Eatery

239 N Union St, Olean
(716) 806-1306

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Jacob Holmberg

Amazing food. Best around.

Bri B

Delicious food and great service.

Lisa Budinger

Pizza was the best I have had in a long time.

Justin Giles

My wife and myself have been here a few times now and have had lunch being sandwiches which both where huge and very good. The Eatery steak dinner for supper was awesome and my wife always orders something outside the box from most and she always enjoys her plate. We have yet to try the pizza but plan on it soon but the cheese bread appetizer is yummy. Also give the French onion soup a chance its the best I've found in the area.

Falicia Snyder

Nice people gross food chicken parm was half oil and tasted like frozen chicken patty

Vernon Robinson Jr

First time in this restaurant and I wasn't disappointed. Our server was great and helped with the menu options. Drinks were good and the items we ordered were all made to perfection. The pizza was baked perfectly and there were numerous options.

Prices for the meals are similar to others asking North Union St, but I would return.

Dee Cherberg

Corey the bartender made a great Margarita. Also very informative about the area.🍹

jahan chahal

The triple-B burger was ok, you couldn't taste the bacon, I asked for pink in my berger and got not pink

Greg Sprague

Wanted to support our local business. How ever we stood for 5 minutes at wait to be seated sign. Only 2 tables were in use and the waiter just leaned on the back counter after he saw us. So we left . Sorry but we won't be coming back.

Chris Badger

Had the prime rib. Who fries prime rib? It was very poor. Everyone else seemed pleased with their choices so maybe I just picked the one dish the cook didn't know how to make.

Annie Cusumano

My friend and I went here today, what a gem! The menu size was perfect, not too big or too small and beverage list was fantastic! We had a pizza and a sandwich to split between us, everything was wonderful! The service was great, the wait wasn’t long at all even with a busier afternoon and our bill was LESS than it is when we go to Chipotle, Applebees, or Pizza Hut. And the food was so much better! We will definitely be back! Has anyone noticed that we seem to be more dissatisfied with the bigger chain restaurants than we are over our locally owned businesses? 🤔 SUPPORT LOCAL!

Wally Schurr

Recommended by family and celebrating my Birthday 2/22/25 my wife chose to take me to dinner here.
She ordered a Long Island Ice Tea, For myself
I will have a Mountain Dew, Sorry no Mountain Dew, Okay I will take a root beer, We make our own root beer and some people like it and some don't! Well I will try it, Sorry no root beer, so remembering what my wife had ordered I replied I will have an Ice Tea, Sorry we don't have any Ice Tea ? Now I'm a bit puzzled so I asked what do you have?
We have Sprite, good enough I'll take it!!!
I ordered the Wagyu Beef $$$ medium rare.
My Wife ordered just a steak prepared the same way.
I,ve had my own meat shop and served as a meat manager in a grocery store.
The beef that I was served was in noway Wagyu !
My steak as well as my wife's steak appeared to look like a flank steak!!!
I always said if your going to serve a tough steak you should at least have a knife sharp enough to slice it.
They did provide Cutco knifes but the steaks were as tough as shoe leather!!! Only thing missing was the laces.
We tried our best to finish our meal but we both had to throw in the towel and get a box and bring home 1/2 of our steaks each.
Our German Shepherd enjoyed his hundred dollar treat.
Will I Ever Come Back ?
It was a joint decision and the verdict stands as probably Not.

Bret Marvin

We decided to enjoy our Valentine dinner at “eatery”. We were definitely not disappointed. We were seated quickly after terrific cocktails at the bar. Service could not have been better. My wife had the chicken parm, I had the “catch of the week”. Pizzas looked great. Both were absolutely delicious. We highly recommend “eatery”.

L Con

A true GEM in this town. Pizza and beers are the best. Service and timing of food was impeccable. I would drive from much farther away to come here again .

Rene

One of my favorite places in the area. Hang out and have drinks or a meal. Always good food and friendly service.

Loading...