COOKIE JARZ BAKESHOP

Cookies and cupcakes are amazing. Highly recommend the stop here for a sweet treat!

We are cookie Jarz fans for life!! I (accidentally) walked into the shop with my daughter one day before they were set to open officially. We were greeted by Renee, who told us their grand opening would be the next day and told us to stop by, but not before giving my little one a free cookie to sample. From that very first encounter we were hooked. My kids were enrolled in the daycare a few doors down and I swear for the first month cookie jarz was open, we would stop after daycare every time and grab a cookie. I’m surprised by the end of the month they didn’t have an intervention set up for us for cookie addiction. Every single time we go into the shop we’re greeted with smiles. I’ve ordered custom cutout cookie pops for a school birthday party and they came out beautiful, and so tasty. Anytime someone asks for a bakery recommendation, I suggest cookie jarz. They’ve done custom cakes for some of my coworkers and every single time everyone has been blown away by the quality of the products and also the customer service. I love the large selection of classic Italian cookies they offer. Their cupcakes are incredible and the perfect size to satisfy your sweet tooth without being too sweet to finish in one sitting. Their giant cookies are to die for. I cannot say enough wonderful things about this place. Truly wonderful, caring people with a special talent for all things sweet. Zoe and Renee - thank you both for always being so sweet to my kids when we come in. I will sing cookie jarz praises to whoever will listen!!

I always love stopping in here! They are wonderful and the sweets are out of this world!

Food: 5

Beautiful job on engagement cookies! Lots of compliments on how tasty they were too! They were able to have them ready in less than a week also.

Visited Cookie Jarz twice with my best friend, Brian. Our experience here was nice. Great cookies and even better service. We love this place! Zoe is always friendly, she is great. We highly recommend a visit. We can't wait to stop in again.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

They made cookies and a cake for my daughter’s graduation party they both were a huge hit! The cookies were perfect and that cake was amazing! Thank you so much!!!

A custom cookie platter for a graduation party did not disappoint. So glad this recipe lives on at Cookie Jarz. Thank you!

Food: 5

Service: 5

Super friendly..pleasant..great cupcakes!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Hands down the best cupcakes I've had in my life! Just ordered a chocolate double dose cake and I know it's going to be nothing short of life changing.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

My husband and I stopped here to buy some Italian cookies and I'm glad we did. They had a good variety and they are delicious. The cupcakes are just as good as the cookies.

Dietary restrictions: They had gluten free options

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

I love cake...lol. So when trying a new bakery, I always get a vanilla / vanilla cupcake. The Cookie Jarz cupcake was the absolute best cupcake I have had so far. I will be back.

Great place overall! The assorted cookies are delicious and they definitely have one the best carrot cakes in buffalo! If you haven't already stopped in for a visit, I highly recommend that you do. This is a wonderful business to support!

Amazing, exquisite, delicious cookies, cupcakes and whole cakes! My favorite is the orange ricotta cookie however everything is so delicious and beautifully made! The young ladies are so pleasant. Please give them your business. It's so wonderful to have a small business like this!

We've gotten cupcakes a few times now and they've been great every time! Love that they have monthly flavors tooThey also helped us out with a gender reveal cake a few weeks ago which looked great and tasted wonderful! Highly recommend them :)

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Amazing, exquisite, delicious cookies, cupcakes and whole cakes! My favorite is the orange ricotta cookie however everything is so delicious and beautifully made! The young ladies are so pleasant. Please give them your business. It's so wonderful to have a small business like this!