Pelham Bakery
121 Fifth Ave, Pelham
(914) 738-0804
Menu
Photos
+17 photos
+16 photos
Add a photo
Recent Reviews
This is an old school bakery the way they're supposed to be. Black and white cookie was fantastic and so was the cherry pie. Cash only folks cash only. That's fine. That's what I expected. Will definitely be going back.
I stopped in recently to pick up a very last minute cake for a birthday celebration, no pre order made. There were so many choices. I picked up a small strawberry shortcake (made with fresh strawberries) and it was a huge hit! Like other reviews mention, this is an “old school bakery” vibe, no frills, just a large variety of home made delicious treats and reasonably priced. I’d highly recommend to anyone in the area in need of a special order dessert, last minute needs,...
Old fashioned bakery, you don’t find these anymore. I’m a big fan of baked goods so had to stop in once I realized how close I work to this bakery. The owner was very friendly, the atmosphere was great, very homey feel, just good vibe all around. I ordered a lb of cookies, rainbow cookies and a linzer tart. Everything was fresh, soft, perfection. Not too sweet like a lot of other Italian cookies.. everything was just perfect!! So happy to have found this place!!
You May Also Like
Pelham Pizza - 113 Fifth Ave
![]()
Pizza, Italian, Seafood, Vegetarian
Sakura - 124 Fifth Ave
![]()
Japanese, Sushi Bar, Sushi, Asian, Vegan
Pelham Diner and Grill - 138 Fifth Ave
![]()
Diner, Mexican