Mario's Pizza

186 Broadway, Port Ewen
(845) 338-1157

Recent Reviews

the gargamel

This has to be the worst place to order a slice of pizza. Young staff who doesn’t know what they are doing. Pizza was cold and soggy. I had to ask for a refund. Stay away from this dump.

андрей захаров

I always arrive grabbing some food in this place. I like the efficient service and well prepared dishes. Never disappointing.

Psychic_ Kaylee

I'm 31. been eating here since I was was 5 years old..they are great people with great food still.

Sabrina Tarantino

This is the second time I’ve ordered a pizza and this time didn’t get it at all—the last time I had to call and remind them that I ordered. Not good enough food for a third chance smh

andrewsX4240RJ

Try the Meat Balls...any of the Pizzas...Stuffed Shells...and everything on the menu. I have been eating here many years and never had a bad experience.

Kaylee Arceri

I'm 31. been eating here since I was was 5 years old..they are great people with great food still.

Tim Thomas

Pizza slices were excellent. Young guy taking order was very helpful giving directions as we are out of towners.

Andres Vialpando

This unassuming pizzeria serves up the best NY style pizza in the entire area. If you are craving pizza it's exactly what you want.

Scott Cuthell

Best pizza in the Hudson Valley hands down. For classic New York Style Pizza Mario's can't be beat. In addition to the great pizza the staff is very friendly, the dining area is always spotless, and currently they have a carry-out window that make's picking up an order easy and safe.

John Lavin

Unfortunately I have to move away soon but I love this place. After work there was no better place to find a good hot meal then Mario's. I'm going to miss Port Ewen especially living so close to a piece of place.

Chastity Jaffer

I called for a pick up order, 1 pizza and 2 subs, I was told 40 min. I arrive in about 20 because I was already that far away and that’s normal pizza time 20 - 30 minutes. I wait for 1 hour there and when I ask for my money back, my order is ready. I get home, meatball parm sub is soggy wet, no cheese on it at all, the Italian mix is meat, mayo and tomato, not what I asked for. The pizza is brown on edges but cheese is not completely melted or to the edge of crust ice cold Total waste of my time and money, never ever again. I have been there in the past and it was pretty good but it has gone down hill.

Austin Benjamin

A true staple of Port Ewen! Marios has great pizza serving regular gluten free, cauliflower, and everything in between. All their food is amazing but even if they only served ramen noodles I would still eat there because Sue, her family and staff are amazing people always putting others first. High Recommend

Kirsten Miller

Love Mario’s!!! The have great pizza and the service is tops!

Butterfly June BERARD

Yesterday, I went to get a slice of sausage pizza and the guy handed me a cheese pizza and just caught the sausage in laid it on top of the pizza and gave it to me uncooked. I am very unhappy, and I will never go back order food there again.

Carrie Bono

Mario’s is an original hometown favorite. Every pizza expected including white vegetarian and Sicilian.. Indulge in fresh authentic Italian treats made from family recipes. The best cannolis filled fresh & crisp Such reasonable pricing for catering trays and the super subs. Your always welcome and these are just the best people on earth !

Load More