Subway

3515 Amelia Dr, Orchard Park
(716) 821-7827

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Jenna Haring

Barely toasted my sub .

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 1

Service: 1

Lisa Clute Ellis

Bought pizza roll. It had one peice of pepperoni and maybe a teaspoon of cheese. First bite was only bread. Next bite would have been only bread. I asked for my money back but person refused. He remade and remake wasnt much better. It had 2 peices of pepperoni and maybe 2 teaspoons of cheese. I also heard the man haulk a giant lougie while my back was returned so I didn't dare try it. Also bought a churro and ice tea. Gold Tea was great. Churro tasted bitter and strangely chewy. Left hungry. #subwayfail.

Food: 1

Service: 1

Jessica F

This store is filthy. There is always only one man working who makes you feel unwelcome. The veggies are not fresh. The cookies taste like they have been left out for days. The bread is stale. This location is so convenient but I’ll drive the extra distance to go to a different one from now on.

Food: 1

Service: 2

Damion Torres

The worker serving me digged in the garbage to get another coupon but probably didnt work with gloves and made my food with the same gloves and didn't know my coupon went with my sub and made me pay extra

Sean Bergeron

This place is never open on time.
There is nobody here and this is like the third time within 2 months.

Tim Wysocki

Raced after work to get there before closing. 8:40pm locked up tight, sign on the door literally says 9:00pm. Just wanted to get a salad. The guy even saw me and didn't do anything or say anything.

Service: 1

Jennifer Conway

Very disappointed!!! We ordered a sub through the app along with a special price. There was hardly any meat on it, there was empty spots where the meat should have been. I want my money back!!!!

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 1

Service: 4

Brad Felton

This is a $14 dollar footlong on flatbread? They won’t accept coupons on eligible items. Go anywhere else!

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Pamela DiNicola formerly Smith

The Subway in the Quaker crossing in Orchard Park N.Y. is really bad. We had a really bad experience with this Subway. Management was a big problem.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 5

Service: 1

Recommended dishes: Subway Footlong Cookie, Veggie Delite, Auntie Anne's Footlong Pretzel, Pizza Sub, Vitamin Water xxx, Chocolate Chip Cookie, Fritos Original, White Chip Macadamia Nut, Doritos Nacho Cheese, Subway Club, Grilled Chicken, All-American Club, Cookies, The Hotshot Italiano

Kaylyn Love

This is probably one of my worst Subway experiences. The only redeeming feature was that the sandwich bread seemed relatively fresh. The bathrooms needed cleaning and the tables were clearly not wiped. Our server appeared to be wearing sandals and took a call mid preparation of our sandwiches. Definitely not a location I would ever recommend.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 3

Service: 2

Recommended dishes: Veggie Delite

M K

Place was gross. Tables were disgusting, floors were dirty, just a mess. Worker making the subs had no gloves on while touching the food. He was also talking to someone on his phone while preparing food. Nasty.

Jordyn Jaworski

They put absolutely no food on your sub. So stingy. I paid $10 for a sub with nothing on it. ridiculous. If you're in the mood for Subway, make sure you go to a different one because you will still be hungry when you leave this place.

AJ Mihalko

Be aware. They will upcharge. You,

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Madeline Jurusik

Never wished I could give a negative star review more in my life. My boyfriend and I placed an online order as the restaurant is open until 6. We get there and the door is locked at 5pm. The order went through and the employee is out back smoking and hasn’t even made it and tells us it’ll be another 10 minutes while he stands there smoking. Not to mention a very old man with an oxygen tank tried to open the door and he did not let him in and even laughed at him. It was awful! We’ve eaten here a few times and this dude is always rude and obnoxious. Corporate should really fire him. All of the bad reviews on this place recently are because of him.

Service: 1

Paul Hackathorn

I’ve been here twice now thinking the first time was just a fluke and decided to give it another try. It seems next to impossible to mess up a subway sub, but this guy will do it every time. He looks and smells very dirty and puts next to no meat on the subs. 5 thin slices of turkey is not enough for a footlong. I’m surprised they are still in business. They also don’t speak English so it might make sense that they mess things up but please just get competent employees. Maybe try to take care of the customer instead of standing in the back picking your nose playing on your phone. Or download Duolingo and make your time on the phone useful 0/10 this place sucks

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Loading...