Really good pizzas. The meatball sub is a MUST HAVE! It is by far one of the best meatball sub I ever. The meatballs are sliced, which is really nice.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 4
704tracim
First bite of pizza, instead of a good cheese pull, I pull a long brown hair from my mouth that was embedded in the cheese. I showed the manager Judy and she acted as if I was bothering her . Her response was, "It happens." No apology, no attempt to compensate. I had to ask for a refund, which I was given begrudgingly. Horrible customer service.
Cliff Price
I’m not sure if there was a new employee working or what but this is what the entire sub looked like. Not what I remember ordering from pap’s.
Literally a sliver of meat across my entire sub AND I had added bacon to it.
As soon as I took the subs out of the bag I knew something was off. Literally looked like I picked up foot longs from Ted’s, that’s how small they were.
Crazy when you’re paying $28 for two subs.
Ruth Maciejewski
The pizza was ready on time, hot and delicious.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 4
Andrew Bean
Love their pizza. Very consistent. It's honestly a nice compromise between thin crust and typical buffalo style. Always on time and the price is very fair given the current state of pizza cost
buffaloray
Best pizza in Orchard Park. Especially the white pizza.
Robin Marsh
Not much of a dinning area. A few tables and booths. I Perfer to only do take out. Pizza on Wed deal is pretty good. The pizza is constant. Nice flavor sauce. Plenty of cheese and tasty pepperoni. We added onions and the pizza was wonderful. Highly recommend. Pizza will always take longer than expected. Allow 35min no matter what they say. I tend to always wait. Wednesday is the day to go for the special large cheese & one item. Try you'll be back!!! 😜
CHUCK LESTER
Good pizza!
Nick
Nice little place. Good pizza nice staff. New spot to go😁
yan Lin
I have been Oder and waiting for 35 minutes. When my brother go to pick up and open it at home it was messed and missing my pepperoni. And I go back to the store they admitted that I ordered it but they forgot to write it down and didn't charge me. What do you mean, you forgot to put what I asked for on there, that’s not my fault , and then the crust is burnt, but the cheese and sauce are all messy, they keep saying that I fell down, I was upside down, excuse me. I was walking around one minutes away from the store.they had bad attitude and will never come back again
Always incredible, delicious buffalo style food. Be sure to try the bbq chicken finger sub :)
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 4
David Thompson
Only way I can think of improving the "stinger" ....is to take a ride to North Tonawanda. Order a "stinger" from Dwyers...next door to the "Riviera Theater " You will not be disappointed...GUARANTEED!!
Becca K Wicher
Wheelchair accessibility: No Ramp into building. No accessible eating area outside. Inside cramped. Not wheelchair accessible bathroom.
Really good pizzas. The meatball sub is a MUST HAVE! It is by far one of the best meatball sub I ever. The meatballs are sliced, which is really nice.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 4
First bite of pizza, instead of a good cheese pull, I pull a long brown hair from my mouth that was embedded in the cheese. I showed the manager Judy and she acted as if I was bothering her . Her response was, "It happens." No apology, no attempt to compensate. I had to ask for a refund, which I was given begrudgingly. Horrible customer service.
I’m not sure if there was a new employee working or what but this is what the entire sub looked like. Not what I remember ordering from pap’s.
Literally a sliver of meat across my entire sub AND I had added bacon to it.
As soon as I took the subs out of the bag I knew something was off. Literally looked like I picked up foot longs from Ted’s, that’s how small they were.
Crazy when you’re paying $28 for two subs.
The pizza was ready on time, hot and delicious.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 4
Love their pizza. Very consistent. It's honestly a nice compromise between thin crust and typical buffalo style. Always on time and the price is very fair given the current state of pizza cost
Best pizza in Orchard Park. Especially the white pizza.
Not much of a dinning area. A few tables and booths. I Perfer to only do take out. Pizza on Wed deal is pretty good. The pizza is constant. Nice flavor sauce. Plenty of cheese and tasty pepperoni. We added onions and the pizza was wonderful. Highly recommend. Pizza will always take longer than expected. Allow 35min no matter what they say. I tend to always wait. Wednesday is the day to go for the special large cheese & one item. Try you'll be back!!! 😜
Good pizza!
Nice little place. Good pizza nice staff. New spot to go😁
I have been Oder and waiting for 35 minutes. When my brother go to pick up and open it at home it was messed and missing my pepperoni. And I go back to the store they admitted that I ordered it but they forgot to write it down and didn't charge me. What do you mean, you forgot to put what I asked for on there, that’s not my fault , and then the crust is burnt, but the cheese and sauce are all messy, they keep saying that I fell down, I was upside down, excuse me. I was walking around one minutes away from the store.they had bad attitude and will never come back again
Restaurantji Recommends
The best pizza ever?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Definitely the best pizza around!
Food: 5
Recommended dishes: White Pizza, Pepperoni Pizza
Always incredible, delicious buffalo style food. Be sure to try the bbq chicken finger sub :)
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 4
Only way I can think of improving the "stinger" ....is to take a ride to North Tonawanda. Order a "stinger" from Dwyers...next door to the "Riviera Theater " You will not be disappointed...GUARANTEED!!
Wheelchair accessibility: No Ramp into building. No accessible eating area outside. Inside cramped. Not wheelchair accessible bathroom.
Atmosphere: 2
Service: 3
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza
Loading...