Had to order my favorite type of slice, which looked really good, but the Buffalo chicken slice was not what I expected. It had a lot of sauce on it, so I figured it would be spicy, but it was the complete opposite. The sauce is basically there to just cover the chicken, and it was very greasy. The other slice I had was chicken parm, and I can proudly say that was a delicious slice. I would gladly eat that again. Service was good after I got the attention of one of the 4 guys standing around about the slices of get an idea.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Chicken Parm Slice
Dee Lavery
Excellent yummy pizza ? and foodThank you for your kindness and Delicious
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Holly Steuernagel
Had a slice was
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Regular Pizza Slice
breanna rolla
We ordered delivery to our new apartment and the buffalo chicken pie had just red hot sauce on it & chunks of chicken. It looked red in color, and had no melted cheeses. It was the worst buffalo pie we have ever had. Also the cheesy bread was just a roll with a heaping help of garlic on top of it. Wild, idk after reading reviews we were excited to try this place but we won’t be back, I don’t know how you mess up a buffalo pie. We threw out the whole pie it was so sad, especially to throw away $40 somethin dollars. Whole order came out to $70 way too expensive for some pizza.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 2
T A.
I've been going there since i was a child, was prob the best pizza around patchogue for years but they must have sold the shop which hey good for them, great people and they deserve to retire but these new owners definitely ain't gonna last lol. Pizza was terrible and the people working there def shouldn't be in the pizza business.
Laura N.
Just bought luncheon special ...ravioli 2 orders 4 ravioli each last week 5 ravioli same price.owner said I can't do it every week.They are crooks and liars go some place else and owner you have a good day now
C T
NEW OWNERS ARE TERRIBLE! They sold to an Indian family who have no clue what they are doing! Just ruined my saturday trying to pick up a pie to have them tell me they burnt it and could now put another one up! Didnt even throw another one in right away, let me show up first. Disgusting! After 20 years will never go
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Laura I.
ehhh..i got a baked ziti slice and it was literally 98% cheese it was so overwhelming and wasn't good at all, i had to throw it out :( i couldn't even eat it..i got mozz sticks also and they were so cold :/
Albert R.
Garbage food. Used to be very good pizza but I think it's been taken over by new owners. If you guys are reading this...I'm the guy who ordered the pie well done.
Our first experience ordering from Nino's Pizzeria was great!! We decided to give it a try after reading all those fantastic reviews and learning that they offer delivery. Let me tell you, it definitely lived up to the hype! We ordered 3 different pies and their garlic knots. I requested a thin, well done crust. The regular pie with pepperoni had the perfect balance of flavors, with a robust tomato sauce, gooey cheese, and savory pepperoni. The white pie was a heavenly combination of creamy ricotta cheese, garlic, and herbs, creating a rich and indulgent taste. And, of course, the margarita pie, with its fresh basil, ripe tomatoes, and melted mozzarella, transported us straight to the streets of Italy. One thing that stood out to me was how perfectly they executed the thin and crispy crust we had requested. It added a delightful crunch to every bite, making the pizza even more enjoyable. There was no flop which I love! Another great aspect of Nino's Pizzeria is their delivery service. The fact that they offer delivery adds convenience and makes them a go-to choice for a delicious meal. Overall, Nino's Pizzeria truly impressed us with their fantastic pizza. From the perfectly thin and crispy crust to the delectable toppings, each pie was a delightful experience. Whether dining in or ordering for delivery, I highly recommend Nino's Pizzeria for a satisfying and enjoyable pizza feast.
Amanda A.
Amazing pizza! Quality ingredients, beautiful presentation, and friendly service. Nothing more to ask for!
