Caryville Inn

Name: Caryville Inn
Address: 25 Main St, Oakfield, New York, 14125, US
Telephone: (585) 948-9780
Price range: $
Rating: 4.5

$ • American

Hours:
25 Main St, Oakfield
(585) 948-9780

About Caryville Inn

Caryville Inn is a restaurant known for its accommodating staff and solid dining experience. The menu features a variety of options, with wings being a popular choice. Customers can enjoy wings prepared in different ways, and they are reported to be delicious. The restaurant has a rustic farm decor, and there is a beautiful patio available for dining during the summer months. During holiday seasons, the decorations are top-notch.

In addition to wings, the restaurant offers other dishes, including Turkey Ruben, Philly Cheesesteak, pull-apart pizza bread, and soups. French onion soup has been highlighted as a favorite among guests. The Greek salad is also mentioned as fantastic, with a perfectly balanced combination of ingredients and generous Greek dressing.

The service is generally fine, although it can be inconsistent. Reservations are recommended, especially on busy nights such as $0.25 wing Wednesdays. The restaurant is not large, but guests have reported being seated within a reasonable amount of time. Drinks, including specialty cocktails, are available. Customers have appreciated the kindness of the staff and the atmosphere, noting the value placed on supporting local agriculture and businesses.

Overall, Caryville Inn is a great spot for dining in or taking food to go. The food is consistently good, and the service can be satisfactory. It is recommended for those seeking a solid dining experience, despite some occasional service issues. Parking is available on the street and in a nearby lot, and outdoor seating is offered when the weather permits.