My Hero

25 E Patchogue Yaphank Rd, Patchogue
(631) 289-4376

Recent Reviews

Marjorite Velasquez

Was told about this place from a coworker of mine about a year ago and it’s my absolute favorite spot!!! I LOVE their chicken caesar salad & their sandwiches are amazing! Such amazing and kind people. Absolutely recommend this place!!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Yourstrulydragon

the only hero place i'm going to moving forward came here for the first time bc the other one customer service was terrible, this place simple i ordered when i was 5 min away and it was ready when i walked in.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

David Lettieri

Great!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Bronx Bomber

Alicia Yarborough

Been ordering lunch sandwiches from them a lot lately and they’ve been delicious. They catered a party for us with two hero trays and it was excellent! Just tried breakfast sandwiches and they were really good as well - plus great prices. We are very happy to have them close by!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Rob G.

I have been coming to My Hero for 30 years and the owners or an owner always seem to be there. Keeps the quality very high and the experience is mellow and you can always find a Yankee great somewhere on the walls of this eatery. Joe is quiet the yanks fan. Love the food the service and the experience of a small town hero shoppe

denise jimenez

Had to give at least one star to be able to leave a review. Ordered 61.00 worth of food for office lunch today. We haven't made it through the afternoon and 3 staff are sick from it so far. Chicken cutlet was dry and old tasting ... Italian hero- let's just say nope ! They literally splashed a drop of dressing, tomato wasn't even ripe had no color to it..and the meats looked like the packaged Aldi lunch meats. Egg sandwich was a joke. All sodas were warm except for the one they charged us for and did not put in the order I'm assuming that was the cold one left in fridge .Needless to say We will not be ordering from them again .

Andrew M.

My Hero's Cuban sandwich is quite delicious for the money. That is why I giving them three and a half stars.

William Thoden

Excellent heroes! Very friendly staff!

Sam

For the love of God DO NOT GET THE CHICKEN. it was the worst chicken cutlet I have ever had. I got the kraken and the chicken was terrible, room temperature at best, tasted like it was over a week old and sitting out on the counter the entire time. The cheese was thick and cold like they just took it out of the fridge. I truly feel like I'm going to vomit. So please do yourself a favor and never get the chicken there. Other stuff wasn't bad

Joe Cullen

WOW!! Outstanding Family-run business. Great tasting sandwiches (Heros). The cold cuts, cheeses and all ingredients are always fresh, GREAT variety of fresh breads, and they have the BEST coleslaw around. You will enjoy it, Breakfast or Lunch.Joe Cullen

George Russell

Fast friendly super staffAlways get what you order they don't skimp out

ditrMEDIA

I used to come here with my mom & grandma 20 years ago. Stopped in while visiting home and was happy to see little has changed. The food was just as I remembered it too. Thank you guys for remaining the same all these years. My grandma is long passed now, but sitting in your parking lot writing this review while eating my subway series makes me feel like I’m right back in her back seat.

John C.

I'd say 4 out of 5 times meals is great and prices are lower than other delis. Once and awhile you will get a bad sandwich but all in all I order here every single time I want roast beef bc they have the best roast beef around 90% of time cooked perfectly. Portions are kind of small compared to other delis where they put a ton of coldcuts on your sandwich but it's a decent amount cheaper and it's quality.

Ricky Jay

Food is great but their hours are very strange. How are you closed at 2:30pm on a Friday? ?

Melissa Powers

Went to My Hero after reading reviews and they had 4.5 stars. Ordered 3 sandwiches. All three were very dry. Chicken club-chicken way over cooked. Basically inedible.Grilled chicken- chicken was dry and they did not put the bacon onBronx Bomber-again very dry meat. Barely any cheese or gravy. Will not be returning to this location.

Load More