The Pepper Cantina & Mexican Eatery

13 City Hall Pl, Plattsburgh
(518) 566-4688

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Damien Schrull

Amazing‼️ Had both specials last night and they absolutely blow me away. Very attentive wait staff, great drinks, and a fun family friendly environment. Will be back, hungry for more‼️

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Kathleen Backlas

I’ve been 3 times since they’ve opened. Delicious food and great drinks. Love the chips and salsa as well!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

COLBY weaver

Love the jalapeño popper dip

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Thomas Diman

Had the enchiladas with the green sauce and it was fantastic, wonderful flavor. The Popper dip was killer as our appetizer. Son got the Birria Racos and also just fantastic Flavor. Wife got the Stuffed Peppers ( Chili Rellenos ) and also just great. The servings are large, the flavors are on point...Definitely worth it for Real Mexican flavors.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Sonny Giroux

Amazing service from such a great staff! The jalapeño margaritas are incredible!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Ryan Lynch

Top notch staff, excellent beverages and delicious food. No better cuisine further from the border.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Patricia MacMannis

We miss the old menu, especially the soup and asparagus and chicken enchiladas. The bar service was slow and the margaritas were not up to their usual standards. We'll try it again, but they should consider adding former favorites back on the menu.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 3

Service: 3

Hanleys Cigar Box Guitars Hanleys Cigar Box Guitars

Highly recommend The Pepper! Great food, Drinks, and super staff!! You won’t be disappointed!

Jackie Bill Allan

so my wife and I went tonight Thursday 9/18/25. We ordered Cadillac Rita's but the bartender ( not Glenn) used tequila and triple sec, should have been tequila, grand marnia, and cointreau per the recipe on the menu. Pointed it out to our server who offered to have them redone but we declined and drank them anyway. Our server Aryana, was awesome and apologized repeatedly. I ordered Carne arsada fajitas. the meal came out and the steak looked awesome done perfectly medium but one bite and I had to spit it out. my god it tasted spoiled and had no seasoning. I sent it back and didn't order anything else. My wife's dinner was OK but just ok. We were sooo disappointed to say the least. In fairness my wife ordered another Cadillac Rita and the second one was made per the recipe, I just ordered a beer. I am not writing this to be a jerk but in hopes that the owners see they have some issues that need to be fixed. I hope they fix it. long story short I spent $ 70 and went home to eat a bologna sandwich.

Taylor Boomhover

the birria tacos sadly disappointing. I ordered no onions and got onions and no side sauce but the shell and everything doesn't even compare to the new El Dorado. Glen is still awesome but this place is not what it was. Even the premixed margaritas are better at El Dorado then the fresh ones here. my husband was disappointed that the previous purple sauce that was used on burritos in the past wasn't being used and said it was just falling flat compared to how the pepper use to be. You took the best Mexican restaurant and closed it and failed to meet its mark. If you're gonna change the menu, the food, especially the banging queso that the OG had, change the name. If I didn't know it changed hands and came to try the new one, id be more upset. just an all around completely unsatisfying experience.

Loading...

The Pepper Cantina & Mexican Eatery

13 City Hall Pl, Plattsburgh, NY 12901
(518) 566-4688