GREAT PIZZA, CAME BACK IN TOWN AND SAME OWNER STILL THERE, CUSTOMER SERVICE WAS GREAT AND EVERYONE STILL REMEBERED ME,
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
M Smith
Arguably THE BEST slice of pizza I've ever had! A MUST if you're in Nyack.
Terrance Cox
My partner is from Nyack. We drove up form Michigan to New City on family business. We Have To Go in honey! Even saw Batman while we were there. They know each other. Speaking to everyone was great.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Mikayla Ramo
Terrible experience was charged for tip I did not leave on my card!
Linda Brown
Have to do another report on this place. . We go here frequently and will continue to do so. We were helped very much again by Dina, Gloria , and Lorenzo. Tony ia also special ! The meals are delicious and plentiful !
TARANTELLA REPORT CARD Atmosphere A+++ So clean and comfortable Meals A++++ Really enjoy the hot subs.They are so yummy and huge ! Next time want to order some other tasty looking items. Staff A++++ Was helped by Danny and Freddy.. They are awesome !! Can't wait to come back here again !
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jon Smith
Great slice
Chrisy Shah
family owed and operated pizza shop, super friendly and the pizza and coffee is great. a lot of other option if you are not into pizza.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Emi Rose
Called to order person on the line was very disrespectful yelled at me just bc we asked how many wings come with ann order yelled”what you don’t have the menu in front of you!” 3 pepperoni slices one of them had a piece of plastic stuck to them and all of them had vegetables in them like they were picked out of the pizza to make it a pepperoni slices won’t be back here!
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Som Boualaphanh
Amazing pizzas and service. When there twice on our trip and will definitely come back.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
New York NY
⭐ 8.5/10 – A Surprisingly Exceptional Pizza That Could Redefine Tarantella's Reputation
I recently ordered from Tarantella Pizzeria through DoorDash, and I was pleasantly surprised from start to finish. First off, shoutout to the Ukrainian driver who was not only punctual but also extremely personable—he confirmed every detail of my order with care, which gave me confidence right away.
Now, let’s talk pizza. I was very specific in my request: thin crust, extra crispy—the kind of slice that would make Dave Portnoy of Barstool Sports nod in approval. As the saying goes, “One bite, everybody knows the rules.” I’ve ordered from Tarantella in the past and received a standard, thicker New York-style pie. It was good—solid even—but not in my regular rotation.
To be honest, I hesitated placing this order because my usual go-to spots are heavy hitters like Martio’s Brick Oven in Nanuet, The Nanuet Hotel, Mountain House, Ray’s Grandma Pizza, Pepe’s in Yonkers, and of course, Johnny’s in Mount Vernon. These are all places that consistently hit the mark with one side pepperoni and onion and the other side meatball and onion.
But let me tell you—Tarantella absolutely nailed it this time. The crust was beautifully thin and perfectly crisped, with that golden undercarriage that had zero flop, even after delivery. That’s no easy feat. The texture held up so well, it felt like it came fresh out of the oven straight to my table.
If Tarantella consistently makes pizza like this one—crispy, light, and well-balanced—they’ll see their sales grow tenfold. This was hands-down the best pie I’ve had from them, and as someone with Calabrian roots, my standards are high and my palate isn’t easily pleased. Dave Portnoy might have his Massachusetts upbringing, but for me, the bar is set by the depth of Southern Italian flavor and authenticity.
Tarantella, if you’re reading this—make this your standard recipe. You’ve won me over, and that’s no small accomplishment.
I love this place. Delicious food, friendly family atmosphere. It’s just the best.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Yolanda Singh
The food and service was excellent!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
John and Joanna Stumbo
Great service. Loved every bite.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
todd morgan
Super fast service. Some of the best pizza I’ve had in my travels. This sauce doesn’t get any better.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
jesus rosario
2 pies 1 plain 1 with ½meat ½ another, 1 chicken roll $72 . Stay away from these crooks with attitudes. Order the same thing this week and it's more money. Make it make sense. I even brought it up to his attention not surprised he didn't care.
