Nonna's Brick Oven Pizza

1843 Main St, Peekskill
(914) 737-3222

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Amanda Nelson

The food is always good but the service is terrible. They called me and I missed the call by about 20 seconds. I called back I got put on hold for 10 mins and then hung up on, I called back was placed on hold again and hung up on. I called AGAIN and asked what this issue I told them they called me so I’m trying to figure out what’s going on she puts me on hold for another 5 mins and then someone answer the phone pick up or delivery which legit sent me into rage!!! I just spent 80$ This is absolutely ridiculous! And for someone who’s been getting food for years I will never order delivery again! Or from this location. I’ll stick to the one in Putnam because they know me by name and always are amazing and an absolutely pleasure to be around.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 4

Service: 1

Carolina Rodriguez

I think is under new ownership is terrible I ordered chicken parm they hardly put any cheese I miss the old management this is recipe for disaster stingy with cheese doesn't even put sauce dry old chicken

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Lupo

When it comes to Italian food, It is one of the better ones in the area. Not saying it's great, but options are few. Pizza is good.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 4

Property Manager

This is my brother's.Go to pizza place and I can see why. Enjoyed takeout of my first salad pizza and it was delicious. Ordered a small one and asked for thin crust which made it still doughy but crisp. The salad on top was fresh crisp and abundant. Even came with some balsamic dressing on the side but didn't use it because, as it came was flavorful enough. We also ordered a small meatball pizza, which came with thinly sliced meatballs covering the surface. on regular crust that was delicious as well. But I preferred the crispness of the thin crust and recommend it. Good balance of dough, sauce, cheese and topping.

Food: 5

Izabel Arroyo

The service is prompt, and friendly as well as the food.

Ronald Worgul

Ordered the chicken BLT , meatball parm hero WITHOUT fries and cobb salad. BLT stands for BACON of which there was non lettuce and tomato. I ordered mayo instead of what ever dressing they put on the sandwich and added onions of which there were non and charged for it. Absolutely tasteless. The price of the meatball hero stayed at same price when I removed the fries. Good way to rip off customers. The Cobb salad was good except for the fact that the amount of salad dressing you are given for $18 salad is laughable. I had to use my own. First time there and completely disappointed. Staff were helpful and quick. Only positive. In this day and age with costs the way they are food should be what it is and taste like something and dont make your customers have to use their own salad dressing. Pathetic. Will not be back!!

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 1

Service: 5

Emily Hunter

We order pizza to go - but it's always great!

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 4

Tina Wilkes

Just got large pie delivered! Hot and fresh! Nonna's os our household fav! 😋

Food: 5

Service: 5

MariNegron

The variety alone was great. Slices are not too bready with a nice crunch. We would highly recommend. I enjoyed the Classic Vegetarian and my husband the BBQ chicken slice. Staff were very attentive and friendly. We were even asked if we enjoyed the food and to have a great day upon leaving.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Sharon Thorpe

I had dinner with 30 people
The place was amazing
The food was great
The service was amazing
I recommend it for anyone who wants to have a party
Ps the price was right

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

dolly bawa singh

Loved this place so yummy food wonderful amazing please do visit highly recommend

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Robin Armstrong

I ordered out yesterday the Veal Parmesan and chicken cutlet Parmesan. The chicken Parmesan was good, however the Veal parmesan was horrible. It was so tough like someone’s tongue.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 1

Service: 5

Keith Lynch

Garlic nots are really good, my one
bite score on the pizza would be 7.9.
Good stuff!

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 4

Limb Hacks

It is what it is - a strip mall pizza place for locals out shopping. Large selection. I wasn’t too pleased when someone repeatedly swept dust on me instead of asking me to move while I was at the register to pay, but whatever, the young people these days can be oblivious. My rating is based on the food. The counter people were nice.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 3

Service: 3

Liam Hagen

No surprise the influx of one star reviews. I have been ordering from nonnas for over 20 years. No longer will be ordering from there due to the immense drop off in customer service. This place use to be a powerhouse in the beech shopping center but it has fallen faster than Rome. The customer service on the phone is a joke and then when you go in to pick up and just ask for clarification the spiky head working the register is snickering with his co workers. This place is no longer the same as when Borat and Suprim worked the front. I’m assuming the owner Mike has sold the business as well because it doesn’t have the professionalism as it use to. Place is consistently empty when you go to pickup for a reason. Spend your money elsewhere!

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 3

Service: 1

Loading...