The LOT at Phoenicia Diner

5681 NY-28, Phoenicia
(845) 688-9957

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Rose Quinn

Delicious food fair prices.

Alivia ShiAnne

awesome menu & friendly service! first time coming after a hike & will definitely return!

Rita DiBella

Food was awful Eggs Benedict Dry crab cakes, 1 egg overcooked, 1 egg raw, cube style home fries so greasy. Service was good.

JoAnn Panella

Enjoyed a fabulous breakfast. Smoked trout, herb cream cheese, capers, red onions on a Brooklyn, NY bagel. Amazing!!

Ash Kimber

An absolute gem. One of the standout experiences of our family's trip to the Catskills. A perfectly curated blend of wonderful food, idyllic location, and the best of American hospitality.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

MichaelSloaneH

Brilliant diner, great staff, awesome food, what else to say - recommended! Perfect place for a hearty brekfast/brunch

DStailer

The food can be a little greasy but mostly pretty good. Other than the food it can take a long time to be seated, sometimes up to thirty minutes or so depending on if it’s a weekend or not. They have a wide variety of options and I would recommend, as long as you are ok with waiting for a little while.

phall41890

Food was very good and priced well. Great place to stop after a long day of hiking and outdoor activities.

Janet Kerrigan

Great food using locally sourced ingredients where possible. Been going to this diner since I was a child

boodlelola

Two of us visited around lunchtime on a Sunday. The food was enjoyable (overpriced in some aspects but good quality) and the staff work tremendously hard to keep up with the high turnover of customers. Because of this, I don't feel as though I enjoyed my visit - the whole experience was rushed. We waited 25 minutes for a seat and once we were sat, we were rushed to order, eat and move for the next customer in line. I'd like to visit during the week when it's perhaps calmer and both staff and customers can breathe.

christophee757

Exactly what you would expect for a great American breakfast. Friendly and attentive service. That may not be a gourmet restaurant but you get excellent solid food. thanks!

Trvwr

Stopped here on a Saturday afternoon after hearing great reviews. The location is nice outdoor dining also very nice. The service was awful we ordered at the airstream then waited over 45 minutes I had to ask twice where the food was. The boyfriend really like the trout Trout

savinaw2022

very close to Rail explorers. great staff and food. this was our second time eating here. we enjoyed the meal and service both visits

Dr_Marc_B

The classic US diner experience - booths, super helpful staff, unlimited coffee refills, trucks rolling past and superb food.

michaeldG4289GD

Great place.. good food , great staff , great atmosphere. Convenient access from Rail Explorers. Indoor door and outdoor seating available.

Loading...

The LOT at Phoenicia Diner

5681 NY-28, Phoenicia, NY 12464
(845) 688-9957