Large sit-down dining area in the back. Polite, warm, hospitable service. Standard Italian menu. The calamari starter was fresh and crisp. The Française, Cacciatore, and Marsala all hit the spot. 12” personal pizza was well made, good balance between crust and toppings, holds up well and offers a hearty bite.
Jan F.
Came here to celebrate my new job with my family...all 15 of us and this place did not disappoint! From the moment I stepped in to their party room, the big table was laid out so beautifully! I was so impressed and the staff were so friendly, especially Courtney who patiently waited for us! I'm so happy to have finally tried this place! We must've ordered everything on the menu and everything was delicious and fresh! Will definitely come back here to try the pizza next time! Our bellies are full! Thank you so much Nostro Posto for making my new career beginnings so wonderful! Even the sun came out after a big down pour!
Brent H.
First time eating here. Whenever I look for places I like to go to the ones that have the most ratings that are the highest (4-5 stars.) This place only had 61 ratings but sits at a 4-5 stars. After perusing the individual ratings I decided to come here. And I'm glad I did. I read really good things about the pizza so I got a regular slice of cheese. Forget about it -amazing. I thought I ordered pepperoni but I don't think I said it loud enough. I got a slice of cheese. I scarfed that down. We also got an order of calamari which was something else. The squid was so tender and fresh, like it was caught that day or something. I've never had it so tender. They know something that other restaurants don't because their calamari was absolutely amazing. I ordered a plate of pasta. Bolognese. I gotta say, I was disappointed with the bolognese. Usually, when the sauce to meat ratio is off there's not enough meat and too much sauce. This bolognese sauce -too much meat, not enough sauce. I had a couple bites and decided to take it home to doctor it up with some rao's sauce. I can get 2 good meals out of this no problem. Next time I know to stick with the pizza and stay away from the pasta. Now I know. They gave us focaccia flatbread which looked really nice. I'll be taking this with me as well. 4 out of 5 stars.
D. Abrams
Had dinner in the attractive dining room which currently is only open Fri-Sun. Mussels marinara in red sauce was delicious. Service very good.
Paul Fetscher
Lovely dining room and a wide assortment of good authentic Italian food.
Diana Rego
Great place and great food! Service was great and staff is very friendly. I'd recommend this place to anyone!
Jeff Smith
One of my favorite pizza spots. I always get sausage sliced pizza. It's always great.The service was excellent.COVID restrictions were followed.Indoor dining was allowed.
Anne K.
We decided to order tonight and it was so easy on their website. Told us when it would be ready for curbside pickup. Very easy. Only waiting a few minutes after we called to tell them we were there. I had the shrimp monachina. My favorite go to. I requested the shrimp not fried with no raisins. Just as i asked and enough for 2 meals. The fried calamari was lightly fried and soft. My husband had the shrimp marinara which was also delish. They have us plenty of bread and pasta with both dishes. They came out to the car and wouldn't even accept a tip. Great go to neighborhood charm.
Marisa Morgillo
This place is fantastic and very authentic !! I recently started joining my family there for dinner and love the indoor dining experience. The homemade gnocchi with the homemade pesto was so delicious. We ordered the stuffed artichoke on the specials and that was also amazing! Highly recommend the Buffalo chicken rolls too.
Jennifer Strong
Excellent pizza, had the Sicilian yesterday and again today and they were both very good. Can't wait to try other things from here.
NP came through with our catered order! They did a wonderful job, from packaging to serving size to delicious entres! Delivery was on time, courteous and safe. Don't hesitate to try them out if you haven't! Plainview's hidden gem is not so hidden anymore!
Jeff S.
One of favorite pizza places on Long Island. I went here maybe 8 years ago as I was hungry while shopping at Shoprite that was next door at the time. I was visiting my parents in NY at the time. I remember how great the pizza tasted. I remember trying to locate the pizza shop and didn't realize Lidl replaced Shoprite. I was in parking lot and investigating the pizza shop and thought it was familiar. I googled what was former tenant of Lidl space and realized that was the long lost pizza shop. This spot is still amazing.
Sharon Sieloff
Excellent food, excellent staff and excellent service. The best!!
Mark R.
Hidden gem ! Been in area for 5 years and for some reason never stopped in, went 2 weeks ago and been back 3 times since , great quality nice portions and pleasant wait staff. Highly recommend !
