Great place to be after hours! Dj was great and music was on point!
Kathy Kuroly
We had reservations for the Salem Sisters pop up, Monday 10/13 @ 8pm. We arrived at 7:30, doors locked, no lights on. It appears that the show was cancelled without prior notification. Received a text at 8 pm that the show was not happening.We know it was an outside company doing the performance but That Meatball Place contracted with them and had an obligation to notify the customers of the cancellation either by a call, text or even a sign on the door.
Taylor Rueb
Good food friendly staff would definitely go back again.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Cailie Tweedy
Door security is 10/10. But inside security… so rude. I have Prescription tinted glasses due to light sensitivity and I asked security to accommodate my needs and they said take my glasses off, they aren’t prescription n that I’m lying after I showed him a photo of my prescription and he was super aggressive about it. Borderline discrimination, they wouldn’t have asked me to take my glasses off if they were clear but because I have tinted lenses, it’s a problem.
Atmosphere: 5
Service: 1
Kaitlynn Riordan
The food was great, and the waitress was extremely attentive and kind. We also went on a Friday so they had a raffle of sorts and my daughter was so excited when she won a $20 gift card! I was sad to see that this place was not busy at all on a Friday night, but also worked out for our family since we had a 2 month old with us who slept mostly through dinner. We will definitely come back!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Alexandra
My family tried the classic, sausage and peppers, and eggplant meatballs. All were incredibly delicious! I also really loved the decor/atmosphere. I will definitely be back! 
On Point Everything
Breakfast food was great ( steak and eggs ) with bacon jelly you need to try it ! The customer service from Allison A+ , thank you meatball place .
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Joseph Mastriano
Went there Sunday night for impromptu birthday get together .. had a large group and Anthony and Kaylan were awesome..
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Christine Whalin
The Sunset Sangria was lovely. The Meatball trio sampler was also soooo good. Gluten free wings and fries were also very good! Our server Jay was great (and made a stellar hand shaken Sangria)!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Taii potatoie
The place wasn't bad, but their cocktails were not great, and they were pricey too.
Diet cokes tasted gross sent them back, sprite tasted gross sent it back, something is wrong with their soda fountains. Kept the iced tea which tasted bad just because I was tired of bothering the very friendly waitress. Food was gross . Amazed how a place on main st can’t cook decent food. Do you even taste your menu?
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 4
Chrissy D
This is specifically rating for when it’s just the bar at night. I’ve yet to go there for dinner but have heard good things about their food as wel
Atmosphere: 3
Service: 4
Jennifer Whitbeck
Like all the other reviews. The bouncers are chasing skirts and let all the girls in and won’t let the boys in. Bullying them at the front door. I have seen them go out together to beat up on the boys. I don’t know who’s responsible for these bouncers but there are so may reviews. The should be sued immediately.
Gemma
If you want to run an enjoyable bar and night experience I suggest getting better bouncers/ security! The bar was dying out considering it was past 1 AM and the bouncers gave some of us an issue about shoes/ outfits (2 out of the 11 of us). I would get that for a club in Manhattan but this is a random bar in patchogue. Also if you want to establish a dress code maybe you should put that on your Instagram flyers or website. You posted the event and it says nothing about a dress code, IN FACT it actually says “dance off the bbq” and the kid was wearing clothes coming from a bbq😭 Bouncers were pushing and threatening us. Don’t go here. Go somewhere with a more welcoming and fun environment.
Atmosphere: 1
Service: 1
Cameron Little
An alright establishment in Patchogue. Only ever been there for their food, which tends to be pretty good. However, based on other reviews, the treatment of some of the bouncers should be brought in question.
Great place to be after hours! Dj was great and music was on point!
We had reservations for the Salem Sisters pop up, Monday 10/13 @ 8pm. We arrived at 7:30, doors locked, no lights on. It appears that the show was cancelled without prior notification. Received a text at 8 pm that the show was not happening.We know it was an outside company doing the performance but That Meatball Place contracted with them and had an obligation to notify the customers of the cancellation either by a call, text or even a sign on the door.
Good food friendly staff would definitely go back again.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Door security is 10/10. But inside security… so rude. I have Prescription tinted glasses
due to light sensitivity and I asked security to accommodate my needs and they said take my glasses off, they aren’t prescription n that I’m lying after I showed him a photo of my prescription and he was super aggressive about it. Borderline discrimination, they wouldn’t have asked me to take my glasses off if they were clear but because I have tinted lenses, it’s a problem.
Atmosphere: 5
Service: 1
The food was great, and the waitress was extremely attentive and kind. We also went on a Friday so they had a raffle of sorts and my daughter was so excited when she won a $20 gift card! I was sad to see that this place was not busy at all on a Friday night, but also worked out for our family since we had a 2 month old with us who slept mostly through dinner. We will definitely come back!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
My family tried the classic, sausage and peppers, and eggplant meatballs. All were incredibly delicious! I also really loved the decor/atmosphere. I will definitely be back! 
Breakfast food was great ( steak and eggs ) with bacon jelly you need to try it ! The customer service from Allison A+ , thank you meatball place .
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Went there Sunday night for impromptu birthday get together .. had a large group and Anthony and Kaylan were awesome..
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
The Sunset Sangria was lovely. The Meatball trio sampler was also soooo good. Gluten free wings and fries were also very good! Our server Jay was great (and made a stellar hand shaken Sangria)!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
The place wasn't bad, but their cocktails were not great, and they were pricey too.
Restaurantji Recommends
Diet cokes tasted gross sent them back, sprite tasted gross sent it back, something is wrong with their soda fountains. Kept the iced tea which tasted bad just because I was tired of bothering the very friendly waitress. Food was gross . Amazed how a place on main st can’t cook decent food. Do you even taste your menu?
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 4
This is specifically rating for when it’s just the bar at night. I’ve yet to go there for dinner but have heard good things about their food as wel
Atmosphere: 3
Service: 4
Like all the other reviews. The bouncers are chasing skirts and let all the girls in and won’t let the boys in. Bullying them at the front door. I have seen them go out together to beat up on the boys. I don’t know who’s responsible for these bouncers but there are so may reviews. The should be sued immediately.
If you want to run an enjoyable bar and night experience I suggest getting better bouncers/ security! The bar was dying out considering it was past 1 AM and the bouncers gave some of us an issue about shoes/ outfits (2 out of the 11 of us). I would get that for a club in Manhattan but this is a random bar in patchogue. Also if you want to establish a dress code maybe you should put that on your Instagram flyers or website. You posted the event and it says nothing about a dress code, IN FACT it actually says “dance off the bbq” and the kid was wearing clothes coming from a bbq😭 Bouncers were pushing and threatening us. Don’t go here. Go somewhere with a more welcoming and fun environment.
Atmosphere: 1
Service: 1
An alright establishment in Patchogue. Only ever been there for their food, which tends to be pretty good. However, based on other reviews, the treatment of some of the bouncers should be brought in question.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 4
Service: 2
Loading...