Hands down the best bagels on Long Island, so fluffy light and fresh, theirs nothing like a fresh hot bacon egg and cheese on a bagel right out of the oven.
Spud
How about NOT wearing only one glove then going to tend to the garbage can while my bagel toasted; then return to cut/wrap the bagel without changing your glove or washing your filthy hands.Also the lox spread was rancid ?Absolutely disgusting!
Pats Fan
I ordered a scooped bagel from this establishment and I watched the guy remove the inside of the bagel with his bare hand! This is absolutely disgusting ! You are supposed to wear gloves when handling people’s food ! I will never be returning here again!
Kimberly Forte
I wanted to share my positive experience at stuffn bagels. I had a complicated order. 2 eggs scrambled, extremely well done bacon and cheese on a scooped out light plain bagel. It always freaks me out when they don’t write down my order. But this guy behind the counter was sharp. He got my order perfect. My bacon was cooked to perfection. I didn’t have to dissect my sandwich! The lady who rang me up was friendly. And the guy who took my order made small talk.What made the experience great was the 2 employees behind the counter. The lady that rang me up and the guy who took my order.
Mickey Mantle
Great tuna and bagels, but, I went there the other day and the AC either wasn’t on or not working on a hot day. They said it was, but it was the oven heating up the place. That’s not how AC works or else you could never go to a pizza place in the summer.
colesmommy18
Sorry to Say this place has gone downhill since the new owners have taken over. I have gone several times hoping that it will get better with time but it just keeps getting worse the bagels are stale the spreads and cream cheeses are all old in the refrigerator with crust on top it’s over priced and the employees are rude. They should be listening to their reviews and hopefully fix the place up.
bekah santos
I used to love this place, but two days ago they sold me an egg salad sandwich and a potato salad that was completely inedible. It cost me at least 9 dollars and it was completely rotten. I don't think they replace their fridge items as often as they are supposed to. Be careful! I almost got really sick. Will not be revisiting -- it makes me sad to say :(
Kristin Wilson
Omg, I use to go to this bagel place all the time. I haven't had it in a while and I order a bacon egg and cheese on a bagel (it was disgusting the bagel was stale the bacon was not even cooked all the way) I spent $9.50 for a sandwich and yoohoo, totally outrageous. I wouldn't care if it was good but it was inedible and I threw it out. Not to mention the lady behind the counter was super unfriendly looks like she didn't even want to be there. When you work with the public you should be a little bit nicer. Over all a terrible experience, if I could give it no stars I would. I will gladly take my business else where.
Josh Landau
Been coming to stuffs over 20 years and ever since the place was sold in 2020 everything went downhill. Quality control dropped and prices are now insane. Just went in and ordered 2 bagels with lox, a bagel with cream cheese, and two drinks for $39!!!! What a ripoff!!!! Didn’t even have a chance to see what I was being charged because I was never told, and they didn’t give me a receipt with my card transaction. New ownership and staff is nowhere near as nice or welcoming as the original owners. This place is nothing special anymore, I will not be going back:(
Richard Kaplan
My wife and I used to live in the Valley Townhouses right next door. The scalion on a garlic bagel made me see God. I also bought farmer cheese there on a regular basis. In fact, Lynn referred to me as Mr. Farmer Cheese.
This is a Bacon egg and cheese on a roll. Smh. Nice greasy bacon sandwich. Worst I had in my life. Where is the egg. Aweful. Expensive also.
Michael Weiss
Place has been getting worse and worse as the weeks go on. Staff arguing with each other, lox that's going bad, stale bagel, ordered a regular coffee and got french vanilla. Just incompetence and bad attitudes. 2 stars because at least it's edible.
Shelly VonShtupp
If you like your breakfast with a side of incompetence and a free headache, this is the place for you! After not being able to communicate with woefully inept counter person, and subsequently accosted by her father who owns the place, I was then yelled at by the grill person to “HAVE A NICE DAY!” on my way out the door. My day got exponentially better with each step I took farther away from this dysfunctional clusterfart masquerading as a bagel store.
