Great NY-style pizza and friendly service. Plan on take-out and bring cash.
Herb Pipes
Best Pizza in town.
Donna Rinn
Had Hawaiian was awesome
Jared Tarbox
Plattsburgh’s Hidden Gem 🍕
If you’re craving amazing pizza in Plattsburgh, New York Pizza is the spot to go! From the second you walk in, you’re welcomed with friendly smiles and top-notch service. The owner and the staff are some of the kindest people around – they truly make you feel at home. ❤️
Now, let’s talk about that pizza... I recently ordered a large pineapple pizza for just $20, and wow – DELICIOUS! 🍍🍕 The crust was perfectly crispy, the toppings were fresh, and the sweet and savory combo was on point. Even if you’re not usually a pineapple fan, this pizza might just win you over!
Great prices, fantastic food, and service with a smile – what more could you ask for? If you haven’t tried New York Pizza yet, you’re missing out. Highly Recommend! 🔥🍕🙌
Shanna Maliniak
Hands down BEST pizza around! Owner is wonderful and friendly. Pizza is ALWAYS CONSISTENTLY DELICIOUS! My entire family will only order from here now and would give it a 10 if we could. Currently in Florida craving some now! Can't wait to get a pie when we return. ❤️
G
The best of the best this east of the Mississippi. The nicest people on earth with the nicest pie to match all for an unbeatable price. 11/10
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Classic White Pizza
Tracee
Best pizza in Plattsburgh. You must pick-up. They do not deliver or use food delivery services. They also only accept cash. It’s worth the minor inconveniences. SO GOOD!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Ryan Conard
How the do you even ORDER from here?!?!
No website. Phone number is usually busy or no one answers. They aren't associated with DoorDash for delivery. Parking CAN be a nightmare as they share parking with a laundry mat and if the lot is packed then you're walking.
I've driven by this place a lot and their open sign is usually left on all the time. Their signage is confusing as they advertise they have a deli and do sandwiches and stuff, but I called and asked about it once and the guy told me no, only pizza.
I've also confirmed they're CASH only ?♂️
I mean.. in this day and age, to be cash only is basically throwing away at least 20-30% of your business, and I feel like I'm being conservative here.
For all the "stellar reviews" this place has about how well the owner makes NYC style pizza, as he's been in the "pizza game" for many, many years, it's amazing how hard it is to even get your hands on a slice!
If you want pizza from this place, be prepared to DRIVE to the store (make sure they answer the phone are open first), hope you find a spot in the small lot behind the store and don't block one of the numerous ways to come in and out, and make sure you bring CASH otherwise you're walking to the ATM at the laundry mat to get money. Maybe the shop has one? Go figure they would. No credit card machine but they'll have an ATM so you can enjoy another $6 in fees to pull $20 out, right?
I've been WANTING to try this pizza for a while now, but the timing to stop in is never right and I NEVER have cash on me.
But I guess the owner doesn't care or need the business from card holders by simply getting a little SWIPE app/reader for his phone or something. It's not rocket science. And yea, there are transaction fees involved, but you can either EAT them to make customers or pass them on to the customer. Wanna use a credit card? Fine, it'll cost $1.25 extra. Ok.. whatever. That's crappy, but I'd rather pay THAT than go out of my way to find an ATM and pay ATM fees. It's common sense.
Also, OFFER DOORDASH!!! Again.. NOT a hard thing to get in to. It's commission based and simple to use for the local area and you just need an Android tablet to use the app to see your orders. Once you accept the order a DoorDash driver is on their way to you to grab the pizza and bring it to someone who wants to try it! Sounds wonderful to me.
Yannick Landreville
Very good For the Price ?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Don Bb
Absolutely love this place Bill is awesome. Makes some really great pizza. He really cares. I wish I was still up there. I would go every single week.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni and Sausage Pizza, Pepperoni Pizza Pie
Had my doubts about best pizza in Plattsburgh but after this veggie specialty pizza, hands down the best in town. Cooked & made to perfection, he definitely knows how to make & cook a true New York style pie. Will be our Friday special treat for the foreseeable future.
Food: 5
Service: 5
Tristan Kelleher
Best pie hands down in Plattsburgh, the guy is super friendly, and the food is super good. Authentic NYC Style pie. Crust is amazing. Cash only!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Amber Averill
I have heard nothing but positive things about this establishment so decided to try it out for the first time this evening. Placed an order for a pepperoni pizza. The gentleman was very pleasant on the phone and in person. I honestly would have to say that it was the best pizza that I have ever had. Homemade dough, pizza sauce, fresh cheese and toppings. Lots of cheese, sauce, and pepperoni cooked just right. The price was decent. I found my go to place for pizza.
