feel rushed at all. Food was melt in your mouth delicious! Definite 10/10!
Another great experience at Arlo. Management was very accommodating to our seating request. Food was delicious. We had the crab cake, grilled octopus (a bit chewy) and wedge salad for appetizers. We had the pork chop, lobster pappardelle and Chilean sea bass. They were all perfect. Drinks were great. For dessert, we had my favorite Baked Alaska. Yum! Service was great and we were checked on a few times by management. The ambiance upstairs is stunning. Arlo sets the standard for fine dining!
We went last night for our 5th wedding anniversary and it was amazing. The staff was all super friendly and they even gave us a card and, noticing my wife was pregnant, they gave us a ginger ale toast for free. I highly recommend this restaurant to everyone.
All four of us had martinis at their bar. Very good. Were alerted via phone text when table was ready. Right on time ! We had filet mignon and Chilean sea bass. 2 and 2. Steaks came out HOT as did fish. Steaks done medium to perfection. Girls said the coconut sauce for the fish was fantastic ! Sorry girls had salads and guys had the octopus. Octopus charred exactly as we liked. Dinner was great ! Looking forward to our next visit
always a wonderful experience!! service is top notch! favorites of mine include the lobster pappardelle, the halibut and the pork chop!!
From walking into the door at one of the prettiest restaurants I've seen on Long Island . Enjoying drinks at the bar upstairs and dinning downstairs. The bars signature drinks were amazing. We had Corey as a waiter he was amazing, friendly and helped us decide on what to eat from appetizers to steak or seafood , everything that came out was delicious. This is a must try and we can't wait to go back again .
Incredible food and service! We went for restaurant week and Arlo did not disappoint! We will definitely be back!
I was a little disappointed that when the reservation was made I added it was for an Anniversary. We were seated next to the kitchen. The service was really great though and we did receive a card with well wishes which was nice along with a complimentary glass of champagne. We started off with the Arlo salad which was fantastic. I had the Chilean Seabass which was a little tough. My husband had the NY Strip and said it was good. The restaurant itself is beautiful, service was great, I just expected the food to be a lot better.
Amazing meal at Arlo tonight. The staff was perfect, especially our server, DARWIN. He understood and explained everything well, and was there quickly for everything we needed. Best EVER Crab cake and Pork chop!! The Caesar salad, Chicken Spiedini, kitchen sink potato, and mac&cheese were very good. My 3 year old son liked his chicken fingers and fries, they have a few options for kids. Good soda, beer, cocktails. Loved it, will be back, and definitely recommend.
Since our anniversary coincided with the start of LI Restaurant week, we decided to try Arlo, which had been on the "radar" for awhile. It is, in fact, one of our friends' favorite places and after last night, we totally understand why!! The place was lively when we arrived just a bit early for our rezzie, but we found the bar & settled in to a pre dinner cocktail. Located in the back of the house, the bar area has a few tables and about 8 comfortable seats for drinking (of course!) or dining. The bartender was busy but took our order and swiftly set us up. Did I mention hos gorgeous the restaurant is? Done up in neutral tones with splashes of black it screams sophisticated luxury without pretense. The vibe is definately laid back and comfortable. We were seated quickly and visited by Naomi our server and given the requisite water...gotta stay hydrated!! A basket of complimentary bread (did you hear that Farm Italy??) also arrived. After perusing both the Restaurant Week pre fixe & the regular menus, we opted to order the pre fixe-a great value may I add. We both ordered the crab cake appetizer-a wonderful patty of crab served on frisee. A crunchy outside revealed a creamy crab meat filling puncuated by the caper tartar sauce. A perfect combo of sweet and tangy. Dinner consisted of the 10oz filet cooked to medium rare perfection with a side of broccolini, sautéed in a super yummy garlic butter. Hubby ordered the Short Rib Ragu, a very rich dish which was utterly delicious. The paccheri pasta was perfectly al dente to absorb that awesome sauce! We finshed the meal with NY Cheesecake & Chocolate Mousse cake-both stellar desserts we could barely finish. My only regret was not ordering the wine pairing to accompany the meal-will def not forget the next time. Our service was perfect, friendly, not overbearing and all the waitstaff was on top of clearing plates, glasses and replacing silverware when appropriate-a pleasure. Arlo is a great dining experience.
Restaurantji Recommends
John was an excellent server. Greatly appreciated his attentiveness and positive attitude.
Probably the best restaurant in Suffolk, if not the whole Island! EVERYTHING was perfect. I'm extremely picky however I was blown away!
Always an amazing experience at Arlo Kitchen and cocktail. We celebrated our 25th wedding anniversary and it was incredible.
The Tomahawk for 2 was delicious. The steak was tender, juicey and cooked perfectly. The table side carving experience was a fun bonus.
Had a great experience at Arlo! The food was amazing and so was the service! The restaurant is gorgeous also. I will be back!
Loading...