GREAT PIZZA, CAME BACK IN TOWN AND SAME OWNER STILL THERE, CUSTOMER SERVICE WAS GREAT AND EVERYONE STILL REMEBERED ME,
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Arguably THE BEST slice of pizza I've ever had! A MUST if you're in Nyack.
My partner is from Nyack. We drove up form Michigan to New City on family business. We Have To Go in honey! Even saw Batman while we were there. They know each other. Speaking to everyone was great.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Terrible experience was charged for tip I did not leave on my card!
Have to do another report on this place. . We go here frequently and will continue to do so. We were helped very much again by Dina, Gloria , and Lorenzo. Tony ia also special ! The meals are delicious and plentiful !
TARANTELLA REPORT CARD
Atmosphere A+++ So clean and comfortable
Meals A++++ Really enjoy the hot subs.They are so yummy and huge ! Next time want to order some other tasty looking items.
Staff A++++ Was helped by Danny and Freddy.. They are awesome !!
Can't wait to come back here again !
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great slice
family owed and operated pizza shop, super friendly and the pizza and coffee is great. a lot of other option if you are not into pizza.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Called to order person on the line was very disrespectful yelled at me just bc we asked how many wings come with ann order yelled”what you don’t have the menu in front of you!” 3 pepperoni slices one of them had a piece of plastic stuck to them and all of them had vegetables in them like they were picked out of the pizza to make it a pepperoni slices won’t be back here!
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Amazing pizzas and service.
When there twice on our trip and will definitely come back.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
⭐ 8.5/10 – A Surprisingly Exceptional Pizza That Could Redefine Tarantella's Reputation
I recently ordered from Tarantella Pizzeria through DoorDash, and I was pleasantly surprised from start to finish. First off, shoutout to the Ukrainian driver who was not only punctual but also extremely personable—he confirmed every detail of my order with care, which gave me confidence right away.
Now, let’s talk pizza. I was very specific in my request: thin crust, extra crispy—the kind of slice that would make Dave Portnoy of Barstool Sports nod in approval. As the saying goes, “One bite, everybody knows the rules.” I’ve ordered from Tarantella in the past and received a standard, thicker New York-style pie. It was good—solid even—but not in my regular rotation.
To be honest, I hesitated placing this order because my usual go-to spots are heavy hitters like Martio’s Brick Oven in Nanuet, The Nanuet Hotel, Mountain House, Ray’s Grandma Pizza, Pepe’s in Yonkers, and of course, Johnny’s in Mount Vernon. These are all places that consistently hit the mark with one side pepperoni and onion and the other side meatball and onion.
But let me tell you—Tarantella absolutely nailed it this time. The crust was beautifully thin and perfectly crisped, with that golden undercarriage that had zero flop, even after delivery. That’s no easy feat. The texture held up so well, it felt like it came fresh out of the oven straight to my table.
If Tarantella consistently makes pizza like this one—crispy, light, and well-balanced—they’ll see their sales grow tenfold. This was hands-down the best pie I’ve had from them, and as someone with Calabrian roots, my standards are high and my palate isn’t easily pleased. Dave Portnoy might have his Massachusetts upbringing, but for me, the bar is set by the depth of Southern Italian flavor and authenticity.
Tarantella, if you’re reading this—make this your standard recipe. You’ve won me over, and that’s no small accomplishment.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
I love this place. Delicious food, friendly family atmosphere. It’s just the best.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The food and service was excellent!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great service. Loved every bite.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Super fast service. Some of the best pizza I’ve had in my travels. This sauce doesn’t get any better.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
2 pies 1 plain 1 with ½meat ½ another, 1 chicken roll $72 . Stay away from these crooks with attitudes. Order the same thing this week and it's more money. Make it make sense. I even brought it up to his attention not surprised he didn't care.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 2
Service: 1
Loading...