Great NY-style pizza and friendly service. Plan on take-out and bring cash.
Best Pizza in town.
Had Hawaiian was awesome
Plattsburgh’s Hidden Gem 🍕
If you’re craving amazing pizza in Plattsburgh, New York Pizza is the spot to go! From the second you walk in, you’re welcomed with friendly smiles and top-notch service. The owner and the staff are some of the kindest people around – they truly make you feel at home. ❤️
Now, let’s talk about that pizza... I recently ordered a large pineapple pizza for just $20, and wow – DELICIOUS! 🍍🍕 The crust was perfectly crispy, the toppings were fresh, and the sweet and savory combo was on point. Even if you’re not usually a pineapple fan, this pizza might just win you over!
Great prices, fantastic food, and service with a smile – what more could you ask for? If you haven’t tried New York Pizza yet, you’re missing out. Highly Recommend! 🔥🍕🙌
Hands down BEST pizza around! Owner is wonderful and friendly. Pizza is ALWAYS CONSISTENTLY DELICIOUS! My entire family will only order from here now and would give it a 10 if we could. Currently in Florida craving some now! Can't wait to get a pie when we return. ❤️
The best of the best this east of the Mississippi. The nicest people on earth with the nicest pie to match all for an unbeatable price. 11/10
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Classic White Pizza
Best pizza in Plattsburgh. You must pick-up. They do not deliver or use food delivery services. They also only accept cash. It’s worth the minor inconveniences. SO GOOD!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
How the do you even ORDER from here?!?!
No website. Phone number is usually busy or no one answers. They aren't associated with DoorDash for delivery. Parking CAN be a nightmare as they share parking with a laundry mat and if the lot is packed then you're walking.
I've driven by this place a lot and their open sign is usually left on all the time. Their signage is confusing as they advertise they have a deli and do sandwiches and stuff, but I called and asked about it once and the guy told me no, only pizza.
I've also confirmed they're CASH only ?♂️
I mean.. in this day and age, to be cash only is basically throwing away at least 20-30% of your business, and I feel like I'm being conservative here.
For all the "stellar reviews" this place has about how well the owner makes NYC style pizza, as he's been in the "pizza game" for many, many years, it's amazing how hard it is to even get your hands on a slice!
If you want pizza from this place, be prepared to DRIVE to the store (make sure they answer the phone are open first), hope you find a spot in the small lot behind the store and don't block one of the numerous ways to come in and out, and make sure you bring CASH otherwise you're walking to the ATM at the laundry mat to get money. Maybe the shop has one? Go figure they would. No credit card machine but they'll have an ATM so you can enjoy another $6 in fees to pull $20 out, right?
I've been WANTING to try this pizza for a while now, but the timing to stop in is never right and I NEVER have cash on me.
But I guess the owner doesn't care or need the business from card holders by simply getting a little SWIPE app/reader for his phone or something. It's not rocket science. And yea, there are transaction fees involved, but you can either EAT them to make customers or pass them on to the customer. Wanna use a credit card? Fine, it'll cost $1.25 extra. Ok.. whatever. That's crappy, but I'd rather pay THAT than go out of my way to find an ATM and pay ATM fees. It's common sense.
Also, OFFER DOORDASH!!! Again.. NOT a hard thing to get in to. It's commission based and simple to use for the local area and you just need an Android tablet to use the app to see your orders. Once you accept the order a DoorDash driver is on their way to you to grab the pizza and bring it to someone who wants to try it! Sounds wonderful to me.
Very good For the Price ?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Absolutely love this place Bill is awesome. Makes some really great pizza. He really cares. I wish I was still up there. I would go every single week.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni and Sausage Pizza, Pepperoni Pizza Pie
Restaurantji Recommends
THE best pizza in Plattsburgh.
The only good pizza in Plattsburgh!
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 5
Service: 5
Had my doubts about best pizza in Plattsburgh but after this veggie specialty pizza, hands down the best in town. Cooked & made to perfection, he definitely knows how to make & cook a true New York style pie. Will be our Friday special treat for the foreseeable future.
Food: 5
Service: 5
Best pie hands down in Plattsburgh, the guy is super friendly, and the food is super good. Authentic NYC Style pie. Crust is amazing. Cash only!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I have heard nothing but positive things about this establishment so decided to try it out for the first time this evening. Placed an order for a pepperoni pizza. The gentleman was very pleasant on the phone and in person. I honestly would have to say that it was the best pizza that I have ever had. Homemade dough, pizza sauce, fresh cheese and toppings. Lots of cheese, sauce, and pepperoni cooked just right. The price was decent. I found my go to place for pizza.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Loading...