Heintzelman's BBQ Pit

6361 Knickerbocker Rd, Ontario
(315) 333-1235

Recent Reviews Order Online

Customers' Favorites

Half Rack of Ribs with Smoked BBQ Beans
Smoked Mac N Cheese Add 2
Smoked Mac and Cheese
Pulled Pork Sandwich
Smokey Baked Beans
Garlic Parm Fries
Pig Pen Sandwich
Hour Pulled Pork
Sampler Platter
Pit Style Wings

Menu

Pit Style Wings
Pit Style Wings
Smoked Jumbo Wings served -Deep fried or Charred(charred wings take an additional 15 min). Served with 1 house-made blue cheese per 8 wings, tossed in your choice of 1 of our house made sauces.

Heintzelman's House Salad
Heintzelman's House Salad with 32 Hour Pulled Pork
32 hour Pulled pork, cornbread croutons, bacon, cherry tomatoes, and red onion.
Heintzelman's House Salad with Pulled Chicken
Pulled chicken, cornbread croutons, bacon, cherry tomatoes, and red onion.
Heintzelman's House Salad with Shredded Brisket
Shredded brisket, cornbread croutons, bacon, cherry tomatoes, and red onion.
Heintzelman's House Salad
Chopped romaine hearts, cornbread croutons, bacon, cherry tomatoes and red onion slices served with your choice of dressing.
Heintzelman's house salad with crispy chicken
romaine heart , cherry tomatoes, cornbread croutons, bacon bits sliced red onion and crispy chicken pieces

Appetizers
Garlic Parm Pretzels
Fried pretzel dough, sprinkled with sea salt, then lightly coated with our garlic butter and garlic parmesan cheese. Served with our house made jalapeno beer cheese.
Fried Pickle Fries
Battered and deep-fried. served with house made sriracha ranch dipping sauce.
Fried Cheese Curds with Side Gravy
Coated cheese curds deep fried and served with our brisket gravy.
Corn Bombs
Battered sweet corn kernels nuggets, deep fried served with house made sriracha ranch.
Fresh cut fries
fresh cut fries w/nacho cheese, bacon and sour cream

Housemade Sides
Cajun Corn
Sweet corn kernels cooked with Cajun and other spices for just a hint of heat
Cornbread
House made honey cornbread.
Hand Cut Fries
Hand cut potatoes, deep fried to perfection. Sprayed with our house vinegar blend then sprinkled with house made fry salt.
Garlic Mashed Potatoes
Idahoan potatoes mixed with milk, butter, garlic and seasoning. Place a note if you would like gravy.
Mac N Cheese with Meat
Barilla elbow pasta mixed with our 7 cheese blend and our 32 hour pulled pork sprinkled with fresh bacon bits.
Smokey Baked Beans
Baked beans mixed with bacon, green pepper, sweet onions and spices smoked on our hickory smoker for 6 hours.
Collard Greens with Ham
Chopped fresh collards cooked till tender perfection with ham hocks, bacon, onions and a blend of spices.
Garlic Green Beans
Fresh green beans sautéed in butter and olive oil with minced garlic and spices.
Grandma's Mac Salad
Barilla elbows mixed with house made dressing peppers, onions, celery and spices.
Mac N Cheese
Barilla elbow pasta smothered in our 7 cheese blend sauce.
Sweet Potato Glazed Fries
Sweet potato tots, deep fried then coated with maple syrup, cinnamon, sugar and other spices for a delectable treat to your palate.
Coleslaw
Hand shredded cabbage mixed with carrots and our house made slaw dressing for a sweet, acidic velvety palate pleaser.
Garlic Parm Fries
Hand cut deep fried french fries, tossed in our garlic butter and covered with our garlic parmesan cheese topping.
Tater Tots
deep fried potato tots seasoned with house fry salt.
Spiced Applesauce
house made chunky applesauce kicked up with cinnamon, nutmeg and allspice
Side Salad
Chopped romaine hearts with house made cornbread croutons and real bacon bits. Choice of dressing. Add extra dressing for an additional charge.

Soups
Clam Chowder Soup
A thick hearty soup consisting of chopped clams, potatoes, and sweet shredded carrots within a milk and cream base.
Seafood Bisque
Our version of a country bisque. A creamy rich soup with lobster, scallops, clams, and crab meat.

Fresh Cut Fries
Bacon, Fresh Cut Fries with Cheddar Cheese and Sour Cream
hand cut fries with shredded cheddar cheese, sour cream and bacon bits.
Fresh Cut Fries with 32 Hour Pulled Pork
Hand cut fries with 32 hour pulled pork, nacho cheese, sour cream, jalapenos, original BBQ.
Fresh Cut Fries with Pulled Chicken
Hand cut fries with Pulled chicken, nacho cheese, sour cream, jalapenos, original BBQ.
Fresh Cut Fries with Brisket
Hand cut fries with Brisket, nacho cheese, sour cream, jalapenos, original BBQ.
Fresh cut fries with crispy chicken
fresh cut fries w/nacho cheese, jalapenos, original bbq sauce, sour cream and deep fried crispy chicken

Little Heiny's Club
Kids 4 Chicken Wings
4 smoked wings deep fried and coated in choice of house made sauce. Served with 1 house made blue cheese.
Kids 3 Chicken Fingers
Southern battered chicken tenders.
Kids Pulled Pork Sandwich
A smaller version of our 32 hour pulled pork sandwich just the right size for the little ones.
Kids Pulled Chicken Sandwich
A smaller version of our pulled chicken sandwich just right for the little ones.
Kids Hamburger
1/4lb burger, made of select cuts of beef. Served on a hearty roll just right for the little ones.
Kids Cheeseburger
1/4lb burger, made of select cuts of beef, topped with shredded mild cheddar cheese. Served on a hearty roll just right for the little ones. .
Kids Zweigle's Red Hot
Kids No Meat Mac N Cheese
Barilla elbow pasta smothered in our 7 cheese sauce.
Kids Hot Dog Mac N Cheese
Zweigels red hot served with our Barilla elbow pasta covered in our 7 cheese blend sauce.

