Nina's Italian Resturant & Pizzera

I have not been to Nina's in many years and was in town last week and stopped here for lunch.
The pizza my wife and I had was very good. My complaints are that the service was not that friendly. It seemed as though the waitress was curt and not that attentative.
Above the booth we were sitting at was a ceiling fan. Not only were the blades of this fan filthy, but the ceiling around it was encrusted with heavy dust and what appeared to be bugs in this heavy dust.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 5

Service: 3

The best Sicilian pizza i have had since I was in Manhattan 8 years ago.

$13 for 2 slices of pizza and a drink. I guess if you do business in the center of a college town you can charge crazy prices for pizza. But the place was clean the customer service was fast and the servers very friendly. Just way overpriced.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 5

Although the food was good. I've never had such a cheese-less calzone! Literally almost no cheese in it. And flat! I've always had calzones that were full and tall with cheese. We actually ended up with a spare as 1 broke boxing it. But I won't waste my money there again. Also... I've never had my calzone cut in half. It was just wrong.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 3

Service: 4

I always go to Nina's. I am really particular because lived in NYC and love Italian. So I've tried every place in the area and I honestly will tell you this is the only real Italian restaurant in the area. These are real Italians. Im talking reggiano parmesean...quality ingredients...great gravy...or sauces... Do not go to any other place.. Fresh salads. Premium ingredients. You can taste the quality of the ingredients. Pizza, lasagna, Alfredo sauce to die for. Perfect flavor perfect consistency.... and if Nina ever cooks for you... it's like taking a trip to Italy! Like i said....come here and very picky.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Great service, great food and fast service! Reasonably priced!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Family owned and ran super friendly and the pizza is so yummy and they have Alfredo pizza. To die for

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Always friendly, outdoor seating available. Great owner, always accomodating.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Wings, Garlic Rolls, Chicken Parmesan Roll, Pepperoni Pizza Slice

I've done all of them. Dined in, out and had it delivered. Had lunch and dinner.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

They may have the best burger in town!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

We came in for a sunday lunch and ordered the Gourmet Xlarge pizza - veggie lovers
The pizza was really good and quite literally Xlarge… they charged for ketchup and marinara on the side which was disappointing though.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 3

$27 for a pepperoni pizza is insane. Not to mention the whole thing smelled and tasted like onions

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 1

Service: 2

We had a large group coming in from Cooperstown and they said we can have the back room with no mention of a fee. Our party of 4 were sat and ordered and another large large party came in and were seated in the same room and then we were told it was first come first served. The rest of our party of 25 arrived and we made do with the tables available and were told we could not move the tables to sit together.
At the end of our meal, the owners wife came over with 2 checks one for our dinner and another for $100 for deposit of the room which we were not told about and they actually sat others in the room as well.
She was very rude and was not concerned about the customers, she was only concerned about collecting an additional $100. We spent a total of $750 on food which was good.
Not sure we would recommend again because she was so rude.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 5

Service: 4

The food was amazing !! Everything tasted freshly made and the waitress was the sweetest!! Honestly wish I had the time and space left to order more. Also the bathrooms were super clean 👌🏼

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

★★★★★ – Absolutely Amazing Pizza and a Local Gem

Nina’s Pizza is hands down one of the best pizza spots I’ve ever been to — and I don’t say that lightly. From the moment you walk in, you can tell this place has heart. It’s not just another chain; it’s a cozy, welcoming, family-run place that clearly takes pride in everything they serve.

The food? Incredible.
The pizza is next-level. The crust is that perfect balance between crispy on the outside and soft, chewy on the inside. You can tell it’s made fresh, not some frozen nonsense. The sauce is flavorful and just the right amount of tangy, and the cheese… wow. It’s gooey, perfectly melted, and doesn’t feel greasy or overwhelming. Whether you’re a plain cheese kind of person or like to pile on the toppings (try the pepperoni and sausage combo!), every slice is satisfying from start to finish.

They also offer garlic knots, wings, salads, and a few pasta dishes — and everything I’ve tried has been solid. The garlic knots are soft, buttery, and addictive. The wings are crispy and packed with flavor. It’s clear that quality ingredients are a top priority here.

The staff and service? Super friendly.
Everyone working there is always kind, patient, and genuinely seems to care about your experience. Even when they’re busy, they’re efficient and polite, which really makes a difference. The place is clean and well-kept, and there’s a relaxed, welcoming vibe that makes you want to come back.

Prices? Totally fair.
For the quality of food you’re getting, the prices are more than reasonable. You get generous portions and never feel like you’re overpaying.

Final thoughts:
Nina’s Pizza is a must-visit if you’re anywhere nearby. Whether you’re grabbing a quick slice after school, picking up dinner for the family, or just craving something really good, this is the spot. It’s the kind of place you keep coming back to — and tell everyone you know about. Five stars, easily. ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