Benny's Pizza
18 W Rd, Pleasant Valley
(845) 723-4482
Customers' Favorites
Chicken Bacon with Ranch Dressing
Sausage and Pepper Roll
Large Pepperoni Pizza
Pepperoni Pizza Slice
Buffalo Chicken Pizza
Chicken Bacon Ranch
Calzone Family Size
Gluten Free Pizza
Mozzarella Sticks
Chicken Wings 12
Appetizers
Fried Calamari
Mozzarella Sticks
6 pieces. Served with marinara.
Chicken Wings (6) and Fries
6 pieces. Served with bleu cheese.
Garlic Knots
Bella's favorite. 6 pieces. Served with marinara.
Chicken Quesadilla and Fries
Steak Quesadilla and Fries
Focaccia Bread
Baked Clams
Chicken Fingers and Fries
Boneless wings (12)
Chicken wings (12)
Garlic Bread
Garlic Bread with Cheese
Fried Zucchini
Beef Patty
Fried Shrimp
12 Fresh jumbo wings
Flavors BBQ mild Buffalo
8 pcs fresh jumbo chicken wings and fries
15 fresh jumbo chicken wings
20 fresh jumbo chicken wings
Garlic knots with cheese
Salads
Garden Salad
Iceberg lettuce, tomatoes, cucumbers, carrots, olive and onions.
Chef Salad
Bella's favorite.
Caesar Salad
Green salad with Caesar dressing and cheese.
Antipasto Salad
Traditional Italian salad.
Fresh Mozzarella Salad
Buffalo chicken salad
Mixed greens, crispy chicken tossed in a delicious Buffalo sauce.
Soups
Pasta e Fagioli Soup
Soup made with pasta and beans.
Chicken Noodle Soup
Soup that is made with chicken, broth, noodles, and vegetables.
Minestrone Soup
Hearty vegetable soup.
Lentil Soup
Savory legume soup.
Cheese Tortellini Soup
Soup with ring shaped stuffed pasta.
zuppa di frutti di mare
Sandwiches
Ham and Cheese Sandwich
Ham, cheese, lettuce, tomatoes and mayo.
Turkey Sandwich
Turkey breast with bacon, shredded lettuce, tomatoes and mayo.
Italian Combo Sandwich
Bella's favorite. Ham, salami, prosciutto, provolone, lettuce, tomatoes, roasted red peppers, oil and vinegar.
Chicken bacon ranch
Wedges
Chicken Parmigiana Wedge
Meatball Parmigiana Wedge
Sausage Parmigiana Wedge
Sausage and Pepper Parmigiana Wedge
Shrimp Parmigiana Wedge
Eggplant Parmigiana Wedge
Grilled Chicken Wedge
Lettuce, tomatoes and mayo.
Chicken Francese Wedge
Bella's favorite. Served on garlic bread.
Chicken Cutlet Wedge
Fried chicken, lettuce, tomatoes and mayo.
Chicken Marsala Wedge
Philly Cheesesteak Wedge
Peppers, onions, mushrooms and melted American cheese.
Veal Parmigiana Wedge
Potatoes and Eggs Wedge
Peppers and Eggs Wedge
Buffalo chicken wedge
Wraps
Chicken Bacon Ranch Wrap
Bella's favorite. Crispy chicken, bacon, ranch, cheddar, lettuce and tomatoes.
Turkey and Cheese Wrap
Lettuce, tomatoes, mayo and American cheese.
Grilled Chicken Caesar Wrap
Buffalo Chicken Wrap
Crispy chicken tossed in Buffalo sauce with lettuce, tomatoes and bleu cheese.
Philly cheesesteaks wrap
Italian combo wrap
Veggie wrap
Sauté broccoli spinach & eggplant
Pasta
Spaghetti with Marinara
Long thing pasta.
Spaghetti with Garlic and Oil
Long thing pasta.
Spaghetti with Meatballs
Long thing pasta.
Spaghetti with Sausage
Long thing pasta.
Cappellini Primavera
Red or white sauce, angel hair with vegetables sauteed in garlic and olive oil.
Penne a la Vodka
Narrow tube shaped pasta.
Penne a la Rosa
Bella's favorite. Chicken breast with broccoli in a light pink sauce.
Fettuccine Alfredo
Creamy white sauce, salt, pepper with grated cheese.
Spaghetti Caprese
Long thing pasta.
Tortellini Carbonara
Tortellini in a creamy bacon, onion and Romano cheese sauce.
Gluten-Free Ravioli
Gluten-Free Penne a la Vodka
Narrow tube shaped pasta.
