Tonight we had a wonderful dinner! We've relocated to MA and when we knew we were returning to LI, this was the first reservation we made! Excellent service from a super attentive staff and fabulous food. We never felt rushed and the staff couldn't been kinder. Highly recommend!
Arlene Stack
Fantastic lobster special .Best Napoleon I ever had
James Brown
Great place
DIANE
Our first time here, and we were happy with our experience. Our server was friendly and knowledgeable, and quick to attend to us. The linguini with white clam sauce was superb in flavor and freshness, and the stuffed filet of sole was equally perfectly cooked, with a delicious crabmeat stuffing. Our only disappointment was that both dishes were swimming in sauce, WAY too much. Perhaps the kitchen was off a little because of a really big party in their catering hall, but it was still a really good meal and enjoyable dinner. We'd certainly go back.
Julie
We ate outside at a table right along the water. It was absolutely beautiful. Food was reasonably priced and delicious 🌸. Waiter was great too!
Andrew Cifuni
Had another wonderful experience at Lombardi’s on the Bay. The happy hour is fantastic, with unbeatable views of the Great South Bay. The food and drinks never disappoint, and the atmosphere is always welcoming. A special thanks to our favorite bartender, Donavan, who makes every visit even better.”
Roy
Great food and service. Will come back!
Colleen OHara
Beautiful food beautiful view.
Lynne Ross
We had dinner tonight with friends and the service was incredible. James came up to us multiple times to check in and even moved us to a better table. Our waitress was outstanding! The food was delicious. We will definitely be back. Thank you to James, Jerry Lombardi and the waitstaff for a wonderful evening.
Debbie
Food and service is consistently excellent. However, our anniversary dinner experience was marred by a very loud group of 4 sitting in the corner next to us. Their loudness from alcohol intake was worsened even more when they were offered “complimentary drinks from Mr. Lombardi.” Shame on you
Lombardi's on the Bay truly shines when it comes to service. From the moment we walked in, the staff made us feel like VIPs. Our server was friendly, knowledgeable, and made excellent recommendations—he was always just the right amount of attentive, checking in without being intrusive. James, the manager, took the time to personally introduce himself and ensure everything was to our liking. He even shared a few behind-the-scenes insights about the menu. His hands-on approach and genuine care for the guests made the experience feel extra special. It’s rare to find service that so effortlessly blends professionalism with warmth!
James Romero
First off I like to say I have visited the establishment in Holbrook and patchauge on numerous occasions. I thoroughly enjoyed their food. I ordered the stuffed veal and my wife the chicken cutlet parm. This review is based off the service not the food (veal portion was very small but good). The waiter first off was very forgetful not stating choice of pasta with the chicken, and not telling us about the specials. That was pretty much the beginning. We were hungry being we had a long day traveling and just wanted to have a good meal and relax. There is so much to say regarding this waiter so I’ll give just the highlights. We wanted a refresh of bread do to the shrimp app was in a sauce that was quite tasty for dunking purposes. Well about 20 minutes our bread came out after asking someone else. My veal was served without a knife, the beverage I ordered before my meal came was served during my main meal. The waiter was either pre occupied with a larger table ( bigger tip) I suppose. Any way the service was horrible. My meal was 155 dollars not cheap thats not including the tip. So you never know who you will serve and if the would take the time to wright a review. Treat your customer’s like they matter you never know who will visit your establishment. And your waiter just didn’t care about his customers . Very sad for a place with a reputation like yours.
June
Manager and staff were very accommodating and friendly... Food was very good and drinks as well!!! Prices were higher than they should've been for both food and drinks but nowadays it's impossible to find a reasonable good dinner it seems.... I would recommend it as a place to go if you like the outdoors or being near the water and enjoy good food !!
Kathy Maher
Love the bartenders, especially Donovan. He always has a magnificent smile and is very social. James the general manager is always around to make sure everyone is taken case of. The scenery on the Great South Bay is beautiful. Best place to spend spend a telaxing Friday
Mary
This restaurant was amazing! The food was so good, but what really made it special was our waiter, Chris, and the general manager, James. Chris and James were super personal, friendly, and made the whole night feel so easy and fun. The view was also amazing, right on the water with a beautiful sunset. Definitely recommend! Can’t wait to go back!
