Now the Amsterdam in Patchogue. Put our name on the wait list at 7:20pm. By 9:15 still hadn't been seated even though there were many open tables throughout the evening. Can't rate the food because we never got to eat. No place to put your coat or put down a drink unless you happen to get a spot at the bar. They took a $20 cover charge for the band when we came in but after a little while I noticed they stopped charging people when they came in. Service was awful and management was totally absent. Stay away! Plenty of other places to go in Patchogue for music and food.
Atmosphere: 1
Service: 1
Yatti
Way too many bouncers and way too aggressive for no reason. As you can see from other reviews, they seriously need to humble themselves and check their behavior. The way they act and present themselves is intimidating and unnecessary, it killed the vibe completely. Not worth it.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Rich Straus
Attended the holiday Grinch themed dinner. Very enjoyable, interaction with characters, good food and adult drinks.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Lili
Trashy place with big head bouncers that need to get their eyes checked. IDs with photos and pass scanners and they try to say its fake. Thats why the business is failing!! Saturday night and EMPTY.
Marcos Vazquez
Very good place, very good music and drinks; Although I would recommend that the DJ put new clues...
Laura James
Went for a pop up show. It was a great time. Our waitress was out of this world. She had a great personality, helpful and attentive. Her name was Allison.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Daniel Miranda
This place is a joke. It was raining, and I was refused entry because I was wearing boots—as if sticking to a rigid dress code in a downpour somehow matters more than treating customers with basic respect. When I asked for a manager, they didn’t even bother sending one. Instead, they pushed me off to a security guard who acted like giving attitude was part of the job description. If this is how they treat people before they even walk through the door, I can’t imagine how bad it must be inside. I’m done with this place, and I wouldn’t send anyone here unless they enjoy being disrespected for no good reason.
Atmosphere: 1
Service: 1
Allen Zelenka
Yikes….dont go here before 11. Old people only bad live music and crazy bad drinks. Like wow I spent 40$ on two shitty drinks that I had to throw them out waste of time waste of money
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 2
Service: 2
Renee Bandes
We planned on going to Buttermilk but didn't have the time to wait so came for brunch and what a happy accident. The 4 of us all got different brunch meals and all were unbelievably delicious!!! The service was atrentive and geeat energy. Highly recommend!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Alexandra Santiago
Went for their Halloween Pop up it was so amazing the sisters were so talented and the environment was so great. My husband got the vodka pasta and it was delicious. I will say we got the sangria for two and it tasted like water which was not great. I also got the pear and fig flatbread and was extremely disappointed. First the prosciutto was fried and tasted like bacon the delicious prosciutto flavor was not present. I had 2 bites as that was all I could force myself to eat. It tasted spoiled with an aftertaste of sugar. I mentioned to the bartender as we were sitting at the bar that I didn’t like it because it tasted off and was not what was advertised. She responded that’s too bad and asked if I just wanted her to take it out of my way so I didn’t see it or if I wanted to take it home for someone else to eat. She was pushing me to take it home so I did but she did not offer me any type of solution so I could enjoy my food at the restaurant. This was very disappointing as I have never been to a restaurant where they do not try and find a solution for the customers especially after they have made it clear that they have not eaten anything and that was their first meal of the day especially when the food the customer is eating was because of their recommendation. Afterwards she proceeded to offer us dessert and try to push us to order some after we told her he’s full and I still haven’t had dinner. It was disappointing but the atmosphere was fantastic and the Sanderson sisters were extremely nice and made our night extra magical.
Went here for a hocus pocus show, 33 dollars to walk in the door for a 10 minute performance literally 3 songs! Our waitress never came to check on us food was ok but no drinks replenished I did have an espresso martini it was pretty good. The bill came and for 3 people one adult meal, one kid meal and an app....there was a 20 percent gratuity...as the Sanders sisters made their way around the room for a 2 min photo opp they also had a tip bucket! If I could give zero stars I would have! I have done many pop ups over the years and by far this was awful. Even the decor was unimpressive
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 2
Service: 1
Jose Alban
Food was average but this pretzel was a hit with my group and the drinks were alright. This place is a little pricey for what you get. But you can be the judge
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 5
Jenny Baez Rosado
Great place to be after hours! Dj was great and music was on point!
Kathy Kuroly
We had reservations for the Salem Sisters pop up, Monday 10/13 @ 8pm. We arrived at 7:30, doors locked, no lights on. It appears that the show was cancelled without prior notification. Received a text at 8 pm that the show was not happening.We know it was an outside company doing the performance but That Meatball Place contracted with them and had an obligation to notify the customers of the cancellation either by a call, text or even a sign on the door.