Raju Appukuttan
High Quality Pizzas.Great Variety.Too good to eat.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Rachel Ruquet
Forever my favorite spot on the island. The pizza is amazing. An ex watched me eat an entire pie in one sitting. I’m unapologetic; 10 fuckin’ stars .Parking: I’ll park on the damn roof if it means I’m getting pizza from Nino’s
Had to order my favorite type of slice, which looked really good, but the Buffalo chicken slice was not what I expected. It had a lot of sauce on it, so I figured it would be spicy, but it was the complete opposite. The sauce is basically there to just cover the chicken, and it was very greasy. The other slice I had was chicken parm, and I can proudly say that was a delicious slice. I would gladly eat that again. Service was good after I got the attention of one of the 4 guys standing around about the slices of get an idea.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Chicken Parm Slice
Excellent yummy pizza ? and foodThank you for your kindness and Delicious
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Had a slice was
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Regular Pizza Slice
We ordered delivery to our new apartment and the buffalo chicken pie had just red hot sauce on it & chunks of chicken. It looked red in color, and had no melted cheeses. It was the worst buffalo pie we have ever had. Also the cheesy bread was just a roll with a heaping help of garlic on top of it. Wild, idk after reading reviews we were excited to try this place but we won’t be back, I don’t know how you mess up a buffalo pie. We threw out the whole pie it was so sad, especially to throw away $40 somethin dollars. Whole order came out to $70 way too expensive for some pizza.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 2
I've been going there since i was a child, was prob the best pizza around patchogue for years but they must have sold the shop which hey good for them, great people and they deserve to retire but these new owners definitely ain't gonna last lol. Pizza was terrible and the people working there def shouldn't be in the pizza business.
Just bought luncheon special ...ravioli 2 orders 4 ravioli each last week 5 ravioli same price.owner said I can't do it every week.They are crooks and liars go some place else and owner you have a good day now
NEW OWNERS ARE TERRIBLE! They sold to an Indian family who have no clue what they are doing! Just ruined my saturday trying to pick up a pie to have them tell me they burnt it and could now put another one up! Didnt even throw another one in right away, let me show up first. Disgusting! After 20 years will never go
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
ehhh..i got a baked ziti slice and it was literally 98% cheese it was so overwhelming and wasn't good at all, i had to throw it out :( i couldn't even eat it..i got mozz sticks also and they were so cold :/
Garbage food. Used to be very good pizza but I think it's been taken over by new owners. If you guys are reading this...I'm the guy who ordered the pie well done.
Good pizza. Meatball on pizza is a must for my
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Restaurantji Recommends
Our first experience ordering from Nino's Pizzeria was great!! We decided to give it a try after reading all those fantastic reviews and learning that they offer delivery. Let me tell you, it definitely lived up to the hype! We ordered 3 different pies and their garlic knots. I requested a thin, well done crust. The regular pie with pepperoni had the perfect balance of flavors, with a robust tomato sauce, gooey cheese, and savory pepperoni. The white pie was a heavenly combination of creamy ricotta cheese, garlic, and herbs, creating a rich and indulgent taste. And, of course, the margarita pie, with its fresh basil, ripe tomatoes, and melted mozzarella, transported us straight to the streets of Italy. One thing that stood out to me was how perfectly they executed the thin and crispy crust we had requested. It added a delightful crunch to every bite, making the pizza even more enjoyable. There was no flop which I love! Another great aspect of Nino's Pizzeria is their delivery service. The fact that they offer delivery adds convenience and makes them a go-to choice for a delicious meal. Overall, Nino's Pizzeria truly impressed us with their fantastic pizza. From the perfectly thin and crispy crust to the delectable toppings, each pie was a delightful experience. Whether dining in or ordering for delivery, I highly recommend Nino's Pizzeria for a satisfying and enjoyable pizza feast.
Amazing pizza! Quality ingredients, beautiful presentation, and friendly service. Nothing more to ask for!
High Quality Pizzas.Great Variety.Too good to eat.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Forever my favorite spot on the island. The pizza is amazing. An ex watched me eat an entire pie in one sitting. I’m unapologetic; 10 fuckin’ stars .Parking: I’ll park on the damn roof if it means I’m getting pizza from Nino’s
Great pizza, and excellent hot heros!!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Salad Pizza