Their pizza was SO good!!!!!! Get the mozzarella donuts!!!! They even had an ARCADE machine!
M&M
Very friendly staff, tasty pizza, they sell by the piece, the place has air conditioning, very clean.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
herbert fields
Charges for delivery and expects you tip delivery person.Bad form!The reason restaurants charge for delivery is to cover the expense of having to pay someone to deliver the food. The delivery charge is a tip.Don’t charge….let the delivery person make some money.
Food: 3
Service: 2
Luis Montero
Amazing mozzarella donuts, great staff, definitely a go to place at fire islandKid-friendliness: Air conditioned in the summer and helped us bring in the stroller up the stairs amazing staff
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Lissette
I ordered the buffalo bites and mozzarella donuts. The buffalo bites tasted bland and rubbery like they were heated in the microwave. The mozzarella donuts were okay, hardly any flavor but the cheese was fresh. It was very busy so maybe I should’ve just tried the pizza instead ?♀️
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 2
Service: 4
Taylor W.
We ordered the Calamari Arrabiatta and 3 slices of pizza.ALL WERE PERFECT!The flavors that dance around on your tastebuds from the calamari Arrabiatta are amazing. The tangy little kick from the sauce is absolutely memorable. We dipped our pizza into the sauce and BOY OH BOY that changed everything!The perfect NY pizza can not always be found outside of NYC or the boroughs, but you better your a55, you'll find it at Beacheria.The place is clean and quirky. The employees seem to take so much pride in their place of work and the foods made.I even think I heard the manager telling the cooks how much we enjoyed our food. The best thing is to know that they received our feedback immediately.OH! and they have PAC-MAN!
Nadav M.
One of the best pizzas ive tried all time .Let's talk about the pizza itself, which was the highlight of the visit. The crust was superb, achieving the perfect balance between crispy and chewy. It had a delightful golden-brown color and a subtle, yeasty aroma that hinted at the quality of the dough. The crust provided a solid foundation for the toppings and had a lovely homemade feel.Best of the best !
Chris Aldrich
Great food. My favorite was the Buffalo chicken pizza.
Steve Bruno
The pizza was not good, and overpriced.The chicken parm hero was delicious, and fairly priced. Don't eat the pizza, eat the food.
Joseph Cavera
Food was decent (penne Madeira was very watery, though the wings were excellent) and pricy, which is to be expected for a primo spot on Fire Island. What struck me as exceptional about this place was the management. The management staff is clearly very attentive to the restaurant, cleaning tables and even the entryway, and were also fair to the workers, who were also attentive.
Good pizza, however second best in Ocean Beach. If you want pizza go to town pizza.
Alicia Sundberg
An Ocean Beach visit MUST! Seriously best meal you can get on the island, dine in or take out! Awesome meatball and ricotta pizza, but it’s more than just pizza. The Penne Madeira is amazing!
henry
bruh they have good pizza but like a slice and a soda is worth 9$ so it’s like really expensive
Their pizza was SO good!!!!!! Get the mozzarella donuts!!!! They even had an ARCADE machine!
Very friendly staff, tasty pizza, they sell by the piece, the place has air conditioning, very clean.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Charges for delivery and expects you tip delivery person.Bad form!The reason restaurants charge for delivery is to cover the expense of having to pay someone to deliver the food. The delivery charge is a tip.Don’t charge….let the delivery person make some money.
Food: 3
Service: 2
Amazing mozzarella donuts, great staff, definitely a go to place at fire islandKid-friendliness: Air conditioned in the summer and helped us bring in the stroller up the stairs amazing staff
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I ordered the buffalo bites and mozzarella donuts. The buffalo bites tasted bland and rubbery like they were heated in the microwave. The mozzarella donuts were okay, hardly any flavor but the cheese was fresh. It was very busy so maybe I should’ve just tried the pizza instead ?♀️
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 2
Service: 4
We ordered the Calamari Arrabiatta and 3 slices of pizza.ALL WERE PERFECT!The flavors that dance around on your tastebuds from the calamari Arrabiatta are amazing. The tangy little kick from the sauce is absolutely memorable. We dipped our pizza into the sauce and BOY OH BOY that changed everything!The perfect NY pizza can not always be found outside of NYC or the boroughs, but you better your a55, you'll find it at Beacheria.The place is clean and quirky. The employees seem to take so much pride in their place of work and the foods made.I even think I heard the manager telling the cooks how much we enjoyed our food. The best thing is to know that they received our feedback immediately.OH! and they have PAC-MAN!
One of the best pizzas ive tried all time .Let's talk about the pizza itself, which was the highlight of the visit. The crust was superb, achieving the perfect balance between crispy and chewy. It had a delightful golden-brown color and a subtle, yeasty aroma that hinted at the quality of the dough. The crust provided a solid foundation for the toppings and had a lovely homemade feel.Best of the best !
Great food. My favorite was the Buffalo chicken pizza.
The pizza was not good, and overpriced.The chicken parm hero was delicious, and fairly priced. Don't eat the pizza, eat the food.
Food was decent (penne Madeira was very watery, though the wings were excellent) and pricy, which is to be expected for a primo spot on Fire Island. What struck me as exceptional about this place was the management. The management staff is clearly very attentive to the restaurant, cleaning tables and even the entryway, and were also fair to the workers, who were also attentive.
Restaurantji Recommends
Delicious food. Fast service. Great experience
Good pizza, however second best in Ocean Beach. If you want pizza go to town pizza.
An Ocean Beach visit MUST! Seriously best meal you can get on the island, dine in or take out! Awesome meatball and ricotta pizza, but it’s more than just pizza. The Penne Madeira is amazing!
bruh they have good pizza but like a slice and a soda is worth 9$ so it’s like really expensive
The mozzarella donuts are a lie.