Rigatoni with pesto sauce
Pasta al Forno
Baked Ziti
Smooth tube shaped pasta.
Baked Manicotti
Baked Ravioli
Meat Lasagna
Bella's favorite.
Stuffed Shells
Ziti Sorrentino
Eggplant, ricotta and mozzarella.
Ziti Siciliana
Meat sauce with ricotta and mozzarella.
Dinners
Chicken Marsala
Sauteed mushrooms and Marsala wine.
Veal Marsala
Sauteed mushrooms and Marsala wine.
Chicken Francese
Veal Francese
Chicken Parmigiana
Breaded chicken breast, house-made tomato sauce and melted mozzarella.
Veal Parmigiana
Breaded veal, house-made tomato sauce and melted mozzarella.
Eggplant Parmigiana
Breaded eggplant, house-made tomato sauce and melted mozzarella.
Chicken Scarpariello
Bella's favorite.
Chicken Sorrentino
Served with eggplant and prosciutto in a rich tomato sauce and melted mozzarella.
Veal Sorrentino
Served with eggplant and prosciutto in a rich tomato sauce and melted mozzarella.
Chicken Piccata
Sauteed in artichoke, capers, lemon and white wine sauce.
Chicken Cacciatrore
Grilled Chicken
Served with broccoli rabe, garlic and oil.
Sausage and Peppers
Eggplant Rollatini
Seafood
Shrimp Parmigiana
Shrimp Scampi
Shrimp sauteed in garlic butter and white wine sauce.
Shrimp Francese
Battered shrimp in a lemon butter and white wine sauce.
Seafood Fra Diablo
Bella's favorite. Shrimp, clams and mussels in a spicy marinara served over linguine.
Zappa di pesce
A mixture of shrimp, calamari, scallops and clams
Sole Francese
Salmon Piccata
Salmon sauteed in lemon, butter, white wine, garlic and capers.
Seafood Pasta
Shrimp, clams and mussels in a pink herbed cream sauce over linguine.
Linguine with Clam Sauce
Red or white sauce, sauteed clams with garlic, parsley and olive oil over linguine.
Salmon Francese
Shrimp fra Diablo
Mussels Marinara
Pizzas
Personal 12" Pizza
Small 14" Pizza
6 slices.
Large 16" Pizza
8 slices.
House 24" Pizza
12 slices.
Sicilian Pizza
8 slices.
Gluten Free 12" Pizza
Cauliflower Crust 10" Pizza
Gluten-free.
Deep dish pizza 16 inch
Deep dish 18 inch pizza
Toppings are extra charge
Specialty Pizzas
White Pizza
Ricotta, mozzarella and oregano.
Meat Lovers Pizza
Sausage, pepperoni and meatballs.
Primavera Pizza
Broccoli, spinach and tomatoes.
Salad Pizza
Mesclun and iceberg lettuce, carrots, tomatoes, cucumbers and olives drizzled with olive oil.
Tortellini Carbonara Pizza
Tortellini with bacon in a light pink cream sauce.
Penne a la Vodka Pizza
Penne with prosciutto in a light pink cream sauce.
Margherita Pizza
Tomato sauce, fresh mozzarella and basil.
Chicken Marsala Pizza
Diced chicken sauteed with mushrooms, onions and Marsala wine.
Chicken Scarpariello Pizza
Bella's favorite.
Buffalo Chicken Pizza
Diced crispy chicken tossed with hot sauce, mozzarella and bleu cheese.
Chicken Cacciatore Pizza
Bella's favorite.
Chicken Francese Pizza
Bella's Supreme Pizza
Sausage, pepperoni, peppers, onions and mushrooms.
Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza
Crispy chicken with crumbled bacon, mozzarella and ranch dressing.
BBQ Chicken Pizza
Chicken tossed in BBQ sauce with mozzarella.
Chicken Parmigiana Pizza
Breaded chicken breast, mozzarella and sauce.
Philly Cheesesteak Pizza
Philly steak with mushrooms, peppers, onions, American and mozzarella cheese.
Hawaiian Pizza
Bacon, ham, pineapple and mozzarella.
Pesto Pizza
Sliced tomatoes, mozzarella and pesto sauce.
Veggie Pizza
Broccoli, peppers, spinach and onions.