Taylor Rueb
Good food friendly staff would definitely go back again.
Now the Amsterdam in Patchogue. Put our name on the wait list at 7:20pm. By 9:15 still hadn't been seated even though there were many open tables throughout the evening. Can't rate the food because we never got to eat. No place to put your coat or put down a drink unless you happen to get a spot at the bar. They took a $20 cover charge for the band when we came in but after a little while I noticed they stopped charging people when they came in. Service was awful and management was totally absent. Stay away! Plenty of other places to go in Patchogue for music and food.
Atmosphere: 1
Service: 1
Way too many bouncers and way too aggressive for no reason. As you can see from other reviews, they seriously need to humble themselves and check their behavior. The way they act and present themselves is intimidating and unnecessary, it killed the vibe completely. Not worth it.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Attended the holiday Grinch themed dinner. Very enjoyable, interaction with characters, good food and adult drinks.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Trashy place with big head bouncers that need to get their eyes checked. IDs with photos and pass scanners and they try to say its fake. Thats why the business is failing!! Saturday night and EMPTY.
Very good place, very good music and drinks; Although I would recommend that the DJ put new clues...
Went for a pop up show. It was a great time. Our waitress was out of this world. She had a great personality, helpful and attentive. Her name was Allison.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
This place is a joke. It was raining, and I was refused entry because I was wearing boots—as if sticking to a rigid dress code in a downpour somehow matters more than treating customers with basic respect. When I asked for a manager, they didn’t even bother sending one. Instead, they pushed me off to a security guard who acted like giving attitude was part of the job description.
If this is how they treat people before they even walk through the door, I can’t imagine how bad it must be inside. I’m done with this place, and I wouldn’t send anyone here unless they enjoy being disrespected for no good reason.
Atmosphere: 1
Service: 1
Yikes….dont go here before 11. Old people only bad live music and crazy bad drinks. Like wow I spent 40$ on two shitty drinks that I had to throw them out waste of time waste of money
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 2
Service: 2
We planned on going to Buttermilk but didn't have the time to wait so came for brunch and what a happy accident. The 4 of us all got different brunch meals and all were unbelievably delicious!!! The service was atrentive and geeat energy. Highly recommend!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Went for their Halloween Pop up it was so amazing the sisters were so talented and the environment was so great. My husband got the vodka pasta and it was delicious. I will say we got the sangria for two and it tasted like water which was not great. I also got the pear and fig flatbread and was extremely disappointed. First the prosciutto was fried and tasted like bacon the delicious prosciutto flavor was not present. I had 2 bites as that was all I could force myself to eat. It tasted spoiled with an aftertaste of sugar. I mentioned to the bartender as we were sitting at the bar that I didn’t like it because it tasted off and was not what was advertised. She responded that’s too bad and asked if I just wanted her to take it out of my way so I didn’t see it or if I wanted to take it home for someone else to eat. She was pushing me to take it home so I did but she did not offer me any type of solution so I could enjoy my food at the restaurant. This was very disappointing as I have never been to a restaurant where they do not try and find a solution for the customers especially after they have made it clear that they have not eaten anything and that was their first meal of the day especially when the food the customer is eating was because of their recommendation. Afterwards she proceeded to offer us dessert and try to push us to order some after we told her he’s full and I still haven’t had dinner. It was disappointing but the atmosphere was fantastic and the Sanderson sisters were extremely nice and made our night extra magical.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 1
Service: 2
Restaurantji Recommends
Went here for a hocus pocus show, 33 dollars to walk in the door for a 10 minute performance literally 3 songs! Our waitress never came to check on us food was ok but no drinks replenished I did have an espresso martini it was pretty good. The bill came and for 3 people one adult meal, one kid meal and an app....there was a 20 percent gratuity...as the Sanders sisters made their way around the room for a 2 min photo opp they also had a tip bucket! If I could give zero stars I would have! I have done many pop ups over the years and by far this was awful. Even the decor was unimpressive
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 2
Service: 1
Food was average but this pretzel was a hit with my group and the drinks were alright. This place is a little pricey for what you get. But you can be the judge
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 5
Great place to be after hours! Dj was great and music was on point!
We had reservations for the Salem Sisters pop up, Monday 10/13 @ 8pm. We arrived at 7:30, doors locked, no lights on. It appears that the show was cancelled without prior notification. Received a text at 8 pm that the show was not happening.We know it was an outside company doing the performance but That Meatball Place contracted with them and had an obligation to notify the customers of the cancellation either by a call, text or even a sign on the door.
Good food friendly staff would definitely go back again.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Loading...