Entrees
Fish Fry
16 oz. boneless, skinless haddock, house-made beer batter or broiled.
Shrimp Platter
Panko breaded and butterflied, served with your choice of house-made Sriracha ranch or house made cocktail sauce and a lemon wedge.
Mac N Cheese
Barilla elbow pasta smothered in our 7 cheese blend served as is or add any meat for an additional charge.
Chicken Fingers
5 Southern-style battered chicken tenderloins, fried to perfection served with your choice of dipping sauce.
Clam strip dinner
Deep fried clam strips

BBQ Pit Platters
Brisket Prime
House blended spices, hand-rubbed on trimmed prime brisket, slow-smoked with straight hickory wood for 12 - 14 hours. Served on a deli roll.
32 Hour Pulled Pork
Wet and dry rubbed with house blend of 22 spices slow-cooked over hickory wood for 32 hours. hand pulled and served on a deli roll
Pulled Chicken
1/2 chickens marinated for 24 hours in our special blend of spices, smoked, and pulled for your eating pleasure. Served on a deli roll.
Hot Link
A different type of sausage brought in from the meatpacking district in Chicago. Great texture with a little heat. Served on a deli roll.
St. Louis Ribs
Marinated in our dry rub for 24 hours then slow-smoked over hickory wood till pull-apart tender.
Clam Chowder
New England Clam Chowder

Create a BBQ Combo
Pick 2 Combo
choice 2
Pick 3 Combo
Choice 3 items.

The Pit Plate
The Pit Plate
Our version of the trash plate, BBQ STYLE! Seasoned tater tots, mac salad, smoked baked beans, chopped onions, original BBQ sauce and meat sauce. Choice of 2 meats (hamburg, cheeseburger, hot dog, hot link, 32 hr pulled pork, pulled chicken, crispy chicken, upcharge for mac and cheese, upcharge for brisket).

BBQ Sandwiches
Little Dickie Sandwich
Brisket sandwich topped with our 4 cheese blend, jalapenos, house made slaw, and original BBQ.
The Mac Daddy Sandwich
Smoked cheeseburger topped with onion rings, smoked mac n cheese, bacon, and original BBQ.
The Landslide Burger
Smoked cheeseburger topped with 32 hour pulled pork, jalapenos, sauteed onions, bacon, and original BBQ.
Prime Rib Philly Sandwich
Shaved prime rib topped with our 4 cheese blend, sauteed pepper and onions, on a toasted ciabatta roll.
The Pig Pen Sandwich
Hotlink with 32 hour pulled pork, sauteed onions, house made slaw, bacon, and original BBQ.
Sweet Caroline Sandwich
32 hour Pulled pork topped with house made slaw and BBQ.
Pit Burgers
Smoked or Flame-broiled(non smoked). Burgers are smoked unless non-smoked is requested. A special blend of brisket, short rib, and chuck, ground, and seasoned with our blend of burger salt. Topped with romaine lettuce, sliced tomato, and sliced onion, served on a deli roll with a dill pickle spear. Add-ons for an additional charge.

Soft Drinks
Pepsi Products
We are out of regular pepsi
Coffee
Hot Tea
House Brewed Iced Tea
Milk
Juice
Milkshake
thick and rich Perrys Ice Cream milk shake

Pit Syle Nachos
Pit Style Nachos
Sea salted corn chips loaded with Cajun corn, tomatoes, onions, olives, jalapenos, cheddar cheese, nacho cheese, original BBQ and sour cream

Photos

Photo credit: google
Photo credit: facebook
Photo credit: facebook
+46 photos
Photo credit: facebook
+45 photos
Add a photo

Recent Reviews

Went on a coupon offer, never been there. Quiet, pleasent atmosphere unlike Dinasore. Offered side dish sampler for newbies, all of them. which was really cool. Wait staff was excellent, knowledgeable as well as patient. Drink selection was enough to satisfy anyone, even children. As for the food, it came quick, literally 10 min. AFTER ordering. Portions were very generous. Other reviews had issues, but we didn't. When we arrived, we were seated immediately, unlike the Dinasore...
August 2025
Great food, excellent service at a honest price, what more can you ask for. Just a little tip: it’s not only BBQ!! The Steak, prime rib and lobster was the best I have had. The deserts are always a good choice too. You won’t be disappointed and if you are.. you’re wrong! lol.
March 2025
Amazing BBQ.
Low key atmosphere, great food !
Met Bob the owner, he came by and checked in on tables.
Will be back to try more of the menu.
Worth a stop !!!!
March 2025

More Reviews

You May Also Like

Dunkin' - 1873 NY 104
Coffee Shops, Coffee & Tea, Donuts, Coffee
Mamia's Island - 1808 NY 104
Puerto Rican
Precious Chinese Restaurant - 2005 NY 104
Chinese, Seafood, Soup

Heintzelman's BBQ Pit

6361 Knickerbocker Rd, Ontario, NY 14519
(315) 333-1235