Custom Cakes near Orchard Park, NY

“Emilee (I don’t think I spelled her name correctly) and Liam were 2 of the nicest employees I’ve dealt with! They were very helpful and soo nice! I was kinda miserable when I went in, but left with a smile on my face! Thank you to you 2! Thank you for making me smile! You don’t know how much I needed that! I will return! Plus your ice cream is amazing!“

“I was first introduced to this bakery's cookies at a fundraiser for Ten Lives Club, and both the design and the quality of the cutout cookies were fantastic! I love that they are involved in charity work for some really worthwhile organizations, so I'm happy to support that, and enjoy some delicious baked goods in the process! I recently placed my first order and sadly, I have no photos to share, but the presentation was very nicely done, with all of the cookies' ingredients and allergens very clearly marked. There was a large variety of flavors to chose from, and I'm excited to try cupcakes next! And finally, the owner's communication skills are excellent, she's very responsive and super friendly. Highly recommended!“

“My husband and I live close and when we pass, we can’t help but stop and get some amazing cupcakes. They are to die for! So delish! 10/10 recommend!“

“She and her cakes are amazing“

“We are so happy that we decided to use Blue Eyed Baker for our wedding desserts! We ended up with a clear vision of multiple different desserts that we wanted, and Madelyn and the entire team made everything come to life exactly as we pictured. From making custom tasting boxes so we were 100% sure of our flavors, to working with our florist to get matching flowers on the cake, everything was very clear from start to finish. And it all tasted amazing too! Our venue was a bit of a drive away from the bakery (Akron from East Aurora), but delivery was on time and flawless. (The cherry on top was that I knew our delivery person from a dance job years ago - thanks Becca!) I'd recommend Blue Eyed Baker for any event dessert needs, I only wish that I lived closer to East Aurora so I could come in more often!“