Large sit-down dining area in the back. Polite, warm, hospitable service. Standard Italian menu. The calamari starter was fresh and crisp. The Française, Cacciatore, and Marsala all hit the spot. 12” personal pizza was well made, good balance between crust and toppings, holds up well and offers a hearty bite.
Came here to celebrate my new job with my family...all 15 of us and this place did not disappoint! From the moment I stepped in to their party room, the big table was laid out so beautifully! I was so impressed and the staff were so friendly, especially Courtney who patiently waited for us! I'm so happy to have finally tried this place! We must've ordered everything on the menu and everything was delicious and fresh! Will definitely come back here to try the pizza next time! Our bellies are full! Thank you so much Nostro Posto for making my new career beginnings so wonderful! Even the sun came out after a big down pour!
First time eating here. Whenever I look for places I like to go to the ones that have the most ratings that are the highest (4-5 stars.) This place only had 61 ratings but sits at a 4-5 stars. After perusing the individual ratings I decided to come here. And I'm glad I did. I read really good things about the pizza so I got a regular slice of cheese. Forget about it -amazing. I thought I ordered pepperoni but I don't think I said it loud enough. I got a slice of cheese. I scarfed that down. We also got an order of calamari which was something else. The squid was so tender and fresh, like it was caught that day or something. I've never had it so tender. They know something that other restaurants don't because their calamari was absolutely amazing. I ordered a plate of pasta. Bolognese. I gotta say, I was disappointed with the bolognese. Usually, when the sauce to meat ratio is off there's not enough meat and too much sauce. This bolognese sauce -too much meat, not enough sauce. I had a couple bites and decided to take it home to doctor it up with some rao's sauce. I can get 2 good meals out of this no problem. Next time I know to stick with the pizza and stay away from the pasta. Now I know. They gave us focaccia flatbread which looked really nice. I'll be taking this with me as well. 4 out of 5 stars.
Had dinner in the attractive dining room which currently is only open Fri-Sun. Mussels marinara in red sauce was delicious. Service very good.
Lovely dining room and a wide assortment of good authentic Italian food.
Great place and great food! Service was great and staff is very friendly. I'd recommend this place to anyone!
One of my favorite pizza spots. I always get sausage sliced pizza. It's always great.The service was excellent.COVID restrictions were followed.Indoor dining was allowed.
We decided to order tonight and it was so easy on their website. Told us when it would be ready for curbside pickup. Very easy. Only waiting a few minutes after we called to tell them we were there. I had the shrimp monachina. My favorite go to. I requested the shrimp not fried with no raisins. Just as i asked and enough for 2 meals. The fried calamari was lightly fried and soft. My husband had the shrimp marinara which was also delish. They have us plenty of bread and pasta with both dishes. They came out to the car and wouldn't even accept a tip. Great go to neighborhood charm.
This place is fantastic and very authentic !! I recently started joining my family there for dinner and love the indoor dining experience. The homemade gnocchi with the homemade pesto was so delicious. We ordered the stuffed artichoke on the specials and that was also amazing! Highly recommend the Buffalo chicken rolls too.
Excellent pizza, had the Sicilian yesterday and again today and they were both very good. Can't wait to try other things from here.
Restaurantji Recommends
NP came through with our catered order! They did a wonderful job, from packaging to serving size to delicious entres! Delivery was on time, courteous and safe. Don't hesitate to try them out if you haven't! Plainview's hidden gem is not so hidden anymore!
One of favorite pizza places on Long Island. I went here maybe 8 years ago as I was hungry while shopping at Shoprite that was next door at the time. I was visiting my parents in NY at the time. I remember how great the pizza tasted. I remember trying to locate the pizza shop and didn't realize Lidl replaced Shoprite. I was in parking lot and investigating the pizza shop and thought it was familiar. I googled what was former tenant of Lidl space and realized that was the long lost pizza shop. This spot is still amazing.
Excellent food, excellent staff and excellent service. The best!!
Hidden gem ! Been in area for 5 years and for some reason never stopped in, went 2 weeks ago and been back 3 times since , great quality nice portions and pleasant wait staff. Highly recommend !
Good food & outstanding customer service.