Grandma Pizza
Stuffed Pizza
Large stuffed pizza with meatballs, sausage and pepperoni
Grandpa Pie
Broccoli Rab and Sausage with Maredra on top
The Brooklyn Pie Pizza
Thin square crust , mozzarella cheese , garlic , oregano , black pepper , red pepper flakes , grated cheese and lined marinara
California pizza
Square thin crust
Tomatoes bacon ranch
MUNDOS FOCACCIA PIZZA
Pepperoni sweet peppers red onions
Spicy chicken
Chicken Alfredo
Chicken cutle & broccoli with Alfredo sauces
Square thin crust pizza
Vodka sauce fresh mozzarella & basil
Calzones and Rolls
Cheese Calzone
Ricotta and mozzarella.
Meat Calzone
Bella's favorite. Meatball and pepperoni.
Pepperoni Roll
Chicken Roll
Eggplant Roll
Buffalo Chicken Roll
Spinach Roll
Broccoli Roll
Gluten-Free Cheese Calzone
Stromboli Mix
Ham, salami, pepperoni, American cheese and mozzarella cheese.
Cheese slice
Buffalo chicken slice
White slice
Chicken Marsala slice
Lasagna slice
Chicken bacon ranch slice
Grandma slice
Pepperoni slice
Sausage slice
Mushroom slice
Ham & cheese roll
Kids Menu
Kids 3 Chicken Fingers and Fries
Kids 3 Chicken Wings & Fries
Kids Chicken Parm and Pasta
Kids Chicken Francese Over Pasta
Kids Spaghetti and Meatball
Kids Spaghetti and Marinara
Kids Spaghetti and Butter
Kids- Penne a la Vodka
Narrow tube shaped pasta.
Kids- Fettuccine Alfredo
Side Orders
Broccoli Rabe
Spinach, Garlic and Oil
Broccoli, Garlic and Oil
French Fries
Meatballs
Sausage
Onion Rings
Curly fries
Fríes with cheese
Desserts
Cannoli
Bella's favorite.
Cheesecake
Tiramisu
Zeppoli
Gluten-Free Lava Cake
Fried Nutella calzone
Fried calzone with Nutella inside and powder sugar on top.
Carrot cake
Mini Nutella calzone
Drinks
20oz. Pepsi
20oz. Diet Pepsi
20oz. Cream Soda
20oz. Orange Soda
2L Pepsi
20oz. Root Beer
2L Ginger Ale
2L Orange Soda
2L Root Beer
2L Diet Pepsi
Can soda
Pepsi orange ginger ale root beer
Pure Leaf Tea
16oz. Water
Mexican coke glass
C4 energy drink
Red bull
Special
Chicken over pasta
Choise
Chicken Marsala
Chicken Frances
Chicken picata
Chicken parmigiana
1-large cheese pie 12–wings 2 liter of soda
Flavor-mild Bbq Buffalo
1-Large pie 1- penne allá vodka 1-2liter
2-large cheese pie 6pcs mozzarella sticks 1-2liter
2 wedges 2 can soda
Choise
Chicken parm
Meatballs parm
Sausage pepper parm
Shipm parm
2 wraps with fries 2 can soda
Choise
Buffalo chicken
Chicken bacon ranch
Grill chicken Caesar
2 pizza rolls 2 can soda
Choise
Buffalo chicken
Chicken cutle
Pepperoni
Sausage and pepper chicken Marsala
2 cheese slices 2 can soda
Photos
+43 photos
+42 photos
Add a photo
Recent Reviews
First time here as I am just in the area for a day. I had two regular slices and they were fantastic! The crust was crisp and just the perfect amount of cheese, sauce, spices and oil! Unfortunately, I am just here for the day and will not be able to enjoy this pizzeria as much as I'd like to. I live in Westchester county and work in NYC, and I must say that given my location and availability of great pizzerias, Benny's Pizza is one of my favorites, if not my favorite!
August 2025
Got a pie and garlic knots, as a city girl I was impressed. I wanted to try pizza from the state, see how it held up to city pizza. Pizza was very good and can definitely hold up to city pizza.
July 2025
After running around all day, I did not feel like going home to cook. I’ve been wanting to try Benny’s Pizza, but I always get nervous trying new places because I get comfortable where I go. I’m really glad I decided to try them out. The employee who took my order over the phone was very sweet, the staff acknowledged me as soon as I walked in the restaurant to pick up my food, and I was in & out in a few minutes. I feel their prices are appropriate and in line with other...
May 2025
You May Also Like
The Bar on West & Main - 18 W Rd
![]()
Cocktail Bar, Soup
Beijing Chef - 17 North Ave
![]()
Chinese
Madison's Pizza & Catering - 17 North Ave
![]()
Pizza, Italian, Vegetarian