Tonight we had a wonderful dinner! We've relocated to MA and when we knew we were returning to LI, this was the first reservation we made! Excellent service from a super attentive staff and fabulous food. We never felt rushed and the staff couldn't been kinder. Highly recommend!
Fantastic lobster special .Best Napoleon I ever had
Great place
Our first time here, and we were happy with our experience. Our server was friendly and knowledgeable, and quick to attend to us. The linguini with white clam sauce was superb in flavor and freshness, and the stuffed filet of sole was equally perfectly cooked, with a delicious crabmeat stuffing. Our only disappointment was that both dishes were swimming in sauce, WAY too much. Perhaps the kitchen was off a little because of a really big party in their catering hall, but it was still a really good meal and enjoyable dinner. We'd certainly go back.
We ate outside at a table right along the water. It was absolutely beautiful. Food was reasonably priced and delicious 🌸. Waiter was great too!
Had another wonderful experience at Lombardi’s on the Bay. The happy hour is fantastic, with unbeatable views of the Great South Bay. The food and drinks never disappoint, and the atmosphere is always welcoming. A special thanks to our favorite bartender, Donavan, who makes every visit even better.”
Great food and service. Will come back!
Beautiful food beautiful view.
We had dinner tonight with friends and the service was incredible. James came up to us multiple times to check in and even moved us to a better table. Our waitress was outstanding! The food was delicious. We will definitely be back. Thank you to James, Jerry Lombardi and the waitstaff for a wonderful evening.
Food and service is consistently excellent. However, our anniversary dinner experience was marred by a very loud group of 4 sitting in the corner next to us. Their loudness from alcohol intake was worsened even more when they were offered “complimentary drinks from Mr. Lombardi.” Shame on you
Restaurantji Recommends
Lombardi's on the Bay truly shines when it comes to service. From the moment we walked in, the staff made us feel like VIPs. Our server was friendly, knowledgeable, and made excellent recommendations—he was always just the right amount of attentive, checking in without being intrusive. James, the manager, took the time to personally introduce himself and ensure everything was to our liking. He even shared a few behind-the-scenes insights about the menu. His hands-on approach and genuine care for the guests made the experience feel extra special. It’s rare to find service that so effortlessly blends professionalism with warmth!
First off I like to say I have visited the establishment in Holbrook and patchauge on numerous occasions. I thoroughly enjoyed their food. I ordered the stuffed veal and my wife the chicken cutlet parm. This review is based off the service not the food (veal portion was very small but good). The waiter first off was very forgetful not stating choice of pasta with the chicken, and not telling us about the specials. That was pretty much the beginning. We were hungry being we had a long day traveling and just wanted to have a good meal and relax. There is so much to say regarding this waiter so I’ll give just the highlights. We wanted a refresh of bread do to the shrimp app was in a sauce that was quite tasty for dunking purposes. Well about 20 minutes our bread came out after asking someone else. My veal was served without a knife, the beverage I ordered before my meal came was served during my main meal. The waiter was either pre occupied with a larger table ( bigger tip) I suppose. Any way the service was horrible. My meal was 155 dollars not cheap thats not including the tip. So you never know who you will serve and if the would take the time to wright a review. Treat your customer’s like they matter you never know who will visit your establishment. And your waiter just didn’t care about his customers . Very sad for a place with a reputation like yours.
Manager and staff were very accommodating and friendly... Food was very good and drinks as well!!! Prices were higher than they should've been for both food and drinks but nowadays it's impossible to find a reasonable good dinner it seems.... I would recommend it as a place to go if you like the outdoors or being near the water and enjoy good food !!
Love the bartenders, especially Donovan. He always has a magnificent smile and is very social. James the general manager is always around to make sure everyone is taken case of. The scenery on the Great South Bay is beautiful. Best place to spend spend a telaxing Friday
This restaurant was amazing! The food was so good, but what really made it special was our waiter, Chris, and the general manager, James. Chris and James were super personal, friendly, and made the whole night feel so easy and fun. The view was also amazing, right on the water with a beautiful sunset. Definitely recommend! Can’t wait to go back!
Loading...