Pelham Bakery

121 Fifth Ave, Pelham
(914) 738-0804

Recent Reviews

Sort by
NY Starlite

Paul is the best. His cakes are moist and delicious and not too sweet

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Sam Minnitti

Old school bakery. Come for the fresh strawberry and whipped cream birthday cake. Al the Italian cookies are great too..eclectic atmosphere. A+

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Michael Roff

Really good cookies and

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

IanBri1213 “Alamo kids” Alamo

I order a Cannoli cake an cookies an extra cannolis they where delicious I will definitely return to the bakery for other yummy desserts an store smell like heaven

Christina N

Traditional family bakery store. Paul is always kind and works very hard to offer a variety of delicious items. He's made cookies custom order and wrapped for me for my child's class and it came out wonderful. Support local! Shop has much nostalgia feeling.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Nicole Pagano

Rainbow cookies were delicious. Great service!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Gregory Darden

Love it❤️

Oscar Gutierrez

Amazing selection of cookies! A lot of custom handmade cakes. Everything delicious! Def a place to go when I am in town!

Phil D

Not the place for a quick coffee and morning bite. The sign out front lists coffee at the very top, but it wasn’t even made until it was ordered. Then, it was low quality and watered down, more like what you’d expect from a gas station. Cookies are dry and crumbly. Pastry was cold and refrigerated, not made fresh. Lastly, the person who was working seemed grumpy, spoke very little (not even a greeting), and seemed to be having a bad day.Maybe a great bakery for larger orders or for cakes/specialties, but the sign out front was a bit misleading.

Ted Amoruso

Great old-fashioned bakery with delicious items and the owner is the nicest gentleman

Alex

The cannolis were so light and good! Rainbow cookies / 7 layer were bussing! Cash only but worth it!

Brenda Alamo

I order a Cannoli cake an cookies an extra cannolis they where delicious I will definitely return to the bakery for other yummy desserts an store smell like heaven

Cathy Campagna

very good went yesterday got a cheese danish and cookies the man matthew was so nice

Susana Mosiello

Delicious treats. Great place and owner is very nice.

Armen Nakashian

An authentic, old school bakery. Delicious cookies, great custom order cakes, and fantastic pastries ( eclairs, napoleons, and tarts). As good as anything I’ve had in the five boroughs.This is a friendly, family owned business. It’s heart warming to go in on the holidays and see lines of people ordering for family dinners and events. They even have spools of string hanging down from the ceiling to tie up your special treats!Highly recommended.

Loading...