Hands down the best bagels on Long Island, so fluffy light and fresh, theirs nothing like a fresh hot bacon egg and cheese on a bagel right out of the oven.
How about NOT wearing only one glove then going to tend to the garbage can while my bagel toasted; then return to cut/wrap the bagel without changing your glove or washing your filthy hands.Also the lox spread was rancid ?Absolutely disgusting!
I ordered a scooped bagel from this establishment and I watched the guy remove the inside of the bagel with his bare hand! This is absolutely disgusting ! You are supposed to wear gloves when handling people’s food ! I will never be returning here again!
I wanted to share my positive experience at stuffn bagels. I had a complicated order. 2 eggs scrambled, extremely well done bacon and cheese on a scooped out light plain bagel. It always freaks me out when they don’t write down my order. But this guy behind the counter was sharp. He got my order perfect. My bacon was cooked to perfection. I didn’t have to dissect my sandwich! The lady who rang me up was friendly. And the guy who took my order made small talk.What made the experience great was the 2 employees behind the counter. The lady that rang me up and the guy who took my order.
Great tuna and bagels, but, I went there the other day and the AC either wasn’t on or not working on a hot day. They said it was, but it was the oven heating up the place. That’s not how AC works or else you could never go to a pizza place in the summer.
Sorry to Say this place has gone downhill since the new owners have taken over. I have gone several times hoping that it will get better with time but it just keeps getting worse the bagels are stale the spreads and cream cheeses are all old in the refrigerator with crust on top it’s over priced and the employees are rude. They should be listening to their reviews and hopefully fix the place up.
I used to love this place, but two days ago they sold me an egg salad sandwich and a potato salad that was completely inedible. It cost me at least 9 dollars and it was completely rotten. I don't think they replace their fridge items as often as they are supposed to. Be careful! I almost got really sick. Will not be revisiting -- it makes me sad to say :(
Omg, I use to go to this bagel place all the time. I haven't had it in a while and I order a bacon egg and cheese on a bagel (it was disgusting the bagel was stale the bacon was not even cooked all the way) I spent $9.50 for a sandwich and yoohoo, totally outrageous. I wouldn't care if it was good but it was inedible and I threw it out. Not to mention the lady behind the counter was super unfriendly looks like she didn't even want to be there. When you work with the public you should be a little bit nicer. Over all a terrible experience, if I could give it no stars I would. I will gladly take my business else where.
Been coming to stuffs over 20 years and ever since the place was sold in 2020 everything went downhill. Quality control dropped and prices are now insane. Just went in and ordered 2 bagels with lox, a bagel with cream cheese, and two drinks for $39!!!! What a ripoff!!!! Didn’t even have a chance to see what I was being charged because I was never told, and they didn’t give me a receipt with my card transaction. New ownership and staff is nowhere near as nice or welcoming as the original owners. This place is nothing special anymore, I will not be going back:(
My wife and I used to live in the Valley Townhouses right next door. The scalion on a garlic bagel made me see God. I also bought farmer cheese there on a regular basis. In fact, Lynn referred to me as Mr. Farmer Cheese.
Restaurantji Recommends
This is a Bacon egg and cheese on a roll. Smh. Nice greasy bacon sandwich. Worst I had in my life. Where is the egg. Aweful. Expensive also.
Place has been getting worse and worse as the weeks go on. Staff arguing with each other, lox that's going bad, stale bagel, ordered a regular coffee and got french vanilla. Just incompetence and bad attitudes. 2 stars because at least it's edible.
If you like your breakfast with a side of incompetence and a free headache, this is the place for you! After not being able to communicate with woefully inept counter person, and subsequently accosted by her father who owns the place, I was then yelled at by the grill person to “HAVE A NICE DAY!” on my way out the door. My day got exponentially better with each step I took farther away from this dysfunctional clusterfart masquerading as a bagel store.
Great bagels. The only white fish salad I'll buy.
Great place. Nice service and yummy food
Loading...